With this in mind, it's pretty challenging to think highly of the third episode of Cinderella Girls. Using the earlier referenced im@s episode as a point of comparison we have an extraordinarily different perspective that I appreciate. The idols themselves are upstarts here, and this early hill to climb as backup dancers in a live concert setting is fairly steep. It's nice to have scenarios with high stakes, but we've primarily seen the main idol trio bond on a personal level rather than work together in a professional environment. The opportunity for that feels somewhat wasted here, and the talent growth to competency seemingly occurs by magic when it's done through plain sweaty training montage. Old im@s had P-san gradually coming to a realization that he needed to change behavior patterns over the course of an episode. It was a mentality change with a slow build that still needed to be proven. Cinderella Girls thrusts its protagonists into a spotlight and has them preform even under pressure and with minimal training. It all feels too smooth.
I think the goals and themes of the two works are fairly different. Idolm@ster covered the 765 girls as a whole and tried to highlight them more as a group rather than individual sections. In CG, there's a much bigger focus on the trio and the other girls are supplementary to the core trio. I'm starting to suspect that the other girls, such as Oreki loli, won't get that much characterization and instead the show will heavily lean with the main characters for everything. I feel like it's a sort of stop gap measure in that CG really doesn't want all the side characters but due to Idolm@ster fans howling up a shitstorm if their favorite girls aren't animated, commercialization wins. It's a better approach than trying to deal with such an ungodly sized cast such as in the first Idolm@ster but the limitations of the work are also more apparent.
Thematically CG is also more about fairy tales. One of the girls had an orange suit on this episode that reminded me of a pumpkin and had also tapped her heels together like in Cinderella. There's also other stuff like the castle and whatnot. In fairy tales all your dreams come true and so I think the girls are going to do fairly well until the clock strikes midnight. They might throw in family drama though like in the original Cinderella. It's not a show focused on the girls slowly rising to fame but it all being more like a dream as they skyrocket to the top(which should present its own problems such as jealousy and infighting).