I've finally been able to pull myself from Cyrodiil to post these late impressions. OMFG Hot Damn WOW!! If you have ever played any kind of pen and paper RPG this is the virtual incarnation of it. So open ended, from selecting quests to how you can complete them. Out of this series I've only played morrowind for a few days, didn't like it because of the draw distance. It held back the epic feel for me when I could only see 40 yards in front of me. But this, is just massive, I can see for miles, and the only fog is when its about to rain.
The only drawback I've had is the same I've had for any pen and paper RPG. First time character creation can be daunting, since you are not sure what skills and attributes can be useful. The balance of the game has allowed me to feel that any character played smartly can do well, so I've not hat too much first character regret in this game.
I'm sure this thread has tons of similar impressions so I'll just give some feed back on my technical experience with the 360. I've played on a VGA monitor and through S-video. On the monitor it looks un-believable, it will display full screen if you choose 1280 x 1024. Its appears to be a hair smoother at 1280 x 768. Using 480i through S-video it appears the textures have been down graded, the grass looks jaggier than on the Monitor, but it is also very close to 30fps locked. It looks much smoother on the TV. The pop in of the grass and shrubs in all versions is very smooth so it is not jarring at all. Some pop in occurs with buildings or anything during rapid turn arounds occurs on rare occasions. My 360 has the hard drive, and the NOW LOADING text is brief and become rather rare as time has gone by in the game. Hoo Ray for caching. I have not played a game this much in years, I've put in 20 hours since Tuesday, and I could only play for two hours yesterday. This is one of the best western RPGs ever made, the design and depth is fantastic. If you have a good PC or a 360 and have ever in you life been into D&D, buy this game NOW!
Thank you for your time, now back to goblin hunting.