• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

HBO's House Of The Dragon (no book spoilers)

BadBurger

Many “Whelps”! Handle It!
It's worth noting that Daemon is married to Lady Royce of RUNESTONE, which is a castle by the sea IN the Vale, not the Eyrie itself. The Vale is currently being run by Lady Jenye Arryn, something the show doesn't talk about much because it clearly undermines their "these men won't accept a woman ruler, hur dur" narrative.

https://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Runestone#google_vignette

As far as the show is concerned, there is no way that a prince Targaryen very near to the throne would not be the lord of the Eyrie if he married into the Arryns. That would be like Bobby B marrying off Joffrey to some lass from House Fossoway of New Barrell.
 

Batiman

Banned
But if she lived long enough to tell the tale to ANYONE in that valley Daemon would have been executed. Seemed an odd thing to do is all.

That girl is still far too cute.
Ya that scene made no sense to me. Especially that it seemed they were on what seemed to be a path.
 

Batiman

Banned
She 22, yo!

Do you feel this way about Euphoria, American Pie, and American Beauty as well?
22 but made to look very young. Also supposed to be very young in the show. Creepy comment ngl. I’ll give you a pass if you’re like 16 tho
 
Last edited:

jason10mm

Gold Member
As far as the show is concerned, there is no way that a prince Targaryen very near to the throne would not be the lord of the Eyrie if he married into the Arryns. That would be like Bobby B marrying off Joffrey to some lass from House Fossoway of New Barrell.
Well, that's not how succession OR Westeros works, ain't no way marrying a vassal lord gets you to trump the main House. Now if Daemon and Rhea had a daughter, marrying HER to the Arryn heir would make sense, though if Daemons kids were dragonriders the Targaryens would normally want to marry them back into the Targaryen orbit to keep dragonriding exclusive to them.
 

jason10mm

Gold Member
22 but made to look very young. Also supposed to be very young…
Acting! How that work?

So you also feel Euphoria, American Pie, Just One of the Guys (directed by a woman), Porkies, Fast Times at Ridgemont High (also directed by a woman, BTW), any number of HUNDREDS of high school set sex comedies or whatnot should be classified as pedofilth?
 

Batiman

Banned
Acting! How that work?

So you also feel Euphoria, American Pie, Just One of the Guys (directed by a woman), Porkies, Fast Times at Ridgemont High (also directed by a woman, BTW), any number of HUNDREDS of high school set sex comedies or whatnot should be classified as pedofilth?
I don’t know about everything else. I personally find it weird though, especially that she plays a young teen/child so convincingly. I know if anyone in my circle said that in conversation while discussing the show. Eyes would be rolled
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
But it seems they’ve been married for a while and he’s just never been interested in her. And he’s into other women other than Rhaenyra. I think some shows just default to casting attractive people. Maybe since Daemon is meant to be a dick they didn’t want us to think “guess he has a point” if we finally see his wife and she’s not good looking.
I read it as Daemon's ambitions for the throne drive him completely, while also being an awful narcissist. He finds power attractive, and anyone who won't provide him with more is less than nothing in his eyes. Hence why he views his obviously pretty wife as uglier than sheep.

From that perspective it makes sense why he hates her. If he actually settled in the Vale he knows he would lead a life of doing nothing but sitting around protecting the Vale. That's pretty much all the Vale does: serve as a kind of final fortress for the sitting king, able to silo themselves off from the rest of the kingdoms in times of strife.

His actions also give resonance as to why the Vale are so untrusting of the Targs in the later GoT show.
Yes. it's a power thing. He is turned on when he has all control. That is why when Rhaenyra took control back when they were in the brothel or whatever, he lost all interest, and it killed his sex drive with her in that moment.

His wife was a dominant woman, so he bad mouthed her like a child.
 

TintoConCasera

I bought a sex doll, but I keep it inflated 100% of the time and use it like a regular wife
I don’t know about everything else. I personally find it weird though, especially that she plays a young teen/child so convincingly. I know if anyone in my circle said that in conversation while discussing the show. Eyes would be rolled
That might just be your circle bro. Just yesterday I was talking with my circle how cute both the young actresses are and how sad it's to get them replaced.

