I botched my 1st attempt for The Spine of the Vortex Bow. It's been so long since I Crafted an item with affinity I forgot that it also affected "progress" Normally I'd finish a 3* with 3x Careful Synthesis II, after the 1st only gave me 36 Progress I knew I was screwed! I used 2x Brand of the Wind but was short of the 445 Difficulty. It also doesn't help that the MAX Quality you can start with is 577 because most of the mats can not be found HQ, I had a 57% chance to HQ.
There went ~ 4 million Gil worth of mats bought and 2 million worth of saved Battlecraft Demimatetia III. I think people knew I messed up, I had a small group of players around my nook at the Gridinia Market Board. Also within 1 hour 3x more Demimateria of the Vortex was listed... and 10x Battlecraft III to allow me another attempt... a 4.5 million Gil attempt!
This time I stacked all the "progress" at the beginning... 3x Piece by Piece + 2x Brand of the Wind, brought me within 1x Careful Synthesis II of completion. Then the "good" conditions flowed like water and I converted all of them with Tricks of the Trade. I only missed 1 Hasty Touch, had enough CP for an extra Manipulation and had an Inner Quiet stack of 10. Then Innovation -> Great Strides -> Ingenuity II -> Byregot's Blessing. Brought me to 96% Quality! There was a 4% chance I'd get an NQ... but it came out HQ!!!!
Not sure it's a server-first, but it felt dam good to get it HQ! That HQ Spine of the Vortex bow on the Ultros MB is mine