so, I'm going to put this in here.
my first afternoon with Wii U was kind of depressing with patches, and locks and all of that, and my first evening over at a friends playing 5 player nintendoland on his system was very positive.
since then I've not had a boat load of time with the system, but I have gotten to play some Zombi U (not enough to call it one way or the other, but it was promising) and I've played more BLOPS2 and I picked up Nano whatever last night.
System power is a bit disappointing so far. Hopefully things improve a bit, but I'll get over it. I was hoping multiplats would be best on Wii U (but not by any large margin) so I would be able to comfortably pick up games on Wii U over the next year.
This isn't entirely a negative thing though, because ultimately I love the gamepad. It's been a bit of a revelation for me (though not a revolution). Most of this is good stuff, even with load times being a bit quicker than I'd like, the ease of transitioning from game, to miiverse, to web, is still impressive. It'd be even more impressive if they cut down those 10 second load times.
While this sort of makes it harder for me to focus on playing a game, it makes the whole experience more communal, and I really like that. I also really like how easy it is to just fire up the pad and check miiverse, or pop in the store. Where as doing that on the 360 seems like a bigger deal somehow, it feels incredibly convenient to do it on the pad.
Hulu Plus needs to have some updates so you can just use it off the pad like Netflix, but these are the Netflix and hulu plus clients I'm going to gravitate towards in the future, espescially when I'm watching something home by myself. To be able to switch from the gamepad to the TV and vice versa instantly is going to mean I can easily bring what I'm watching into the kitchen if I'm doing dishes, or over to my PC, or whatever. that's a killer feature.
Last night my wife wanted to go to bed early because she'd had a really long day, and she asked if I'd bring up the gamepad and play on that, rather than using my PC or playing on the TV downstairs. she hates going to bed by herself, especially on cold nights, but our schedules aren't completely aligned, so often she's really tired and I'm not.
so, you can see where this is heading. I put BLORPS2 into the Wii U, grabbed my headphones and came upstairs. In no way did I feel like I was getting an inferior experience playing off the gamepad and I was as involved in the game as I'd be anywhere else. I hit the wing suit section and shared a screen of it on Miiverse (tagged spoiler!) and some replies came in very quickly from other people talking about how cool that section was.
I did have to pay a little attention to how I was sitting in order to keep a strong signal between the console and the pad, but I plan to move a couple of things around in my AV center to mitigate that somewhat. That's an environmental issue though, we're only talking about something that cropped up a couple of times in a few hours using the system.
After some more BLORPS2 browsed gaf for a bit, and then loaded up the store and bought Nano whatever and had a few goes on that. I'm looking forwards to seeing that on my HDTV, but it looked really impressive on the pad, and played great. I'd definitely recommend it, even though the leaderboards are a bit bugged right now. basically it only shows the last two digits of your rank, so everyone thinks they're ranked top 100. I thought I was ranked 12th (and presumed the game was selling terribly as a result until I checked the top scores leaderboard and saw the real top 100. the friends leaderboards work just fine though, obviously as you can't have more than 100 of those.
The convenience of it... is incredible. The flexibility of it is impressive. The seamlessness of it is good, and will hopefully improve if those load times can be addressed somehow. The control is a great size and weight. It definitely beats using our Surface in bed for anything other than web browsing.
Smartglass is neat on the 360. I like using it with Forza Horizons where it's a moderately useful little proof of concept, but I can't see how it can even begin to compete, even when talking about AV tasks, like using smartglass to launch videos on the Xbox 360, the Wii U has it beaten. Both have to load the video players, but transferring from one to the other on the Surface takes a little time. That instant switch on the Wii U, it really does feel like some sci fi magic, even if I understand the technology behind it.
TVii is going to get a lot of use from me, especially with the social integrations. Multiplatform games that offer off screen play, unless they've got serious technical issues, it's going to be Wii U all the way for me, for the next year at least.
The benchmark for me of any innovation is, 'do I want everyone to jump on board with this?' and I absolutely do. I really hope Sony and Microsoft go in the same direction. Some people who don't share a screen or live with anyone else aren't going to get it, I don't think. But fortunately we're talking about a very big group of people that will. Trust me, if I was twelve, I'd completely understand what this device was going to offer me, and it's no surprise to see it as high up in the Christmas wishlist rankings as it is.
edit: Also, if you didn't see over in the network id thread, I'm 'plagiarize' over in Miiverse. send me a friend request, just be sure to tag it 'GAF'.