• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Halo The Master Chief Collection |OT| Halo Never Died, It Was Just Missing In Action

Status
Not open for further replies.

Stevey

Member
Thanks for sharing this. You got in. It took a long time "Searching for players" then finally found a game, with 5 players 3vs2. But when the game started, it was 2vs1. Looks like the other guys either quit or didn't make it in?

Yeah, dunno what happened there.

That was my last game, been searching ever since- all playlists the same

I don't even know why you guys are bothering with MM until they release that patch. It's broken guys, save yourself the frustration.

I had a patch today, or is there another one coming?
 

HGStormy

Banned
I don't even know why you guys are bothering with MM until they release that patch. It's broken guys, save yourself the frustration.

I stopped trying to play MP. Played the CE campaign until the middle of the Truth and Reconciliation level, where pressing "x" to open the bay doors did nothing <_<
Am I stupid or is it bugged?
 

Omni

Member
Haven't seen anyone talk about the broken invisibility. In remastered graphics Chief's legs don't go invisible when you cloak and there are a lot of weapon graphical errors too. Like shotgun shells don't turn invisible inside the shotgun, the plasma doesn't turn invisible on the front of the gun for the plasma rifle. The plasma rifle also has a graphical glitch that I think is caused by intersecting geometry which causes the polys to act up. Very annoying to look at.

Yeah, I noticed that while using the Brute Shot the other day.

The game is just one big bug
 

Barzul

Member
The same thing happened to me. I think the "save and quit" is just broken in H2A campaign, I remember it working fine when I played the original Halo 2 disc on 360.

(Why wasn't this issue identified by the reviewers?)

Yup, it's completely broken. I was just doubting my own ability to 'Save + Quit' before quitting but I verified it just now: it's completely broken.
Ok so it's not just me. They really need to get it stuff fixed then. It makes the experience jarring having to restart each time.
 

dork

Banned
I don't even know why you guys are bothering with MM until they release that patch. It's broken guys, save yourself the frustration.

I just wanna see the game in action. I seriously haven't even made it past the searching for players screen. Unbelievable. (I know I can do campaign but ugh)

Omg it found players!
 

NIN90

Member
Is anyone having an issue with Halo 2 campaign not recognizing checkpoints when resuming and going back to the start of the mission. I've had to start that Cairo station mission from beginning way too many times...or is this as it should be?

Yeah, it's basically a coin toss whether it works or not. Leaving the Xbox in standby isn't safe either since the game has a thing for greeting me with the splash screen when I resume.
 

Delt31

Member
How do I play Halo 4 MP without creating a lobby? I just want to play Halo 4 MP and have the game find other players......Team slayer option seems to include all Halo BUT 4.
 
I don't even know why you guys are bothering with MM until they release that patch. It's broken guys, save yourself the frustration.

Pretty much this. It's going to take a client side patch to even be playable. What concerns me is that once this steaming mess is cleared we'll have to go through the inevitable rigmarole of complaining for months before BR starts have a higher weighting, certain map/gametype combos are jettisoned, objective settings are sensible etc.

In a collection that has over 100 maps, why is the near universally reviled 'Isolation' with an AR start even appearing in hoppers? You take the best maps from each game, pair them with their best settings and gametypes and iterate from there. If anyone cries, direct them to customs.
 

HGStormy

Banned
How do I play Halo 4 MP without creating a lobby? I just want to play Halo 4 MP and have the game find other players......Team slayer option seems to include all Halo BUT 4.

You basically can't :lol

Even if H4 DID show up in the Team Slayer playlists, and even if the matchmaking wasn't completely fucked, no one would ever vote for it.

Still waiting for a goddamn objective playlist.
 

E92 M3

Member
343 has some if the best brightest folks... How did this crap happen to a halo game? Halo made online mp where it is on consoles. Sighs.

I am a huge supporter of halo too. But my trust in 343 caretaking halo is being chalkenged.

Sad to say the game was outsourced to 7 different studios - 343 had very minimal input besides supervising and maybe project management. And it all shows.
 

Killer

Banned
343 has some if the best brightest folks... How did this crap happen to a halo game? Halo made online mp where it is on consoles. Sighs.

I am a huge supporter of halo too. But my trust in 343 caretaking halo is being chalkenged.

They are damaging the brand. No other Halo had these kind of issues. They were incredibly polished on release. MS released it to meet the holiday season and it sure backfires at them.
 

Delt31

Member
You basically can't :lol

Even if H4 DID show up in the Team Slayer playlists, and even if the matchmaking wasn't completely fucked, no one would ever vote for it.

