Hey guys I don't know how many of you are in the hedge fund/investment management industry - but I run a pretty large portfolio for some clients and just thought I'd share my thinking around how I size up earnings/financial results. Obviously I don't want to get too technical with the earnings since there are thousands of ways to interpret it, so let me just be brief and speak on specific operational issues. I'd love to get some feedback from anyone here who actually knows what they are talking about (fanboys please don't comment if you don't know what a balance sheet is or what liquidity means).
I just opened a massive short position on ATVI and a massive long position on ERTS
ATVI balance sheet = crap - they have 9 billion in assets labeled as Goodwill based on the reverse merger with Blizzard, unfortunately the forward P/E on the merger valuation Goodwill is based on valuations from pre-September levels at the peak of media tech cycle. ATVI was essentially cashless prior to injection by Vivendi, they are burning through cash at a ridiculous rate even despite beating revenue projections by 40% - most of their spending is towards rehashing existing product lines, majority of their R&D spend is not for new products meaning they will be caught in a CAPEX trap in another year and may need to raise cash/debt
Further, despite Modern Warfare 2 overhype and likely positive reception for Starcraft 2 in Q4/Q1 2010, current forward earnings place too much weight on Guitar Hero. Analysts attributing per-SKU revenue for GH at 2007 and 2008 levels, but how many people are going to repurchase instruments and other crap all over again? Even if you account for DLC which is expanding, earnings will need to go above and beyond to achieve justified valuations relative to other competitors.
Goldman calls it a "conviction buy" based on "solid technical momentum" - every stock they label a conviction buy has historically tanked in 3-6 months.
Proof is in the pudding - ATVI beat revenues by 40% to Street estimates, and the stock struggled to break technical resistance points because of balance sheet game ATVI is playing.
ERTS on the other hand shows similar cashflow levels, they sufficiently burned through most of their new product R&D spending (unlikely to be caught next year and can rehash product cycle again) and have written down significant amounts of goodwill to account for post-crash market (Pandemonium was completely written off and spun off to reduce costs). Further, they have Star Wars MMO coming up which may not be popular globally, but will create stable revenue streams for the company and allow it to establish a foothold in the online MMORPG space that it was previously missing. ERTS also has the most expansive and efficient distribution network and will be publishing id's Rage, and has a deal in-place with Valve now for product distribution.
Other positions I have -
SHORT NINTENDO (7974.OSA) (upward pressure on Yen currency will screw up actual delivered earnings for Q2/Q3/Q4, risk probability of weak winter product lineup to effect sell-through of console in Japan, revival of PS3/PSP in Japanese market to affect margins especially if response is price drop)
LONG TAKE-TWO (TTWO) (solid product portfolio lineup, high-margin earnings from future DLC for GTA4 userbase, little to no debt meaning, excellent cash position, resolved accounting problems, at <$1B valuation to be target of speculative take over rumors meaning sell when reaches 30% upside target to current prices)
UBI is the only other player I am really interested in, but it's difficult to forecast how their games will perform given critical reception has been crap for their past few products but they sold decently well. However most retailers have been negative on their upcoming products given so much AC1 product had to be sold at massive discounts and UBI didn't rebate anything to them. On the other hand there are rumors that UBI may be the target of a hostile takeover by someone like Disney which could destroy any short position. I am staying away for now.