Uncharted 4 - A Thief's |Reviews Thread| Nateness Awaits

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jesus Christ, the user reviews on Metacritic...

5/10 - "Not Jak 4"

1/10 - "Sonys Uncharted 4 is the next the order 1886 with a bad story bad gameplay only good thing about this game is the graphics for being a 1080P 30fps game this game trys so hard to be like rise of the tomb raider but fails..."

0/10 - "... Graphics are ok, but you would expect that at 30fps.. but they are not mindblowing.. weak hardware isnt going to change that, however some of the animations are just awful!"
 
Memento said:
Jesus Christ, the user reviews on Metacritic...

5/10 - "Not Jak 4"

1/10 - "Sonys Uncharted 4 is the next the order 1886 with a bad story bad gameplay only good thing about this game is the graphics for being a 1080P 30fps game this game trys so hard to be like rise of the tomb raider but fails..."

0/10 - "... Graphics are ok, but you would expect that at 30fps.. but they are not mindblowing.. weak hardware isnt going to change that, however some of the animations are just awful!"
Click to expand...
Those are some salty fanboys.
 
why are you so concerned about its metacritic anyway

you cant even use the "just something to til the game comes out" bored excuse, cuz the game is out now
 
I'm not a fan of any of the previous Uncharted games as I found them very limited and over rated. I haven't seen this game although I couldn't care less about graphics tbh, I've always thought people overrated these games purely because of the technical feats achieved by ND.
 
Chapter 18 right now, got the game a day early...
I know, opinions and all that, but anything less than a 9,0 for this game is just weird to me. What else could you possibly want? I haven't even finished it yet, and I'm loving every second! Constantly in awe of what ND has done here - I can't even begin to imagine how hard this must've been to create...

Naughty Dog - THANK YOU!

Hope the 10's keep on coming!
 
peace said:
I'm not a fan of any of the previous Uncharted games as I found them very limited and over rated. I haven't seen this game although I couldn't care less about graphics tbh, I've always thought people overrated these games purely because of the technical feats achieved by ND.
Click to expand...

Are you just going to ignore the many impressions and reviews we've had so far praising the gameplay, especially the gunplay?
 
peace said:
I'm not a fan of any of the previous Uncharted games as I found them very limited and over rated. I haven't seen this game although I couldn't care less about graphics tbh, I've always thought people overrated these games purely because of the technical feats achieved by ND.
Click to expand...

Outstanding.
 
Inching up to 95 score, number 63 all time. I guess it will get pulled down again but only 10 spots away from beating the Last of US on Metacritic. Pretty remarkable even if it doesn't succeed to do so since how hard they grade these type of linear games this gen.
 
So is there anything else this year that could even contest UC4 at this point?

I suspected QB would come close but not beat it but i was sorely wrong there, Persona later in the year is only the Japanese release so doubt it will count. Ueda and the remnants of Team Ico might be the only ones that I could guess would have a shot of beating ND at this point for best reviewed game.
 
Apathy said:
So is there anything else this year that could even contest UC4 at this point?

I suspected QB would come close but not beat it but i was sorely wrong there, Persona later in the year is only the Japanese release so doubt it will count. Ueda and the remnants of Team Ico might be the only ones that I could guess would have a shot of beating ND at this point for best reviewed game.
Click to expand...

Yeah, Persona 5 and TLG are the best bets. But even them I dont think so. Too niche, especially P5.
 
Apathy said:
So is there anything else this year that could even contest UC4 at this point?

I suspected QB would come close but not beat it but i was sorely wrong there, Persona later in the year is only the Japanese release so doubt it will count. Ueda and the remnants of Team Ico might be the only ones that I could guess would have a shot of beating ND at this point for best reviewed game.
Click to expand...

Final Fantasy XV. BELIEVE!
 
Memento said:
Jesus Christ, the user reviews on Metacritic...

5/10 - "Not Jak 4"

1/10 - "Sonys Uncharted 4 is the next the order 1886 with a bad story bad gameplay only good thing about this game is the graphics for being a 1080P 30fps game this game trys so hard to be like rise of the tomb raider but fails..."

0/10 - "... Graphics are ok, but you would expect that at 30fps.. but they are not mindblowing.. weak hardware isnt going to change that, however some of the animations are just awful!"
Click to expand...

That's sad, I hope that they are at least kids, cause if adults participate in such pathetic fanboy wars they need to take a deep look into their life, trying to figure out what went wrong.
 
Gurish said:
That's sad, I hope that they are at least kids, cause if adults participate in such pathetic fanboy wars they need to take a deep look into their life, trying to figure out what went wrong.
Click to expand...

you should check what those same users also reviewed. A lot of starfox fans that gave it a 10 calling it a perfect game lol.
 
So having skimmed this thread of what seems to be considered a great game by many what seems to be of most concern is individuals commenting negatively or giving slightly less glowing reviews than people would like. This is of course is the most fun in review threads , especially console exclusive ones.

Review scores are subjective and everyone has opinions but its not always wrong to query them, anyone who believes that many sites and podcasts don't have agendas are fools. Leave people alone for having opinions which you don't agree but if theres a pattern to a site or podcast query it. Having listened to hundreds of hours of podcasts and read games sites for years some are just better at it than others .
 
