Interesting but inconclusive without taking into account the firing rates and accuracy.Lince said:
Especially for the shotgun analysis, I would have expected a bit more disclosure of results instead of "it's all over the place". What does that mean? If they fired ten shots at x distance, I want to know how many did damage and how many didn't. It seems to me they could have that information but toss it to the side as irrelevant, which it really isn't.
Same for assault rifle vs assault rifle and magnum vs sniper rifle. If you don't factor in firing rates and accuracy at all, you can only reach wrong conclusions.