I'm gonna have a massive response to Mazre's posts now, since I'm finally at a house and can type better (I have no clue how you mobile users do it).
Coppa's text in bold
You've been extremely quiet since Boo died. You brought up how early on his death was then disappeared into the shadow. You didn't even really react with shock
That's quite the narrative. The majority of the time since Boo's death I've either been asleep, at work, or somewhere in between. The measure of my reaction seems completely subjective especially since you're interpreting based solely on text.
Who do you think killed him?
Don't have a strong lead here, Ferret seems overly obvious, but other than that it feels pretty wide open to me, I probably need to reread with a focus on Booboo'n
What alignment are they?
neutral/scum seem most likely; as above I need to double check on booboo'n but nothing is jumping to mind that he's done to draw a town kill to himself
Are they still a threat or not?
If we feel it's a one-shot ability then, no. Following this a little further a one-shot neutral seems unlikely, this would lean me more towards scum. This then takes us to why Boo and why now?
If it's not one shot, it's absolutely a threat. This could go either neutral or scum in my mind and further muddies our analysis as it gives less weight to Boo's death in the grand scheme.
1) Yup, everything is interpreted text, tis the problem with forum mafia. Anyhow, that was more of why I was asking you questions (I realize you've been asleep, since the range of your posts suggested it).
2) Fair enough, nothing too suspect here since that's a pretty standard guess. I'm not really sure where I stand on Ferret doing it or not right now myself.
3) Again, not too surprising. Another pretty logical guess and about what anyone would say.
4) Ahh you brought up one-shot use! And you bring up the irrationality of it all again, which is the part that gets me. The problem is I can't see why a day kill ability would be used so early regardless of which team is using it.
Again, Coppa in bold
Who should we lynch?
I still like Setre as an option, Trigger seems like a possibility (more on this after Coppa's queries), I want to go over Ferret's and Scrafty's posts again as well prior to the end of the phase ; None of these are exceptionally strong reads but that's part in parcel for day 2
Who's acting different than Day 1?
On the whole most everyone feels fairly consistent, no major aberrations in my mind at least. Behavior in the early game is kind of hard to keep track of when we've got 20 people to keep an eye on.
Why did you go "Oh hey Boo died early!" then run off and not post again.
Double skillup event overlapping with Mihawk event in OPTC japanese version
5) Fair enough, I'll respond more on Trigger since you mention him down below and there's more to discuss there. I like your read list, and I like that you included someone who isn't on a lot of people's minds in Setre. I'm curious if anything he said in response to my questions jumped out at you?
6) Very true, and the lack of major changes is going to make this a bit harder for now, but worth asking for sure.
7) Alrighty then. I'm willing to take that and the time being your reason for not really responding immediately, though it still does seem odd to not have any ideas back then.
I'm breaking the next into 2 parts since there's actually 2 things I want to discuss. First is Trigger (I'm grouping both your Trigger statements here from the start and end of your post):
So I mentioned Trigger in my previous post as possible lynch today. I decided to compare my previous days reads and the final d1 votes.
Trigger has had a handful of mistatements, and odd comments. He's pretty consistently pushed the narrative on mike today citing a fairly simple interpretation of booboo'n's death that would seem overly panicky from what I've seen of mike so far. None of this is damning alone and considered together it's still almost entirely circumstantial but it's day 2 and still early in the phase
VOTE: Trigger
Hmm... he certainly does have a lot of odd comments and has been stroking up a lot of attention. Does anyone actually think Trigger is playing normal at this point though? The one problem is a lot of it is circumstantial and just "He slipped up and forgot ____" or "he claimed ordinary too early" and things like that. It's bad play overall, but it's not really overtly scummy by itself. I think overall right now I'd be ok lynching him (as I was day 1 when I voted for him), but I'm also still looking for something more concrete because my feeling isn't quite strong enough to give up on that search.
D1 we had 7 votes for darklighter, the largest group by a wide margin, making it a compelling place for mafia to try to stash a vote. Of these fireblend was killed leaving 6.
flush, ferret, ultrajay, scrafty, trigger and sorian
I still read sorian, flush, a ultrajay as town for the time being.
ferret and scrafty I need to do some more homework on as I stated previously
I wanted to bring up that Day 1 might not be the best source of group votes to look at. It's definitely good to keep in mind, but it's also an interesting outlier from a typical day 1 ends in terms of numbers (at least in my GAFia experience). Overall we had 10 people with votes on them (and 2 people who votes no lynch), the 2nd place had 3 votes. While scum may (and likely do) have some people clustered in on the 7 votes on Darklighter, it was also a very easy opportunity for some of them to go vote on someone else and leave it there. We were pretty set on DarkLighter, they didn't really even need to push us there or defend anything. I wouldn't be surprised if some scum even voted for another scum at that point, realizing that vote wouldn't have impacted anything and could possibly be used as an argument for why they're town later.
Overall, I feel good with your statements, though moreso with your original content than your answers to my questions. I'd still like to know how you interpret Setre's answers, but for now my vote is off you. Still deciding who to park it on over night while I go sleep, but for now...
UNVOTE