I guess it's a culture thing. I'm from Spain and we still are allowed you find young ladies appealing over here.
 

Batiman

Banned
That might just be your circle bro. Just yesterday I was talking with my circle how cute both the young actresses are and how sad it's to get them replaced.

I guess it's a culture thing. I'm from Spain and we still are allowed you find young ladies appealing over here.
I think they’re cute as well. Don’t care or want to see nudity from a character that’s supposed to be a child though.
 

Batiman

Banned
You’re making the thread weird with your personal hang ups. She’s 22, people can find her attractive.
Yes. it's a power thing. He is turned on when he has all control. That is why when Rhaenyra took control back when they were in the brothel or whatever, he lost all interest, and it killed his sex drive with her in that moment.

His wife was a dominant woman, so he bad mouthed her like a child.
I don’t think he lost interest in that moment. I just feel like he did what he planned out to do and moved on. His little scandal mission was done. That’s the way I seen it. I dunno
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
I don’t think he lost interest in that moment. I just feel like he did what he planned out to do and moved on. His little scandal mission was done. That’s the way I seen it. I dunno
He seemed pretty pissed off that he lost the dominant position.
 

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
If you are the heir why not command that your kids father train the boys. I think that would be a way to use your influence. Surely you can see the old boyfriend was showing favoritism.

Childbirth going bad, have your dragon burn you is a new one.

I did like seeing the dragon training.

Also the queen has become a real rude dude.

And a question did the cripple guy burn his own brother and father?
 

Kacho

Gold Member
And a question did the cripple guy burn his own brother and father?
Yes, the guys in jail were tasked to do that in exchange for their freedom.

Was the relationship between Ser Hawrin and Rhaenyra hinted at all before this episode? I was so lost on how they had kids together since it was only shown that she had a thing with Ser Criston and maybe had a child with him.
 

jason10mm

Gold Member
Fuck, great ep.

The show really shot itself in the foot with the Velaryon casting though, compare Rhaenyra kids with Daemon's and it's SOOOOOOO obvious (not that anyone has seen them together...yet). But oh well.

Not sure what they were going for with Laena torching herself. So she refused the C section and had the kid anyway, then dies in grief? The kid died in her and she knew she was dead soon as well? This c-section choice isnt a choice. Mom is almost assuredly dead either way, it's just a chance for the baby to live. My wife called bullshit on this one, no mom gives up on her kid.

My man Strong torching his dad and brother. He becomes Lord of Harrenhall and binds the Queen to him in one stroke.

Alicent leading HARD. Can't wait for Otto to show back up and see the sparks fly.

Noticed they pulled out the producer notes and preview into seperate vids that don't autoplay.

Good dragon shit this ep.
 

BaneIsPain

Member
Another entertaining and good episode. I love the kids (obviously Aegon and Aemond).

A proper introduction to Vhagar finally. The mature alicent is good but the mature rhaenyra is not (at least for now, but surely she will be better in future episode)

I like the
-the little feud between Bracken and Blackwood. They are important later on
-the triachy feuds on going
-the demise of the the strong shows how ruthless another strong son (larys). It is a bit different from the book, as one unreliable narrators said the cause of the fire maybe done by Daemon. Being setup by larys is straight ruthless

The cause of the fire was never determined. Some put it down to
simple mischance, whilst others muttered that Black Harren’s seat was
cursed and brought only doom to any man who held it. Many
suspected the blaze was set intentionally. Mushroom suggests that the
Sea Snake was behind it, as an act of vengeance against the man who
had cuckolded his son. Septon Eustace, more plausibly, suspects
Prince Daemon, removing a rival for Princess Rhaenyra’s affections.
Others have put forth the notion that Larys Clubfoot might have been
responsible; with his father and elder brother dead, Larys Strong
became the Lord of Harrenhal. The most disturbing possibility was
advanced by none other than Grand Maester Mellos, who muses that
the king himself might have given the command

THE SEED IS STRONG
 

BaneIsPain

Member
Yes, the guys in jail were tasked to do that in exchange for their freedom.

Was the relationship between Ser Hawrin and Rhaenyra hinted at all before this episode? I was so lost on how they had kids together since it was only shown that she had a thing with Ser Criston and maybe had a child with him.
I think it hinted twice
1. During the hunting when Rhaenyra stared at Harwin
2. Rhaenyra was saved by Harwin at the wedding. I guess she is grateful to him since Cole shuns on her.
 

Hardensoul

Member
Enjoying this show a lot! It’s really hard to pull for anyone in this show! It’s probably best not to take sides! It’s going to be a bloodbath! I’ll just enjoy the ride!

Side note! The kids sparring is more believable and better choreograph than RoP Galadriel fight scenes! 😂
 
Not sure what they were going for with Laena torching herself. So she refused the C section and had the kid anyway, then dies in grief? The kid died in her and she knew she was dead soon as well? This c-section choice isnt a choice. Mom is almost assuredly dead either way, it's just a chance for the baby to live. My wife called bullshit on this one, no mom gives up on her kid.
Well she says she wants to die a dragon-rider's death like 10 minutes prior to this scene. She also explicitly states she doesn't want the child born here, nor does she want her children to grow up here being used by the Prince. She requests leaving twice from Daemon and he doesn't answer her. Also, I wouldn't apply modern morality to HotD - especially someone given her characterization.
 
Last edited:

mortal

Banned
It's going to take some time to adjust to the new actors tbh.
I really grew accustomed to young princess Rhaenyra and Alicent, very much enjoyed their performances.
It was neat seeing how everyone aged in the last decade. King Viserys looking like the crypt keeper though lol

Was rather surprised to see so many damn Targeryan & Velaryon children running around.
Also, Criston's contempt for Rhaenyra is palpable, to say the least lol

The production values of HotD really are phenomenal. From the prop and set design to the costume and makeup. Each episode features some fantastic atmosphere.
Despite the better writing in the earlier seasons of GoT, it took a while for the series to start looking the part of the books. HBO aren't wasting a penny for HotD and it shows.
 
Last edited:

EviLore

Expansive Ellipses
Staff Member
4lI8BGr.gif
 

BadBurger

Many “Whelps”! Handle It!
God damn Larys Strong giving Iago a run for his money as the most ice cold for no reason villain around.
 

EviLore

Expansive Ellipses
Staff Member
God damn Larys Strong giving Iago a run for his money as the most ice cold for no reason villain around.
He just became lord of Harrenhall and forced the queen to become complicit in his treachery in one stroke. It's a hell of a power play. Dark stuff to have your father and brother killed, but not beyond the scope of what some people at court were willing to do.

Alicent's terror in the final few seconds of the episode, phew. No more low stakes scheming. Proper game of thrones is at hand.
 

Nobody_Important

“Aww, it’s so...average,” she said to him in a cold brick of passion
Loved the episode. The new actors stepped into the roles effortlessly. It really shows that they cast the older actors first and then cast the younger ones. Going to watch the episode again tomorrow and give my full breakdown.


Also on a side note Ser Criston needs to touch grass. Jesus fuck. Dude is straight out of a CoD Subreddit right now.

He just became lord of Harrenhall and forced the queen to become complicit in his treachery in one stroke. It's a hell of a power play. Dark stuff to have your father and brother killed, but not beyond the scope of what some people at court were willing to do.

Alicent's terror in the final few seconds of the episode, phew. No more low stakes scheming. Proper game of thrones is at hand.
Yep. The actress earned her money in that one moment. She put on a masterclass. The tears. The emotion. The betrayal. She had thought she was the one in charge all along talking down to a subordinate that would keep her secrets. The slow realization that he had been building up to this for years and that she was his pawn all along was amazing. She never dreamed that someone "so low" would rise against someone like her that was "so high". It perfectly plays into the already established idea that Alicent is firmly planted in the traditional pecking order of the realm. She is the queen under the protection of the king and a daughter of a prominent house. How could anyone possibly rise against her? And then BOOM. She is the pawn now.


