It's not a 2/10 movie, but it's not much better either. I rank it above Fan4stic, but below even TIH and MoS, which is a very low bar. I would say in line with the old FF movies? I think that sounds fair. Right off the bat, I'm thinking "what the fuck" when Bruce Wayne with his ~250 IQ goes running into falling debris from this huge building that has just fallen. Now, I may be wrong, but Wayne is not a super human like Cap America or an alien like superman. AFAIK he is all human and I would think a regular person wouldn't go running into certain death, let alone a genius, but I digress. I don't like the casting. Thought Eisenberg would make a good Luthor, I was wrong. Cavil is not a good superman. The bad guy from Sam Jackson's Die Hard is not a good Alfred. I don't like Affleck as an actor and I hated him as batman. I like the movies he has directed despite him being an actor in them, so maybe the upcoming batman will be good. Doomsday felt rushed and they already killed the guy (side question, is doomsday created like that in the comics?). The fight scene in his dream was lame as all hell, but the Arkham fight scene recreation was kind of cool, except when Affleck was actually talking. Also since when is his mask (non armor), bulletproof? I didn't see batman kill anybody except in his dream, so not sure why people are complaining about that? Of course I might have missed something.
Is wonder woman supposed to speak english with an accent? Real question. Gal Gadot was okay, but I think WW is hard sell. She came out of nowhere with her introduction and I'm like okay, cool, but no idea what kind of powers she has. She can lasso people? Is it a special rope? The movie kinda assumes you know what her powers are. She is not as big as she was in the 70s and people don't really know her. A lot are still very misogynistic. I saw a youtube video the other day (I think it was Kevin Smith's channel) and this woman was complaining about Elektra tossing guys around because it's unrealistic. I'm thinking, you're watching a world where a blind guy kicks all sorts of ass and a psycho maniac with ptsd kills whole gangs by himself and you're complaining about that? Random question, why does aquaman need to hold his breath underwater? With a $250M budget, you'd think they would not make it so obvious. I also only knew who Flash was out of the whole 4. Final thoughts, I think there's more wrong with this movie than just the direction, it's easy to blame Snyder, but the writing and the script are flawed, the casting is flawed, the cinematography is flawed, etc. Just reshooting with more comedy or replacing the director would not have made this a good movie IMO.