WC/Jez: Microsoft's ambitious new Xbox: Your entire Xbox console library, the full power of Windows PC gaming, and no multiplayer paywall

Will you buy the next Xbox hardware?


  • Total voters
    451
I don't think what the runtime environment is will be sufficient evidence to convince Tobi that the development environment is changing.

Regardless, I don't see the point of keeping GDK alive after this move, unless @Tobimacoss can explain what exactly is the need for it to exist for next gen games going forward. Its existence makes perfect sense until cross gen/Series X is completely phased out, but I would think its days are numbered at the very least.
It would cost money to port it to Xbox SDK and they would not gain any additional money/sales in doing so.

There is no incentive even for MS's own studios.
 
I wonder what is going to happen to the games that are console only but not PC. Like NHL or CFB. Is EA now just going to make these PS6 exclusive or will they be forced to finally make PC versions so it runs on Magnus.
 
I wonder what is going to happen to the games that are console only but not PC. Like NHL or CFB. Is EA now just going to make these PS6 exclusive or will they be forced to finally make PC versions so it runs on Magnus.
If they want to do Xbox versions they have no choice but to do a pc version. Also who knows about those games they might not be around after getting acquired by Saudi Arabia.
 
Project Amethyst provides the core technologies of RDNA 5. It's more like Sony AND AMD's technology this time around. Perhaps more similar to PS3 Cell joint venture than PS4/PS5 development collaboration. My guess is Sony will be paying significantly less licensing costs on a per chip basis for PS6 while Microsoft will be subjected to much higher fees.
 
The Magnus SoC is custom made for Microsoft, but the ATx GMDs are just regular GPU chiplets (apart from the mentioned HW BC stuff like old texture format support).

All AMD APUs since 2022 use Pluton.

By SOC do you mean the bridged die or the CPU+NPU portion.

Also the cpu configuration looks to be similar to the one in Medusa Halo Mini. Why aren't they working with AMD to make the cpu side used in more things such as desktops.
 
Last edited:
By SOC do you mean the bridges die or the CPU+NPU.

Also the cpu configuration looks to be similar to the one in Medusa Halo Mini. Why aren't they working with AMD to make the cpu side used in more things such as desktops.
SOC == cpu cores, NPU cores, bridge dies and gpu chiplet as a package. Each individual part is just normal AMD technology, the actual layout, selection of number of Zen6 cores number of rdna5 components, etc is custom for MS. So the lego bricks are all just normal bricks, how they're assembled into a SOC is bespoke for MS.
 
I wonder what is going to happen to the games that are console only but not PC. Like NHL or CFB. Is EA now just going to make these PS6 exclusive or will they be forced to finally make PC versions so it runs on Magnus.

Good question. Also, games that are PC only in EA, will they work easily? If it plays console only games like the ones you mentioned and GTA 6, and also EA games that are PC only like Vein, it will truly be a hybrid.
 
I wonder what is going to happen to the games that are console only but not PC. Like NHL or CFB. Is EA now just going to make these PS6 exclusive or will they be forced to finally make PC versions so it runs on Magnus.
That would only matter if Magnus actually sold a decent number. Instead these sports games would just keep releasing Xbox Series versions of these games until sales drop off entirely. Magnus would not be sold enough to influence porting decisions.
 
I find it hard to believe that I'll be able to play all my OG Xbox games. ("entire Xbox console library")
Because it is hard to believe.
Hardware BC is out of the question, the 360 Cpu wasn't x86 and the Xbox and 360 GPUs were Nvidia.
Emulation carries potential licensing issues and requires per game optimisation, so I think they mean BC as in the current Xbox and 360 titles they already do BC in the Series consoles (at least until those licenses eventually expire).
 
SOC == cpu cores, NPU cores, bridge dies and gpu chiplet as a package. Each individual part is just normal AMD technology, the actual layout, selection of number of Zen6 cores number of rdna5 components, etc is custom for MS. So the lego bricks are all just normal bricks, how they're assembled into a SOC is bespoke for MS.

K KeplerL2 mentioned that the CPU + NPU die is semi-custom. iirc. Also the comment that I was responding to, he didn't say the CPU + NPU chiplet is off the shelf.
 
Last edited:
K KeplerL2 mentioned that the CPU + NPU die is semi-custom. iirc. Also the comment that I was responding to, he didn't say the CPU + NPU chiplet is off the shelf.
We will see. Nothing says MS solution more than taking off the shelf parts, doing *absolutely nothing* and then claiming that these are *custom* - it's literally waht they did from the OG Xbox onwards. Each gen the western games media falls for it and each gen it's the same story - they do not do custom work, they take a collection of existing IP (or near future roadmap IP) and claim it's custom.

The exact assemblage of these specific blocks will be "custom" for MS - AMD will not create the same thing for anyone else - so again if you squint you can claim it's custom.
 
We will see. Nothing says MS solution more than taking off the shelf parts, doing *absolutely nothing* and then claiming that these are *custom* - it's literally waht they did from the OG Xbox onwards. Each gen the western games media falls for it and each gen it's the same story - they do not do custom work, they take a collection of existing IP (or near future roadmap IP) and claim it's custom.

The exact assemblage of these specific blocks will be "custom" for MS - AMD will not create the same thing for anyone else - so again if you squint you can claim it's custom.

So, they are doing what they always do but you'll also get access to PC (the BEST platform) only games? What is not to love? It's wild that people say PC like it's a bad thing. I wonder how the reception would be if it was a Sony/Steam hybrid console. So much different that it's crazy. You all know it. Same goes for a PSP 2 with access to Steam, etc. But of course, its MS so the hate is blatant. A platform with more freedom is bad. Walled garden or bust.
 
I have a really hard time believing that they will have a console that doesn't require you to pay to play online, that's where they've always made a huge portion of their money.
 
We will see. Nothing says MS solution more than taking off the shelf parts, doing *absolutely nothing* and then claiming that these are *custom* - it's literally waht they did from the OG Xbox onwards.

That's just bullshit. The only corp that took an off the shelf part and literally did nothing with it at all! was NCL on the Switch Hell, Nintendo didn't even put its badge on the SOC :messenger_tears_of_joy:

Even if they're using PC parts, you still have some customisation to shrink them down and work inside a console form factor or in the case of the Series X and PS5 add some ray tracing support at that time. Its not simply a PC GPU just put inside SOC

And I don't get why people are so against using the best tech for a console, even if it comes from PC or wherever. I couldn't give a shit that Power VR came from the PC when playing my DC, or how the Mega Drive CPU was an 'off the shelf' CPU.

The only sad part over the last few generations is both SONY and Xbox are using the same vendor for their SOC, but even then, you can get a different experience with each console
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom