Okay, so I've been wrangling with the best way to keep track of gaffers and make the listing available. Currently, we have what is essentially a BF3 social networking tool in Battlelog and I think we should take full advantage of it. It's much easier to simply look up a GAF platoon and add friends from there, rather than having an OP (that needs to be manually maintained) with a list of users that you have to copy and paste into Battlelog.
Now, the disadvantages to relying purely on Battlelog are:
-Battlelog/Soldier names are not always the same as GAF name
-Harder to make sure that actual gaffers are requesting to join the platoon
Here is what I propose...let me know if anything sounds off or I'm missing something.
-We do away with the OP list of contacts completely and use Battlelog Platoons for GAF contacts
-If a platoon fills up, we make a second "version". For instance, NeoGAF NA East is currently full. We can make a second platoon called "NeoGAF NA East II" or 2 or something
Tricky part is matching up the Battlelog Soldier with a gaffer. We could:
-Ask applicants to put their GAF username in their profile. We could then just run a simple search for "Battlefield 3 + username" in GAF to "verify"
-Ask applicants to post a generic phrase like "My soldier name is WHATEVER" in the community thread before or after they apply. We can then search that exact phrase (making it easier to return the right result) and verify
The only unresolvable issue is easily matching up Soldier names with gaffers, if we rely purely on Battlelog. But I don't really feel this is an issue, as it's a mixed up clusterfuck in the first place.
Thoughts?