I don't know Olivia Cooke as an actress outside this show, but I think she has earned a few checks and maybe even awards from that scene alone.
 
Last edited:
He just became lord of Harrenhall and forced the queen to become complicit in his treachery in one stroke. It's a hell of a power play. Dark stuff to have your father and brother killed, but not beyond the scope of what some people at court were willing to do.

Alicent's terror in the final few seconds of the episode, phew. No more low stakes scheming. Proper game of thrones is at hand.
Yup.

Also, i'm loving the show for 2 reasons:

- It's more about politics again, like early seasons of GOT;
- There's really not a villain as in "he's the bad guy. those are the good guys". I like that i can understand almost every characters motivations and at least respect or side with most of everyone's motivations in here. It's not one of those black and white kind of shows. Again, a lot like early GOT.
 

jason10mm

Gold Member
Well she says she wants to die a dragon-rider's death like 10 minutes prior to this scene. She also explicitly states she doesn't want the child born here, nor does she want her children to grow up here being used by the Prince. She requests leaving twice from Daemon and he doesn't answer her. Also, I wouldn't apply modern morality to HotD - especially someone given her characterization.
My point is WHY did she suicide at all? I'm guessing they did the csection, the baby was dead already, she thought she was dying as well, so burning was preferable to a death in bed. But it wasn't clear, to me at least, what actually happened and what the status of the baby is (I know from the book).

So to my non book reading wife it looked like rather than undergo C section Laena staggers out to be immoliated INSTEAD of allowing any measures to save the baby att he cost of her own life.

Laena certainly puts to rest the theory that Daemon may be impotent with a dominate woman. She seemed very in control and forceful, yet Daemon knocked her up at least 3 times.

Did anyone catch the new black guy on the council? A replacement for Corlys? He is bald so can't tell if he is supposed to be a Velaryon or not.
 

jason10mm

Gold Member
Let's take a vote.

Who thinks Alicent will let her daughter Helena wed Rhaenyra's son Jace to put an end to this squabbling so we get 3 seasons of jousting, dragon riding , and putting the hurt on Dorne and the Stepstones with no more family drama???

Who says aye? Surely no naysayers here? :p
 
All that scheming was straight up GoT again. Feels good.

The cast swap wasn't as jarring as I thought it would be. Everyone did a great job, although it is sad to see the younger actors go.
 

Banjo64

cumsessed
Unless I’ve missed something, how the fuck can a Kingsguard just straight up bludgeon the proposed King Consort’s sworn protector, a servant to one of the most powerful houses, in a room full of people without being seized? Like did I miss something with that?

That aside I am liking this season a lot, and despite reading ASOIF and knowing about the Targaryen inbreeding it still knocks me sick seeing it on TV.
 
D

Deleted member 1159

Unconfirmed Member
I actually rewound to see if the burned corpse on the beach had a little corpse inside it but didn’t see anything…I’m not sure if the blood on her gown was birthing fluid or from the c section, or if it failed or not since they just don’t show anything. It seems like the baby didn’t make it because they didn’t show it, but maybe that’ll be a surprise next week.

Great episode either way
 

BadBurger

Many “Whelps”! Handle It!
Unless I’ve missed something, how the fuck can a Kingsguard just straight up bludgeon the proposed King Consort’s sworn protector, a servant to one of the most powerful houses, in a room full of people without being seized? Like did I miss something with that?

We discussed it back a few pages ago (not trying to be a smart, just saying). Basically the King's Guard float somewhere between the highest noble and the crown in regards to authority - certainly above the Night's Watch. They're trusted to guard the crown in their most private moments, even in their sleep, after all, and called upon to be generals in times of war. It was also pointed out that this isn't exactly a society beneath a tight rule of law. If neither the king nor queen steps in between a fight between a King's Guard and random no-name knight, why would anyone else? Especially when doing so could mean being killed.

Remember, Jaime Lannister stabbed the king he was sworn to protect in the back then sat on his throne and nothing - nothing - happened to him. That's the sway the title of King's Guard can have in the right circumstances.
 

Banjo64

cumsessed
We discussed it back a few pages ago (not trying to be a smart, just saying).
Ah I’ll take a look back, I caught up with episode 4&5 last night.