Still waiting for a goddamn objective playlist.

ok so it's still broken? damn. Is the plan (once it's fixed) to be able to find Halo 4 MP only? Im one of the rare folks who enjoys Halo 4 and would hate to be left with only options to play with other Halos as the voting would never elect 4.
 

Noobcraft

Member
So Halo Nightfall... I'm not going to judge it (solely) from the first episode but it is pretty meh so far. It's not the worst show I've seen but it needs a lot of help in the pacing and story presentation department. The acting is pretty average at best too :/

It does get bonus points for helping me put the baby to sleep though. I'll watch the next episode lol.
 

Killer

Banned
You basically can't :lol

Even if H4 DID show up in the Team Slayer playlists, and even if the matchmaking wasn't completely fucked, no one would ever vote for it.

Still waiting for a goddamn objective playlist.

They REALLY need to do that. Halo is best in objective gametypes imo.
 
You basically can't :lol

Even if H4 DID show up in the Team Slayer playlists, and even if the matchmaking wasn't completely fucked, no one would ever vote for it.

Still waiting for a goddamn objective playlist.
Got in 2 games last night where I actually talked to a couple of other guys that preferred Halo 4. We exist!!
 

Faith

Member
Lol, they removed half of the playlist and this game still fucking needs 30 minutes of searching for 1 game, probably 3v4.
 

Prologue

Member
Halo CE on legendary isn't very much of a joke as I'm starting to notice. Halo 4 and Halo 3 were really doable and hardly died.

I'm on the third mission, jeez.
 

Krilekk

Banned
Because of the MM issues I am delving deep into the campaigns. Started H2A today and I must say..

Those BLUR cutscenes
That BR sound (please 343, put that godly music on the H5 version)
That nostalgia

Really liking it so far. There are some downsides, such as the framerate being a bit jittery at times and I have had some issues with models fading in and out even at point blank range. But despite that, loving it so far.

There's only one thing I don't like about the remake and that's flora. It is static (nothing is animated) it's way less than in Halo CEA (which had animated flora and tons of it, especially grass) and at times for very strange reasons it's even less in Halo 2 Anniversary than in the original Halo 2. Delta Halo especially. Because of this Halo 2A feels very flat. And it seems like unlike Halo CEA a lot less geometry was changed. It's more a reskin than a remake.
 
There's only one thing I don't like about the remake and that's flora. It is static (nothing is animated) it's way less than in Halo CEA (which had animated flora and tons of it, especially grass) and at times for very strange reasons it's even less in Halo 2 Anniversary than in the original Halo 2. Delta Halo especially. Because of this Halo 2A feels very flat. And it seems like unlike Halo CEA a lot less geometry was changed. It's more a reskin than a remake.

Zanzibar beach in anniversary graphics has zero foliage compared to patches in the original visuals, and because the ground is the same polygon wise it looks really bad for a remake.

I agree with how H2A feels more like a reskin because they kept the look of a lot of polygons the same where HCEA changed a lot of things (the halo ring was rather lame looking but the stages looked fine to me)

What I do wish is that more areas in H2A had more / unique looking lighting, they improved it a ton over the original game but everywhere is way too well lit or foggy at a distance, I would have loved to see more dynamic lighting or flickering lights in places to add to the atmosphere, it's a ball they dropped.
 

Sesuadra

Unconfirmed Member
fix the matchmaking and allow me to chose what kind of multiplayer type I want to search for ._."

I have not been able to play the MP since release. it did not find ONE GAME. well, okay, it did find one and when the game was about to start the screen froze..

I just want to play guys.
 

Computer

Member
Out of all the Halo MP's. Halo 2 still holds up as the best in my opinion. With H2A something is off about how it plays. I can't tell what it is but it dose not play near as well has Halo 2.
 
Lol, they removed half of the playlist and this game still fucking needs 30 minutes of searching for 1 game, probably 3v4.

Yeah it's not the lack of people in searches, it's how the code is finding people which is the problem.

Since they cut back the playlists I noticed zero differences, I either find a game or I do not, most of the time it's the later.

Out of all the Halo MP's. Halo 2 still holds up as the best in my opinion. With H2A something is off about how it plays. I can't tell what it is but it dose not play near as well has Halo 2.

4 shot BR kills in H2A ruin it a bit, also the lack of proper 4 v 4's making games feel fair and fun.
 

Ramirez

Member
Halo CE on legendary isn't very much of a joke as I'm starting to notice. Halo 4 and Halo 3 were really doable and hardly died.

I'm on the third mission, jeez.

I told some guys last night that T&R could be a Dark Souls area, lol. It took me about 2 1/2-3 hours to get through the first 3 levels last night.
 
Can you change difficulty through a campaign like in diablo 3? I started on normal and it's very easy right now and want to move it up. There is an option of "show difficulty"but I can't seem to change it.
 