Gurish said:
That's sad, I hope that they are at least kids, cause if adults participate in such pathetic fanboy wars they need to take a deep look into their life, trying to figure out what went wrong.
Click to expand...

guess you haven't heard of crapgamer, mooch or nxtgen yet have you, ohhhhh boy are you in for a treat
giphy.gif
 
Apathy said:
you should check what those same users also reviewed. A lot of starfox fans that gave it a 10 calling it a perfect game lol.
Click to expand...

lol pretty surprising, thought they are Xbox guys, like since when Nintendo fans are part of such wars anyway :D

JK-Money said:
guess you haven't heard of crapgamer, mooch or nxtgen yet have you, ohhhhh boy are you in for a treat
giphy.gif
Click to expand...

I haven't, sounds like I shouldn't :)
 
Apathy said:
So is there anything else this year that could even contest UC4 at this point?

I suspected QB would come close but not beat it but i was sorely wrong there, Persona later in the year is only the Japanese release so doubt it will count. Ueda and the remnants of Team Ico might be the only ones that I could guess would have a shot of beating ND at this point for best reviewed game.
Click to expand...

Maybe FFXV? Though I think it may go to the bad side of the scores lol mainly because of all the wait and hype after all these years of waiting.
 
Don't sleep on TLG. I mean it will no doubt be smaller in scope. But Journey did win over a lot of people. There's more ways to woo the gaming press as UC4 is proving, I think we are in a time where great storytelling will get highly praised.
 
JK-Money said:
go to youtube and look them up, you'll have an aneurysm within 10 seconds
Click to expand...

Checked the Amazon page, lots of trolls giving it 1 star there as well, I don't mind if someone is very disappointed or expected much more (he is in a miniority but every game has them no matter how good it is) but no way that a true Uncharted fan will give it a 1, here is a typical profile of those guys:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/A1UI8ZB2AL/?tag=neogaf0e-20 (this is the same guy from Metacritic)

lol

And this guy hates EVERYTHING:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/A2I1AVUJN8/?tag=neogaf0e-20

They shouldn't let people who don't have a "purchase verified" tag to review a product, yea most guys are alright and they shouldn't be punished because of some trolls but it's the only way to handle it.
 
Memento said:
Jesus Christ, the user reviews on Metacritic...

5/10 - "Not Jak 4"

1/10 - "Sonys Uncharted 4 is the next the order 1886 with a bad story bad gameplay only good thing about this game is the graphics for being a 1080P 30fps game this game trys so hard to be like rise of the tomb raider but fails..."

0/10 - "... Graphics are ok, but you would expect that at 30fps.. but they are not mindblowing.. weak hardware isnt going to change that, however some of the animations are just awful!"
Click to expand...

User reviews should be not be a thing on metacritic, a like dislike bar might be better with an optional written review.
 
Gurish said:
Checked the Amazon page, lots of trolls giving it 1 star there as well, I don't mind if someone is very disappointed or expected much more (he is in a miniority but every game has them no matter how good it is) but no way that a true Uncharted fan will give it a 1, here is a typical profile of those guys:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/A1UI8ZB2AL/?tag=neogaf0e-20

lol

And this guy hates EVERYTHING:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/A2I1AVUJN8/?tag=neogaf0e-20

They shouldn't let people who don't have a "purchase verified" tag to review a product, yea most guys are alright and they shouldn't be punished because of some trolls but it's the only way to handle it.
Click to expand...
lol, kids...
 
Gurish said:
Checked the Amazon page, lots of trolls giving it 1 star there as well, I don't mind if someone is very disappointed or expected much more (he is in a miniority but every game has them no matter how good it is) but no way that a true Uncharted fan will give it a 1, here is a typical profile of those guys:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/A1UI8ZB2AL/?tag=neogaf0e-20 (this is the same guy from Metacritic)

lol

And this guy hates EVERYTHING:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/A2I1AVUJN8/?tag=neogaf0e-20

They shouldn't let people who don't have a "purchase verified" tag to review a product, yea most guys are alright and they shouldn't be punished because of some trolls but it's the only way to handle it.
Click to expand...

The 1 stars are strong. Too many salt Q.Q
 
Just checked metacritic. It's 4 games away from the 95 titles. At 84 reviews it would take quite a few review scores below the average to make a dent in that 94.

Can't wait to get home and play the highest reviewed game of this generation :p
 
SarusGray said:
The 1 stars are strong. Too many salt Q.Q
Click to expand...

People that can't play the game are indeed salty, that's their way of dealing with it, by telling themselves it's shit, that they don't miss anything and trolling MC and Amazon user reviews, sad like I said.

Frag Waffles said:
Just checked metacritic. It's 4 games away from the 95 titles. At 84 reviews it would take quite a few review scores below the average to make a dent in that 94.

Can't wait to get home and play the highest reviewed game of this generation :p
Click to expand...

Sounds like the 94 is locked regardless of the IGN and (the probably great) EDGE reviews, cool :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Atomfall - Reviews Thread
2 3
106
8K
Humdinger replied
South of Midnight - Reviews Thread
11 12 13 14 15
710
32K
T-Cake replied
Split Fiction - Reviews Thread
2 3
149
10K
AJUMP23 replied
The First Berserker: Khazan - Reviews Thread
4 5 6 7 8
380
22K
Northeastmonk replied
'A Minecraft Movie' | Review Thread
2 3 4
157
7K
LordBritish replied
Top Bottom