Support NeoGAF

[Pegosaurus]

guess my lack of Spiderman knowledge shows

the Joker just seems more psychotic to me than the GG for some reason. more unpredictable too, but Spiderman doesn't have a no kill rule like Batman.

Carnage is pretty crazy too though

 

[The Silver]

If he didn't go insane from learning Gwen had two children with Norman, I think he'll be okay with a clown

why'd you have to remind of this, now im pissed off again.

this is worse than learning that Bruce banged Barbera in the DCAU

 

[zeemumu]

Spidey would probably destroy Joker through puns alone. Joker loves being the center of comedic attention, and it's happened before where he was able get thrown off of his game by a heckler.

And Batman has explosive batarangs and most likely some sort of sonic device (being a bat, and all). Either should deal with Venom or Carnage fairly easily.

 

[……forgetit]

There are hundreds of multiverse's within both Marvel and DC. I don't think we can arbitrarily write off one version of the joker when that particular version isn't even doing anything that the Joker couldn't or wouldn't normally do.

Can we quit with this "all realities are valid" bs too? It's like people can't accept that there is an official canon in both universes, after all if we're taking any version of the characters we'd have to include this fucker.

 

[Calamari41]

And Batman has explosive batarangs and most likely some sort of sonic device (being a bat, and all). Either should deal with Venom or Carnage fairly easily.

Is Bats going to survive long enough to figure out that specific weakness?

 

[Spring-Loaded]

why'd you have to remind of this, now im pissed off again.

this is worse than learning that Bruce banged Barbera in the DCAU

That wasn't the bad part. That was clear in that one Batwoman movie and in Batman Beyond. Learning that

Spoiler

Barbara apparently got pregnant, and seemingly miscarried

was a bit much though

 

[Manmademan]

Is Bats going to survive long enough to figure out that specific weakness?

he'd probably get desperate and try whipping out a kryptonite ring first.

seriously though. Venom isn't captain ultra- he's not going to faint at the first lit match or loud sound. Bruce doesn't carry around the kind of sonic firepower necessary to take out a Venom or Carnage that's coming to kill him.

 

[Mudcrab]

Spiderman villains are more powerful, but Batman villains are better at being villains.

Norman Osborn, America's last hero.

 

[flaxknuckles]

Is Bats going to survive long enough to figure out that specific weakness?

He's beaten Clayface before numerous times so I'm pretty sure the writers would find a way.

 

[Manmademan]

Norman Osborn, America's last hero.

i lost it at "smells like death, blondes, and victory."

 

[flaxknuckles]

i lost it at "smells like death, blondes, and victory."

I was just about to comment on that. That's so cold

 

[Mudcrab]

i lost it at "smells like death, blondes, and victory."

It's his face that sells it.

 

[SargerusBR]

Spider-Man villains, because MARVEL

 

[Gleethor]

Can we quit with this "all realities are valid" bs too? It's like people can't accept that there is an official canon in both universes, after all if we're taking any version of the characters we'd have to include this fucker.

My point is that its silly to say "but that was Injustice! doesn't count!" when the characters in the Injustice verse(s) stick pretty close to DC "official canon" as you say. Furthermore, there's a teensy bit of irony in attempting to stick to canon within the context of a hypothetical, definitely non-canonical villain list-war.

 

[……forgetit]

My point is that its silly to say "but that was Injustice! doesn't count!" when the characters in the Injustice verse(s) stick pretty close to DC "official canon" as you say.

Hmm..... Ehh, I can except it.

I mean I see where you're coming from.

 

[Gleethor]

Hmm..... Ehh, I can except it.

I mean I see where you're coming from.

Cool. and honestly I would welcome opening the floodgates for multiverse variations of characters because that makes a discussion such as this even more interesting in my opinion.

 

[The Silver]

That wasn't the bad part. That was clear in that one Batwoman movie and in Batman Beyond. Learning that

Spoiler

Barbara apparently got pregnant, and seemingly miscarried

was a bit much though

yeah that's what im talking about, i didn't feel like typing that all out.

 

[……forgetit]

yeah that's what im talking about, i didn't feel like typing that all out.

I forgot all of that, darn it guys.

 

[Schweinehund]

Can we quit with this "all realities are valid" bs too? It's like people can't accept that there is an official canon in both universes, after all if we're taking any version of the characters we'd have to include this fucker.

Real talk

Ultimate Spiderman is the best spiderman game.

 

[SargerusBR]

Norman Osborn, America's last hero.

 

[Gr1mLock]

Batman villains are more or less tailored for Batman specifically. They seem out of place outside of Gotham, even in the DC universe. Deathstroke is easily the coolest and most dangerous of the bunch. Throw any of the others against Aquaman and they'd get beaten half way to death with a fish.

 

[Seven Force]

Oh man, Electro took out Nate Grey once? This I've gotta see.

 

[Manmademan]

Oh man, Electro took out Nate Grey once? This I've gotta see.

there you go

 

[……forgetit]

Real talk

Ultimate Spiderman is the best spiderman game.

Heck yeah, freaking great game.

 

[G-Fex]

YOU GUYS DISSIN 90's EXTREEEEEEEEEEEEMENESS?

You'd rather see fucking tracing of actors then?

For shame comic gaf

 

[Manmademan]

YOU GUYS DISSIN 90's EXTREEEEEEEEEEEEMENESS?

You'd rather see fucking tracing of actors then?

For shame comic gaf

Spoiler

EXTREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEME

 

[Sinatar]

Spoiler

EXTREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEME

.

 

[lazygecko]

 

[Rastafarian42]

Spiderman villains easily.

/thread.

 

[Manmademan]

Too....Extreme....can't....DFsdkfhsdlkfjsldk

 

[comedy bomb]

Maybe if you tried to pair them off in 1vs1 matches you might get more interesting results?
Lizard vs Killer Croc
Kraven the Hunter vs Ras Al Ghul
Sandman vs Clayface
Vulture vs Penguin
etc etc

Actually some interesting 1 on 1 match ups if you do it this way. I'd add Venom vs Bane, Black Cat vs Catwoman, Mysterio vs Scarecrow, Green Goblin vs Joker.

OT who wins between Spider-Man 2099 and Batman Beyond?

 

[Megadragon15]

Batman has Bat-Mite. His villains are unstoppable because that 5th dimensional imp solos all Spider-Man villains.

 

[Burt]

Burt vs Fun = Burt wins

Haha yeah, sorry. I was cranky this morning.

Still think I stand by Joker taking all though.

 

[G-Fex]

BLOOD GUNS OF FIRING WILD GUN EXTREME

 

[Jarmel]

Has Peter Parker actually killed someone before? Carnage, Norman Osborne and others have very high body counts as well. I think Spider-man is actually one of the least likely Marvel heroes to cross that line.

My understanding is that Spidey doesn't have that much of a qualm with killing. If you push him close enough to the edge, he gets serious and that's when all bets are off.

depends on whether you're talking about their power levels or them as characters

because a lot of spider-man's villains are just "I have superpowers now I'm going to rob banks. mwa ha ha ha ha" while peter deals with personal problems. The only ones that really have any depth to them are goblin, ock, kraven and maybe one or two more i'm forgetting.

Well it's not just about their personal stuff but their powers and how they're threatening to Peter. Kingpin for example threatened Aunt May and there was Venom's possibility of just completely ruining Peter's personal life. Mysterio also is a lot of fun and can be something else when he gets going.

Norman Osborn, America's last hero.

Somebody had a ton of fun writing that speech.

 

[Manmademan]

Actually some interesting 1 on 1 match ups if you do it this way. I'd add Venom vs Bane, Black Cat vs Catwoman, Mysterio vs Scarecrow, Green Goblin vs Joker.

OT who wins between Spider-Man 2099 and Batman Beyond?

Probably O'hara, (2099), since he's significantly smarter (there goes the marvel genius thing again) and those talons of his would probably shred the batsuit if he got his hands on it.

 

[Deleted member 13876]

My understanding is that Spidey doesn't have the much of a qualm with killing. If you push him close enough to the edge, he gets serious and that's when all bets are off.

He absolutely does. Maiming and disfiguring is another thing altogether though.

 

[Jarmel]

He absolutely does. Maiming and disfiguring is another thing altogether though.

He tries to avoid it by and largely, but he's tried to kill Norman a couple of times if I remember correctly(one was over Ben's death).

 

[Style]

Wouldn't Deathstroke pose a huge threat to them alone? He is basically Deadpool and Deadpool have won over these guys numerous times. He also got the strength of Spider-man, can stand punches from Lobo and quick enough reflexes to track even the Flash. At his prime he should be able to take couple of them down by himself. He can use the other villains as a diversion.

 

[The Silver]

Spidey wanted to murder the fuck out of Scarlett Witch and Magneto.(though who didn't want to kill those two during House of M)

 

[Slayven]

Wouldn't Deathstroke pose a huge threat to them alone? He is basically Deadpool and Deadpool have won over these guys numerous times. He also got the strength of Spider-man, can stand punches from Lobo and quick enough reflexes to track even the Flash. At his prime he should be able to take couple of them down by himself. He can use the other villains as a diversion.

Nothing can be farther from the truth.

 

[Deleted member 13876]

He tries to avoid it by and largely, but he's tried to kill Norman a couple of times if I remember correctly(one was over Ben's death).

Current Spider-Man was traumatized by not being able to save someone he now has an absolute "no one dies" rule, which includes the villains.

 

[Style]

Nothing can be farther from the truth.

If Deadpool is Coca-Cola, Deathstroke is Coca-Cola Zero. Happy? The other points still stand!

 

[Manmademan]

Wouldn't Deathstroke pose a huge threat to them alone?

lol hell no.

He is basically Deadpool and Deadpool have won over these guys numerous times

Deadpool has a healing factor so much better than deathstroke it's not really useful to bring them up in the same conversation.

He also got the strength of Spider-man

Nowhere close. Spider man is *conservatively* about 20 tons, and it's been implied during superior spider man that Parker has been holding back the entire time. No one actually knew how strong he really was.

can stand punches from Lobo and quick enough reflexes to track even the Flash.

I shouldn't have to explain these.

At his prime he should be able to take couple of them down by himself. He can use the other villains as a diversion.

Deathstroke would take out the scrub tier (shocker, rhino, maybe vulture) but everyone else is a bit much for him.

 

[Slayven]

If Deadpool is Coca-Cola, Deathstroke is Coca-Cola Zero. Happy? The other points still stand!

Deathstroke's healing is nowhere effective or as fast as Deadpool's

 

[Manmademan]

Current Spider-Man was traumatized by not being able to save someone he now has an absolute "no one dies" rule, which includes the villains.

not as of ASM #700

 

[SargerusBR]

This is now a Rob Liefeld thread?

 

[Manmademan]

This is now a Rob Liefeld thread?

you know, looking up those images I'm actually gobsmacked at how many shitty one-off 90s comics that he did- well, either him or people who REALLY wanted to draw like him.

 

[Style]

This is what I get for trying to meddle with comics GAF.

Deathstroke's healing is nowhere effective or as fast as Deadpool's

Yeah, I've read Deadpool Kills the Marvel Universe. He is borderline immortal.

 

[Manmademan]

Yeah, I've read Deadpool Kills the Marvel Universe. He is borderline immortal.

That one is obviously not meant to be taken seriously.