Bio-Frost

Member
Zanzibar beach in anniversary graphics has zero foliage compared to patches in the original visuals, and because the ground is the same polygon wise it looks really bad for a remake.

I agree with how H2A feels more like a reskin because they kept the look of a lot of polygons the same where HCEA changed a lot of things (the halo ring was rather lame looking but the stages looked fine to me)

What I do wish is that more areas in H2A had more / unique looking lighting, they improved it a ton over the original game but everywhere is way too well lit or foggy at a distance, I would have loved to see more dynamic lighting or flickering lights in places to add to the atmosphere, it's a ball they dropped.

I keep seeing the word "remake throw around in this thread and the majora's mask thread. A remake is something built from the ground up with new code, noting from the original code is used.

What Nintendo and Microsoft are doing is a reskin/enhanced port. Not tryin to be rude or anything but I've been seeing this happen a lot as of late and its setting the bar too high. Noting wrong with a reskin but calling it a remake gives people the impression more is changeling when it's not.
 
I keep seeing the word "remake throw around in this thread and the majora's mask thread. A remake is something built from the ground up with new code, noting from the original code is used.

What Nintendo and Microsoft are doing is a reskin/enhanced port. Not tryin to be rude or anything but I've been seeing this happen a lot as of late and its setting the bar too high. Noting wrong with a reskin but calling it a remake gives people the impression more is changeling when it's not.

Sorry, it's just what I typed, I know it's more or a reskin with fresh models. Remake is just one of those simple words which comes to mind.

Can you change difficulty through a campaign like in diablo 3? I started on normal and it's very easy right now and want to move it up. There is an option of "show difficulty"but I can't seem to change it.

You will need to start again from the chapter you are in with new settings in the menu, you can't change on the fly.
 
Halo CE on legendary isn't very much of a joke as I'm starting to notice. Halo 4 and Halo 3 were really doable and hardly died.

I'm on the third mission, jeez.

I'm stuck on the second mission, I'm going for the no vehicles achievment on top of it, already cleared the area where you have to nade jump but man, it's a nightmare.
 

Raide

Member
Accidentally started making a Rocket Arena style map. lol

Despite a few Forge annoyances, I am getting back into it.

T5SnpMj.jpg

Just blocking out atm, will decorate later.
 
I finally got into a match! 3rd since launch. 45 mins of waiting 4 mins then restarting. Spawn in and it's 4v1 on lockout. I'm by myself. Seriously 343?

They should seriously stop selling it to new purchasers until it's 100% fixed. The avg public won't know how borked it is. I feel bad for anyone who buys
 

Vestal

Junior Member
I forgot how awful the middle section of Halo 1 is in terms of level design. So bad.


Yup it gets very repetitive. Which at the time of release was excusable.

One of the reasons the campaign layout does not hold up too well. Gameplay is still top fucking notch though.
 
I finally got into a match! 3rd since launch. 45 mins of waiting 4 mins then restarting. Spawn in and it's 4v1 on lockout. I'm by myself. Seriously 343?

They should seriously stop selling it to new purchasers until it's 100% fixed. The avg public won't know how borked it is. I feel bad for anyone who buys

Fuck matchmaking at this point, they just need to allow us to start a custom where people can see others playing via a browser search and let us manually join that way.

Or even better, let us connect to a server and wait for others to join too, I am sick of not having a guaranteed server match, that was a big selling point for me and I still get p2p half the time, fucking stupid.
 

clav

Member
Fuck matchmaking at this point, they just need to allow us to start a custom where people can see others playing via a browser search and let us manually join that way.

Or even better, let us connect to a server and wait for others to join too, I am sick of not having a guaranteed server match, that was a big selling point for me and I still get p2p half the time, fucking stupid.

While reducing playlists is a start, I think the whole matchmaking thing should just be one playlist for now.

Add in playlists later once it's all fixed.

People just want to play games.
 
While reducing playlists is a start, I think the whole matchmaking thing should just be one playlist for now.

Add in playlists later once it's all fixed.

People just want to play games.

I think the problems are deeper then the pool size of players looking for a match, something is failing and not working to pair groups together somehow.

Who knows.
 
Yup it gets very repetitive. Which at the time of release was excusable.

One of the reasons the campaign layout does not hold up too well. Gameplay is still top fucking notch though.
It is but my god the copy and paste rooms and backtracking. The level design alone makes Halo 1 the worst Halo I can safely say now.
 

Helznicht

Member
Accidentally started making a Rocket Arena style map. lol

I have not played much with forge in the past games. Is there a way to actually create a old style RA game type? 1vs1, with waiting lines and observers?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom