Parakeetman
No one wants a throne you've been sitting on!
Note to self: a tiger can survive 10+ shots from a pistol, three of which went to the head.
Holy balls.
Get a shotgun ASAP. Thats the best weapon for hunting with. Dont use the 2nd one, the dumbshit player character takes too long to cycle a new round with the lever action. I have some serious issues with the speed of firing for the shotguns.
They should be a threat, but maybe not a "unload two pistol clips into it and it's still a killing machine" threat.
Then again, it adds to the atmosphere a lot.
Closest thing in reality is a guy unloaded 9 rounds of .45 ACP (which basically is about a mag and 2 rounds into the next assuming he was using standard magazines article doesnt say) into a grizzly bear in Alaska when it charged a friend and him. Which warded off the bear which was found dead later by park rangers.
Going after big game with "small caliber" firearms isnt exactly the brightest of ideas.