K
kittens
Unconfirmed Member
I'd be pissed if Cortana died, especially if it was just because of rampancy. Chief and Cortana got literally swallowed by Forerunner technology. Finding a way to extend Cortana's life should be a piece of cake. It wouldn't be a cop out. Cortana is one of Halo's most interesting characters, and I'd be so disappointed if she wasn't there for the ride on this new saga.
And killing Cortana off merely to see how Chief deals with it would be pretty shallow, in my opinon. There are far more interesting ways to examine their relationship and Chief's own emotions. Killing Cortana off just to see Chief be sad is such a typical narrative. Strong, stoic male loses the person he was closest to, and has to deal with his feelings quietly and by himself because that's what men do. It's been done a million times over, and it would be absolutely counter to 343's goals of giving Chief humanity.
Edit : You want to see Chief struggle with his emotions? Then let him actually HAVE emotions. Killing Cortana would be killing Chief's biggest connect to his emotions. If Cortana died, it's not like we would see Chief shed a tear, or hear him monologue about his loss. Cortana is essential to digging into Chief's psyche and enabling him to relate emotionally. I have no idea if I'm making any sense. I'm not a writer, lol, but I definitely feel strongly about how this should/shouldn't play out.
And killing Cortana off merely to see how Chief deals with it would be pretty shallow, in my opinon. There are far more interesting ways to examine their relationship and Chief's own emotions. Killing Cortana off just to see Chief be sad is such a typical narrative. Strong, stoic male loses the person he was closest to, and has to deal with his feelings quietly and by himself because that's what men do. It's been done a million times over, and it would be absolutely counter to 343's goals of giving Chief humanity.
Edit : You want to see Chief struggle with his emotions? Then let him actually HAVE emotions. Killing Cortana would be killing Chief's biggest connect to his emotions. If Cortana died, it's not like we would see Chief shed a tear, or hear him monologue about his loss. Cortana is essential to digging into Chief's psyche and enabling him to relate emotionally. I have no idea if I'm making any sense. I'm not a writer, lol, but I definitely feel strongly about how this should/shouldn't play out.