Rented the Nikon 85 1.4D and the new 70-200 f/4.
Hot damn. Can't decide which I want more. Leaning towards the 1.4, cause 1.4.
The f/4 is fantastic though. Really surprised at how well the VR works. I was getting acceptable results at very low shutter speeds (on static objects OFC). Really sharp, really fast and solid focus.
200mm f/4 1/160 handheld:
The 1.4 however is something special. Somewhat difficult to use, it will often trick the meter and focus system. Everything needs to click for it to work properly, but when it does... oh my.
vs. the newer G version I can't see much difference. I think the focus might hit a little more on target due to the AFS motor. For roughly half the price and a aperture ring for video/film though I think I will go with old version.
Bonus:
Short video of my kids shot with D600 + 85 1.4D