Basically the King's Guard float somewhere between the highest noble and the crown in regards to authority - certainly above the Night's Watch. They're trusted to guard the crown in their most private moments, even in their sleep, after all, and called upon to be generals in times of war. It was also pointed out that this isn't exactly a society beneath a tight rule of law. If neither the king nor queen steps in between a fight between a King's Guard and random no-name knight, why would anyone else? Especially when doing so could mean being killed.
All good points.

Ned considered Jaime killing his men in King’s Landing a crime, however Ned put a higher value on his own men’s life than other Lords.

Remember, Jaime Lannister stabbed the king he was sworn to protect in the back then sat on his throne and nothing - nothing - happened to him. That's the sway the title of King's Guard can have in the right circumstances.
Fair comment again (y)
 

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
I actually rewound to see if the burned corpse on the beach had a little corpse inside it but didn’t see anything…I’m not sure if the blood on her gown was birthing fluid or from the c section, or if it failed or not since they just don’t show anything. It seems like the baby didn’t make it because they didn’t show it, but maybe that’ll be a surprise next week.

Great episode either way

No she overheard the discussion and she didn't want to force her husband to make that choice, so she ended her life and the child's life knowing what happened to the previous queen. It is kind of dumb, but when you think both people will die you can come up with do it quick with dragon fire.
 

Elysion

Banned
So are we supposed to believe that those two black girls are actually Daemon’s biological daughters? Because there’s no way kids who are supposed to be only 1/4 black are that dark (remember, their mother Laena herself is only 1/2 black). They look more black than Laenor, who’s 1/2 black. Then there’s the fact that the show has repeatedly hinted at the fact that Daemon might have problems ‘performing’, if you know what I mean.

Otherwise this is a bad casting decision imo.
 

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
So are we supposed to believe that those two black girls are actually Daemon’s biological daughters? Because there’s no way kids who are supposed to be only 1/4 black are that dark (remember, their mother Laena herself is only 1/2 black). They look more black than Laenor, who’s 1/2 black. Then there’s the fact that the show has repeatedly hinted at the fact that Daemon might have problems ‘performing’, if you know what I mean.

Otherwise this is a bad casting decision imo.

I thought it was weird that the girls don't have their father's hair. They make a big deal about every kid having their father's hair but these Valerian girls don't have their father's.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
They did such a good job explaining how the dragons bond to you, then the moment Laena was asking Vhagar to torch her, you can feel the emotion that she didn't want to do it, not until she realized Laena was suffering and probably going to die anyways. Powerful way to go!
 
Last edited:

jason10mm

Gold Member
So are we supposed to believe that those two black girls are actually Daemon’s biological daughters? Because there’s no way kids who are supposed to be only 1/4 black are that dark (remember, their mother Laena herself is only 1/2 black). They look more black than Laenor, who’s 1/2 black. Then there’s the fact that the show has repeatedly hinted at the fact that Daemon might have problems ‘performing’, if you know what I mean.

Otherwise this is a bad casting decision imo.
It is certainly a tough casting choice given the self-inflicted wound of making Velareyons black and then having to limit yourself to convincing mixed race actors. The older Laenor looks pretty mixed, not so much the older Laena. I REALLY hope they have a scene of Jace and Luc meeting Baela and Rhaena (Daemons twin daughters) and there being some comment about skin tone. To just ignore it and focus on hair color seems borderline insulting (but seems to be the way they are going).

I gotta say though, those ladies look STUNNING with that curly white hair, it really works for the women FAR FAR better than those white dreads do for the men IMHO. Corlys is the only actor that pulls it off, though older Laenor does ok. Young Laenor and brother Velaryon though...ooph.
 
D

Deleted member 1159

Unconfirmed Member
They did such a good job explaining how the dragons bond to you, then the moment Laena was asking Vhagar to torch her, you can feel the emotion that he didn't want to do it, not until he realized she was suffering and probably going to die anyways. Powerful way to go!
Yeah, they really are handling the dragon…mechanics…? Lore? quite well. They nailed that scene with the hesitation and the realization and understanding on Vhagar’s face looking natural. And they seemed much more massive in this episode than previous ones, not sure if they’re purposefully trying to show their growth over time or just my perception.

Honestly the best part of the final seasons of GoT was the dragon porn, like the assault on the loot train or the fight during the Long Night episode.

Nothing tops the GOAT though:

sb3M09I.jpg
 
D

Deleted member 1159

Unconfirmed Member
Movie was so dumb, but the dragon was amazingly good. Loved Sean Connery as a dragon.
And who can forget the theme which seemed to be slapped on to every trailer for the following 5 years or so:
(@2:29)

But really HotD so far is a pretty masterful mix of moving things along, while also giving you all the info you need so things make sense rather than being rushed and happening for no apparent reason, like the final seasons of GoT. It’s moving fast, but the reasons for everything happening seem clear rather than convoluted. And the focus on the main characters hopefully means we won’t have a bunch of plot threads going nowhere.
 
My point is WHY did she suicide at all? I'm guessing they did the csection, the baby was dead already, she thought she was dying as well, so burning was preferable to a death in bed. But it wasn't clear, to me at least, what actually happened and what the status of the baby is (I know from the book).

So to my non book reading wife it looked like rather than undergo C section Laena staggers out to be immoliated INSTEAD of allowing any measures to save the baby att he cost of her own life.
Yeah I didn't read the books either. I guess I just didn't put that much thought into it but now I see a few complaints online that this scene wasn't well explained which seems fair. It just seemed to me she was suffering, delirious/dying, covered in blood, so she went to her dragon to give her a quick death. She indicated in the earlier scene her thought process towards death. I don't know what happened to the unborn child I assumed it died within her or we'll find out later.

I was more focused on why Daemon wasn't stopping her. He didn't run after her or anything, and it's not like she was moving very fast - when he shows up on the beach he's just briskly walking. Daemon's first wife's death raised some questions, this wife's death does too for me. He had a really detached demeanor towards her earlier in the episode. I did hear that in the books he loves her deeply, but maybe that wasn't really the case?
 

Methos#1975

Member
Yeah I didn't read the books either. I guess I just didn't put that much thought into it but now I see a few complaints online that this scene wasn't well explained which seems fair. It just seemed to me she was suffering, delirious/dying, covered in blood, so she went to her dragon to give her a quick death. She indicated in the earlier scene her thought process towards death. I don't know what happened to the unborn child I assumed it died within her or we'll find out later.

I was more focused on why Daemon wasn't stopping her. He didn't run after her or anything, and it's not like she was moving very fast - when he shows up on the beach he's just briskly walking. Daemon's first wife's death raised some questions, this wife's death does too for me. He had a really detached demeanor towards her earlier in the episode. I did hear that in the books he loves her deeply, but maybe that wasn't really the case?
He knew she was doomed either way and she had already professed she wished to die as a dragon rider. I took the scene as him coming to the realization that this was the only way.
 

taizuke

Member
And they seemed much more massive in this episode than previous ones, not sure if they’re purposefully trying to show their growth over time or just my perception.

Dragons grow for their entire lives but if you noticed Vhagar was particularly bigger that's because she is. Vhagar is the biggest and strongest dragon currently in Westeros. She is said to have come close to the size and strength of Balerion the dread.
 
D

Deleted member 1159

Unconfirmed Member
Dragons grow for their entire lives but if you noticed Vhagar was particularly bigger that's because she is. Vhagar is the biggest and strongest dragon currently in Westeros. She is said to have come close to the size and strength of Balerion the dread.
Right, Vhagar seemed noticeably bigger but it’s been a few weeks so I wasn’t sure if that was actually the case to match the fact they just keep getting bigger with age, or if I just didn’t remember how big she was.
 

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
Right, Vhagar seemed noticeably bigger but it’s been a few weeks so I wasn’t sure if that was actually the case to match the fact they just keep getting bigger with age, or if I just didn’t remember how big she was.
In GoT they talk about how all the dragons started getting smaller and smaller and didn't know why.
 
Top Bottom