-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
PoliGAF Thread of First Debate Election 2008 - GAF doesn't know shit
- Thread starter Amir0x
- Start date
- Status
WickedAngel
Banned
RubxQub said:
Really. This is the best example of what I was talking about; he was cordial and allowed McCain to rant up to a certain point but he skewered him here and you better believe that that shit will stick.
Guybrush Threepwood
Banned
Frenck said:
A lot of people could beat Palin in a debate.
Tyrone Slothrop
Banned
As i sort of expected, i don't think this will be any kind of a game changer. it was a historic event and can be picked apart in any much way, but i didn't really notice how this would change the current state of the race, with mccain panicking and obama surging ahead as if the palin/convention bounce never happened. either way, there's still more debates to go. i guess the VP is the next big thing and then this election is more or less out of the woods.
typhonsentra
Banned
Luntz's focus group picked Obama by a wide margin. People gave a lot of different answers but McCain's bad attitude was a factor which came up.Door2Dawn said:
Instigator
Banned
Bumblebeetuna said:
You end the occupation in Iraq and use a fraction of those troops to finish the fight in afghanistan. Cheaper.
ManDudeChild
Member
Crisis said:
McCain showed more "loud" anger (god i hope that makes sense I dont have the time to be dragged into a lame semantics debate), but Obama was angry almost the entire time. I am actually suprised more haven't commented on this. It was written all over his face and in his body language. Don't get me wrong I again reiterate I believe the debate was a draw as far as what the two of them actually did (the aftermath will unfold in the coming days), but Obama has quite the temper too.
I strongly believe that McCain came off very poorly in his mannerisms and quips. He did do better on the Russian issues IMO, but overall Obama had better attacks, did a better job of weaving his platform into every issue, and I think most people saw his intelligence come through well.
SpeedingUptoStop
will totally Facebook friend you! *giggle* *LOL*
Is there any place online where I can watch it in it's entirety?
Grizzlyjin
Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
I don't think that ad is going to hurt Obama that much. After the primaries, you start moving toward the center to get independent voters. One of the biggest attacks McCain launched against Obama tonight was that he was too far on the left to agree with Republicans. That ad contradicts the idea that Obama is too far on the left.
Hellsing321
Member
I had work tonight so I missed the debate. How did Obama do, and what's the general consensus of how each of them did tonight?
chaostrophy
Member
I think a lot of people here don't understand that regular people have different standards of civility and decorum than Internet forum dwellers. Obama catered to them, not to us.
Saint Gregory
Member
People seem to forget the 2000 and 2004 debates. Gore and Kerry wiped the floor with Bush in all those debates but couldn't help but come across as huge dicks (especially Gore) in the process. In the olden days the guy that won debate was the guy that was the most informed but in today's world the guy that wins is the one who's the most likable.
DeathbyVolcano
Banned
I'm telling you, the only ones calling a clear McCain victory are in all honesty cynics at heart. Glass half empty, all the time.
typhonsentra
Banned
Don't be, you just haven't bothered to read his past posts, the guy has been trolling every thread since he joined in the same contrarian manner since he joined.aceface said:
Chiggs said:
I think people underestimate how poorly Republicans thought Obama would do. People who've been followers of McCain's have been told over and over how inexperienced Obama was, how facile and ego seeking. And while Obama might not have knocked it out of the park, he stood up to a 26 year Senator, never got lost or confused, and held his own.
At least, that's the only explanation I can think of for the weirdly pro-Obama real-time audience polling and the number of conservative pundits crediting Obama with a win.
Broseybrose
Member
fox reporter to biden: are you going to be condescending towards palin in the debate?
biden: no, im not going to do what john did.
biden: no, im not going to do what john did.
Hellsing321 said:
Poligaf is in freakout mode.
In reality Obama did just fine, and held his own on foreign policy and really beat McCain on the early part of the debate on domestic issues.
Probably a slight Obama win, and the next 2 debates will go better for him + the VP debate.
kkaabboomm
Member
http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2008/09/26/1456639.aspx
because i know some of you are curious what hillary would say
because i know some of you are curious what hillary would say
MaddenNFL64
Member
See, you fuckers think Obama being cordial would fuck with him. People LIKE Obama, and his cool demeanor when they hear him. They just do.
One of Obama's best segments.kkaabboomm said:
Some random thoughts.
- Obama won the domestic policy debate. He was able to make McCain's entire spending rant seem small and narrow ("$18 billion is important. $300 billion is really important.") McCain was never able to answer that.
- McCain hit the emotional notes on the foreign policy portion of the debate in response to Obama hammering his judgment. The bracelet, "I love veterans", etc. On substance he was wrong, lying or avoiding the topic, but he hit the right emotional notes. Overall this segment was a draw in terms of the impressions people take away.
- Speaking of impressions. It's pretty clear McCain fucking HATES Obama. He came across as a testy, crabby old man. Obama was reasoned and steady. I hope that's what lasts, in this era when sighing too much can cost you a debate.
So the one thing I personally wish Obama handled better was the issue of meeting with "evil dictators" I agree with his stance but I wish he could have better addressed McCain's claim that meeting with these leaders somehow legitimizes them more than refusing to meet with them. Either way it can fuel propaganda for these leaders because it is still a choice by the great and powerful America made specifically about how to deal with their nation and that's what most legitimizes these leaders, that they are able to force some reaction from America and cause us to enact or change our own policy because of them.
It's the most basic strategy of an attention whore - any attention is good attention - and it's ironic that McCain tries to deny it given it's been his strategy for months now.
It's the most basic strategy of an attention whore - any attention is good attention - and it's ironic that McCain tries to deny it given it's been his strategy for months now.
I would say that's about right. I do think Obama did better than McCain on the economic side of things, and I think he really held his own against McCain during the foreign policy stuff. I do think McCain did a very good job underscoring his experience dealing with foreign affairs, though, and it's hard to argue against that laundry list of crises he has dealt with, regardless of your position (which is why Obama didn't even try to argue against those points).BrandNew said:
Holding his own against McCain on foreign policy, though, is the best possible result for Obama. McCain is too knowledgeable and too experienced on foreign affairs for Obama to be able to clearly "defeat him" in that area, and the fact is that Obama is the one who needs to prove himself more in that sphere. By being able to go blow by blow with McCain, weathering McCain's strongest points and attacks, and even being able to stick him a few times, Obama proved he can hold his own with a veteran statesman.
Overall, I thought it was a surprisingly debate-like debate. And I thought both of them handled it very well, albeit with their own styles. I do think McCain came off as a cantankerous old man a few times and was more condescending in general while Obama was more cordial and diplomatic, but it was quite an interesting debate rather than a round of alternating speeches (which is what presidential debates have been more like the last few elections).
Sooo, yeah, there's a lot here that both sides can claim victory on, but I think the results favor Obama a bit more.
Initial impression of the debate:
By the time the initial statements had been made and the rebuttals began, I could barely remember what the question was.
Second impression of the debate:
Hot damn, there have got to be millions of better ways to spend 90 minutes.
By the time the initial statements had been made and the rebuttals began, I could barely remember what the question was.
Second impression of the debate:
Hot damn, there have got to be millions of better ways to spend 90 minutes.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked