• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Trump: 'Fine' with trying US citizens in military courts

Status
Not open for further replies.

Link Man

Banned
qIxPDS4.jpg
 
Yo, this guy is a real know nothing. He really does sound like he would be akin to some kind of dictator as President, and would constantly place our entire country in danger where foreign policy is concerned.

This guy as President would literally just be winging it out there.
 

MetatronM

Unconfirmed Member
This guy as President would literally just be winging it out there.
This is the thing here. It's not like this is a nuanced and thought out policy decision. This is an answer he gave on the spot, because that's what he does and that's about the extent of the thought he puts into it. At the most, his thought process was "does this make me sound tough?"
 

rambis

Banned
Im so confused. I wasnt even aware this was a thing in the first place. How would this even work? Civillians are now subject to UCMJ action?
 

davepoobond

you can't put a price on sparks
Im so confused. I wasnt even aware this was a thing in the first place. How would this even work? Civillians are now subject to UCMJ action?


it wouldnt work. US civilians aren't subject to military court except if they are in the military or possibly a combatant. its a violation of due process and probably a whole bunch of other things
 

Ushojax

Should probably not trust the 7-11 security cameras quite so much
Do you think Trump would be able to name the 3 branches of government and their basic elements? I don't think he would.
 

AstroLad

Hail to the KING baby
Do you think Trump would be able to name the 3 branches of government and their basic elements? I don't think he would.

No, his entire knowledge base seems to be just from whatever's on wingnut media. He'd deflect by starting with "the courts" and go into a diatribe over "liberal judges" and never move on from that.
 

MoxManiac

Member
If be some horrid chance this idiot becomes president, could he even make something like that happen?

It's terrifying to think about.
 

devilhawk

Member
Citizens being tried in military tribunals would be pretty bad.

Though it is still more due process than a citizen getting a drone strike up their ass.
 

Sean C

Member
If be some horrid chance this idiot becomes president, could he even make something like that happen?
No. American citizens cannot be tried in military court unless they're actually part of the military. They'd otherwise be subject to a petition of habeas corpus by the civilian courts. Also, only Congress can suspend habeas corpus, and only in places in the US where the civil courts are not functioning; that would prevent anybody arrested on American soil for terrorism from being tried by the military.
 
Citizens being tried in military tribunals would be pretty bad.

Though it is still more due process than a citizen getting a drone strike up their ass.

Your comment is pretty loaded. It's like saying that an armed robber didn't get due process because they were shot while firing at police. You only get due process if you are caught and under control. I 100% believe that people should be tried in civilian, open court for terrorism charges. But if they are on the battlefield in a foreign country and openly fighting the US (or whomever), then they are fair target for similar military response.
 

Jacobi

Banned
So this is super disturbing even though Bush tried non-citizens, which is pretty much more disturbing because ???
 
Trump doesn't even know what he's talking about. He's dumb as rocks and is way less informed than gaf users on just about everything governing related.
 
Because it's not going to happen.

It will happen, it won't be a debate.

He has no choice, this isn't an issue like tax returns.

OT: You guys are just twisting his words, he isn't a politician, you need to listen to the entire context of what he was saying and that fine is an acronym.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom