nicoga3000
Saint Nic
SnS got a bad rap in Tri because elemental weapons get a kick in the balls when the weapon variety is limited. That will not be a problem this time around.
Although DS kinda steals its thunder just by existing, I think DS' options for status weapons are significantly worse than SnS in this outing.
I still say there's no better weapon for learning a new monster whether you're new or have been playing for 300 hours. Best mobility, attacks you don't need to commit to since you can roll out of anything, and guarding for emergencies. Plus you can use items without putting it away. And you don't need to worry about getting in the way of allies since it has such narrow attacks.
Funny story - I beat my first Alatreon mostly solo with a crappy sleep SnS. I just wanted the urgent out of the way so I joined some sleep bombers - one of them carted twice early on so they all dropped out of the quest. I just said screw it and kept fighting - he went down with less than 30 seconds left on the clock.
I've only ever been a Lance user, so I can't comment myself. I think I'd really like to explore other options this time around, though. Good to know that options exist in this edition (and it's always fun to hear stories of other hunters coming out on top!).