About 6 hours in sp and played a bit of mp. The story is very good, but this is not a fun game to play. It's not terrible, but the clickers are just a chore to fight. The need to play stealth almost all the time is kind of a slog too. I find myself enjoying the game most when Joel and Ellie are just walking around talking. I'll stick with it. Kinda surprised at the seemingly unanimous love though.
I have to agree with this. I'm probably 6 or 7 hours in. 90% of the game for me is running around, searching any corner for literally anything, since ammo is so scarce. Gunplay is what you'd expect, but melee combat is pretty bad and janky. Melee is just mashing square until you can smash an enemy against a wall. There's no way to deal with multiple enemies in melee combat.
Stealth mechanics are pretty lame too. It just amounts to staying crouched all the time, avoiding sight lines and doing silent takedowns. The only other stealth mechanic I'm aware of is distracting enemies using bottles.
The game doesn't do a good job of explaining things either and so much has to be learned through trial and error. So clickers can't be defeated with hand to hand combat, ok fine. I then discover I can kill them with a brick... but it wasn't until several failed attempts later that I realize this must only be possible when they're not aware of you. It's not explained or even logical.
It's definitely the most cinematic game I've ever played and I'm sure the story is wonderful, but I don't think it's a very fun game. I enjoyed Uncharted much more (although I think even Uncharted is pretty overrated). If I still had the Destiny Beta right now I would be playing that instead...