• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The New Yorker: The Best Video Games of 2015

C

Crayolan

Member
I've noticed that most lists from gaming sites feature Mario Maker as their one Nintendo game while lists from non game-focused sites tend to feature Splatoon as their Nintendo top pick, usually alongside other games.

What is with gaming outlets and Mario Maker?
 
F

Ferrio

Banned
danowat said:
Did Divinity and Wasteland get in the NPD top 10?

The list just smacks of someone trying to get overertly cool.
Click to expand...

Some people just are tired of AAA gaming and prefer indies. None of those games aren't deserving of making a top 10 list.
 
P

phanphare

Banned
nice list. I like seeing these non-gaming site lists, most of them have Splatoon as the best Nintendo title released this year which is correct. I feel like the gaming outlets are giving the nod to Super Mario Maker, which kind of makes sense considering the context but Splatoon is in another league imo.

Crayolan said:
I've noticed that most lists from gaming sites feature Mario Maker as their one Nintendo game while lists from non game-focused sites tend to feature Splatoon as their Nintendo top pick, usually alongside other games.

What is with gaming outlets and Mario Maker?
Click to expand...

haha, I noticed the same thing
 
ItsTheNew

ItsTheNew

I believe any game made before 1997 is "essentially cave man art."
So is this just the year of people putting random indie games on top 10 lists instead of some truly excellent games just to rile some clicks?
 
BennyBlanco

BennyBlanco

aka IMurRIVAL69
I like this guy's list because it seems to be coming from a genuine place even if I don't agree.

Is Sunless Sea really that good?
 
S

Sheentak

Member
Wow ive only heard of 6 out of the top 11 games. I feel like im a pretty big enthusiast so i should have heard of these.
Has there been any significant gaf discussion on the lesser known titles?
 
D

DrArchon

Member
Crayolan said:
I've noticed that most lists from gaming sites feature Mario Maker as their one Nintendo game while lists from non game-focused sites tend to feature Splatoon as their Nintendo top pick, usually alongside other games.

What is with gaming outlets and Mario Maker?
Click to expand...

I get the impression that gaming sites, with their gaming focused fanbases, are in a better position to get a lot out of Mario Maker because they can play fans' levels, have their levels get played and get feedback, etc. Non-gaming sites just have to use the tools that came with Mario Maker, which weren't that great when it launched.

That's my thought anyway.
 
G

Geg

Member
Crayolan said:
I've noticed that most lists from gaming sites feature Mario Maker as their one Nintendo game while lists from non game-focused sites tend to feature Splatoon as their Nintendo top pick, usually alongside other games.

What is with gaming outlets and Mario Maker?
Click to expand...

Yeah I've noticed that too. Feels like a lot of those focus more on "AAA" games and just throw in Mario Maker as their token Nintendo nominee because it has Mario in the title
 
P

phanphare

Banned
DrArchon said:
I get the impression that gaming sites, with their gaming focused fanbases, are in a better position to get a lot out of Mario Maker because they can play fans' levels, have their levels get played and get feedback, etc. Non-gaming sites just have to use the tools that came with Mario Maker, which weren't that great when it launched.

That's my thought anyway.
Click to expand...

and on the flip side I feel like gaming sites would be more critical of the minor gripes with Splatoon vs. a non-gaming site whose opinion might be more like "the game's awesome, who cares?"
 
E

enigmatic_alex44

Whenever a game uses "middleware," I expect mediocrity. Just see how poor TLOU looks.
MGSV getting one step closer to that top spot!

az478XS.gif


Splatoon and Xenoblade X!

az478XS.gif


No mention of that trash Witcher 3!

az478XS.gif
 
A

Aaron D.

Member
ItsTheNew said:
So is this just the year of people putting random indie games on top 10 lists instead of some truly excellent games just to rile some clicks?
Click to expand...

Instead of digging into this I'll just put a positive spin on it and say that I'm over the moon that smaller titles are being recognized from all the major outlets.

Her Story, Sunless Sea, Life Is Strange, Undertale, Prune and more aren't just getting token nods here and there, they're getting multiple mentions from LOTS of outlets.

What a fantastic time to be a gamer.
 
M

Myggen

Member
Confused Cheeseburger said:
Wait, Simon Parkin? Like ex-eurogamer?

I'm not even mad, Fallout isn't here. I respect the hell out of eurogamer writers. Will read this list.
Click to expand...

He still writes for Eurogamer from time to time. He seems to be more of a freelancer now who writes mainly for The New Yorker website and Eurogamer(?). He got a monthly column in The Guardian very recently too.
 
O

Omadahl

Banned
Sunless Sea has been on my steam wishlist for a long time now. If it's discounted at all next week, I'm definitely buying it.
 
C

Confused Cheeseburger

Member
Myggen said:
He still writes for Eurogamer from time to time. He seems to be more of a freelancer now who writes mainly for The New Yorker website and Eurogamer(?). He got a monthly column in The Guardian very recently too.
Click to expand...

Oh, I see. No Fallout makes sense, because I'm pretty sure I saw his byline for the guardian. By Hell yes, Bloodborne.
 
C

CHC

Member
Definitely confused by his number 2 since he says "It is, at times, a tonal mélange, and clearly the game has been affected by publisher politics: it ends abruptly and incompletely. Nevertheless, this is the final and full realization of a vision...."

I mean if it were the final and full realization, wouldn't it NOT be clear that the game was affected by publisher politics? I don't know, maybe I'm just biased against MGSV, but it seems like he had all the same criticisms that I did, so who knows what the deal is. I just see that game as being VERY far from ANY kind of realization, let alone a "final and full" one.
 
Plague Doctor

Plague Doctor

Member
I'd love to see the Fallen London setting get another game that shows off the environment, and lore (preferably more visually immersive and character building). It's really a compelling and awesome setting.

Aaron D. said:
The writing certainly is. Outside of Pillars of Eternity I can't think of better writing and general world lore in 2015.

Unfortunately for me it's also a rouge-like and I SUCK at the genre so I ran into a bit of a wall with the game.
Click to expand...

Amen to all of this.
 
A

Aaron D.

Member
BennyBlanco said:
I like this guy's list because it seems to be coming from a genuine place even if I don't agree.

Is Sunless Sea really that good?
Click to expand...

The writing certainly is. Outside of Pillars of Eternity I can't think of better writing and general world lore in 2015.

Unfortunately for me it's also a rouge-like and I SUCK at the genre so I ran into a bit of a wall with the game.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

[The Verge] Microsoft is now in a handheld gaming PC race
2
79
8K
MisterXDTV replied
Lenovo has unveiled the first true Steam Deck alternative with SteamOS... And even an early next-gen Legion Go prototype
2
52
3K
manlisten replied
Microsoft rolls out Windows 24H2 update
2 3 4
193
19K
Kenpachii replied
Circana December 2024: #1 Black Ops 6 #2 Madden #3 College Football #14 Indiana Jones ; PS5 #1 Units + Rev, NSW #2 Units + Rev
Sales-Age 2 3 4 5
214
9K
Mibu no ookami replied
PlayStation has canceled two more live-service games, from subsidiaries Bend and Bluepoint, Bloomberg has learned
News 16 17 18 19 20
976
38K
Negotiator replied
Top Bottom