Joel never uses one, and I think given Ellie's experience, I don't like the idea of her holding one looking all calm and collected on a cover.I just think it's a bit generic. Like, for some reason I'd actually prefer if Ellie or Joel was holding a machete.
I don't particularly like the new cover, I don't think it does a good job of evoking the game's tone or anything, but it is interesting to see Ellie retain her prominent position on the cover. I liked that she took center-stage in the first cover, especially as it seemed contradictory to all the Irrational Games talk at the time of Infinite's cover reveal. I wondered if her placement was relating to how they saw the relative importance of the characters, but I was doubtful it was anything other than coincidence, but this cover is a lot more clearly emphasizing Ellie, which is cool.