I'm curious as to whether or not people think Wesker was OP in vanilla as well?
Because he's really no better than he was in that game, and no one really considered him OP in that game. It really seemed that the general consensus in vanilla was that Phoenix and Wolverine were the only OP characters. There's a difference between a "strong" or "good" character and an overpowered character.
Also, looks like Evil Rahsaan will play the game for a few months again and then quit because he's still not going to win anything with Spider-Man.
To give some background, I have been a Wesker player since day 1, before I the game was released, before I knew he was good...
That being said -- people who want to nerf him are the same people that wanted Sentinel nerfed. In reality, he has some really bad matchups. Zero, Wolverine, and X23 destroy him FREE in close quarters. Trish and other keepaway characters can keep him away all day. Hell, now that I main Doom, I feel that Dr.Doom has an advantage against Wesker. (if you do finger lasers, beam, missiles, super jump air finger lasers, foot dive -- Wesker has a hell of a time getting in)
Like Viscant said, for low level play, he is a problem. Since he does not have a tracking teleport, he does not have a good way to control the air. I have had good players with characters such as (Magneto, Storm, Doom, Trish, etc) waste my entire XF lvl3 by running away...
Phoenix needed to be nerfed because she had no bad matchups and could reverse OCV a team for free. Wesker can reverse OCV a team if you panic/or are a scrub... (I have been reverse OCV'ed also), but that doesn't make me want to nerf him.
IMHO, I think that fucking Spencer is the OP character. If they nerf Wesker, everyone will jump to Spencer -- I gaurantee it. He has a higher execution requirement, which is why people are not on him. But please, someone tell me... who else can do near 1million damage with no xfactor (ie touch of death combos) with no assists? Who can else can completely cut off your escape/jump options by himself? (with that fucking horizontal grapple). Who else has a high priority ambigious crossup that option selects into a throw? When fighting against a good Spencer, he seems like a god tier character...
And this is my point, I can probably make the same argument about a few other characters in the game. When will the calls to nerfs stop? Lets make everyone do shitty damage and then we can have a boring ass game like SSFIV where it takes a hundred hits to kill someone and everyone stares at each other for 30 seconds of the match.
End of rant.
PS. I loved Vanilla SFIV and I absolutely loathe SSFIV and AE... so goddamn boring.