Xplatformer
Member
LOL...I never thought of GAF as family until now. Love you guys (And gals)
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
United States Election: Nov 6, 2012 |OT| - Barack Obama Re-elected
- Thread starter Amir0x
- Start date
- Status
LOL...I never thought of GAF as family until now. Love you guys (And gals)
Gary Whitta
Member
If you're so far gone as to question the ethics of basic taxation, the system by which every civil society in history has operated, it's hard to know what approach to take. It's wackadoodle talk.
Depending on the service, it's often a private firm. But yes, as it stands, the local police would eventually become involved.
To be clear, are we talking about the real world or are we doing a thought experiment?
In thought experiment land, this is trivially easy. Do you really need examples?
In the real world, health care costs are an easy example, if I live in a society where it's not possible to get reliable insurance with a preexisting condition. I'm not taking only your money to pay for it, of course. That's a pretty clear case of self-defense.
Edit: If you're looking for general principles then I'd basically refer you to Rawls. There's also a difference between working within an existing process or institution and going around taking money at gunpoint. Both because they're in-principle different things and because the latter is much more likely to actually cause more harm than good.
And I'd still like to know why anyone would think it's generally unethical.
Damn, you Americans do realize pretty much every other MODERN 1st world country does this right? Do you think places like Canada are like some kind of crazy communist wastelands? America is the outlier here.
PS3GamerKyle
Member
Obama/Romney ties country's first polling location in Dixville Notch, New Hampshire! All 10 people have voted. OMG EPIC MELTDOWN CAN START
EmCeeGramr
Member
i discovered the parallel universe that hokahey lives in: http://www.bigheadpress.com/tpbtgn
Thankfully, fantasy land libertarians are also outliers in America
It's easy to avoid a question and use ad hominem attacks. It's another to break it down to the basics and actually debate the ethics of the system at it's core.
P.s. Loved Book of Eli.
You are completely out of your element here, guy. Stop embarrassing yourself.
Elfforkusu
Member
And if the culprit for the alarm is a thief, and if he is caught, how is he brought to justice? I assume you hire a private firm to have him assassinated?
This. Seriously.
Mackenzie 92
Member
So no mirror for that final speech in Iowa?
Please go to Somalia right now, and don't come back until you admit that socialism is a good thing.
EmCeeGramr
Member
P.s. Loved Book of Eli.
You realize that it wasn't portraying a good future, right?
this may happen more than normal I think
Im sorry you dont like my dissenting point of view. That doesnt mean I wont express it simply because Im outnumbered here. I guarantee youd be considered as embarrassing yourself amongst a number of economic scholars I know.
You see, there are valid approaches on both ends of the spectrum. Its okay to be open minded and not insulting.
GREAT! Now this is going to be the story! Someone call Donna and tell her to call up the Murphy's, she's got to convince them to vote for the president!
rohlfinator
Member
DrForester
Kills Photobucket
Romney/Biden administration of hilarity incoming!
Gary Whitta
Member
So what's the other end of the spectrum? No government services, no taxation, everyone just sinks or swims? Are there any examples in world history of a civilization that's flourished or even survived that way?
It's easy to avoid a question and use ad hominem attacks. It's another to break it down to the basics and actually debate the ethics of the system at it's core.
P.s. Loved Book of Eli.
debate the ethics? The ethics are pathetically easy. You promote an extremely selfish ethic of every man for themselves, which i guess is fine if everyone started out on an equal footing. Too bad that that is simple impossible in the real world. After that first generation though, you'll end up with a country with very little social mobility.
Taxation is necessary and ethical because it helps us build a stronger community and a stronger country. This will benefit everyone in the end, not just those few first generation people in your libertarian fantasy land that got insanely wealthy
As if I couldn't point to an extreme socialist state and tell you its your only choice for how it works? Terrible logic.
Joe Shlabotnik
Banned
Oh god CNN got to them first
Yours isn't a valid approach. It borders on absurd. Please name these scholars for me.
Please state the circumstance in which it is ethical for you to use all that society has set up for you and become successful because of society but not give back what it needs in order to function and progress.
It's easy to avoid a question and use ad hominem attacks. It's another to break it down to the basics and actually debate the ethics of the system at it's core.
P.s. Loved Book of Eli.
And once again it's ethical because everyone pays in and everyone then receives public benefits. It would be unethical if one small segment of the population took advantage of the system and benefited overwhelmingly, while a larger part of the population fought for the scraps.
Xplatformer
Member
LOL...I ain't gone get shit done at work manana (California).
Not sure what your point is. Was just taking a moment to tell the guy that politics aside I loved one of his films.
Earthstrike
Member
Where in the world is this? Didn't realize votes are already starting to come in.
Oh I agree, but it shouldn't be the case, because if he misses, it just means that the polls were wrong. He makes no bones about the fact that he's mostly relying on polls to make his prediction, so if the polls are wrong he'll be wrong, too. People should be pissed that the polls are wrong, instead of turning on Nate Silver. But Polls are wrong sometimes. For example, Hillary Vs. Obama in New Hampshire. Everybody missed that. Some by a mile. There are always a few like that, and sometimes it's hard to understand why it happens.
And actually, I think Silver will take a lot of heat even if it is a narrow Romney victory, but he shouldn't, because all he's really saying is that Romney is a long shot, which is obviously true. Any reasonable minded person would have to say a Romney victory would be an upset based on the current polling. Romney would have to outperform the polls to win, thereby defying the odds But long shots occasionally win. Politics is like any sport, you can crunch numbers all day long and run simulated games, but at the end of the day, real people have to go out and take action, which introduces a level of noise and randomness that you can't totally account for when the margins are narrow enough.
Xplatformer
Member
What factor determines if it's ethical or not? Serious question. You seem smart, so I'm open to being educated about a few things.
Gary Whitta
Member
It's a tiny precinct in NH, literally just a handful of votes, that always declares first, right at midnight local time on election day. It has about as much bellwether relevance as Groundhog Day in Punxsatawney.
Was there ever an example of America before It was founded as it was?
Why would people sink without the government?
Unknown One
Member
Maybe he has only driven on private roads, private highways, bought foods that wasn't transported by public highway, used gas that wasn't transported on public highways, gets his water from a private institution or all bottled, home schooled, never went to a public library, and etc.
The list is endless.
The list is endless.
Gary Whitta
Member
Thanks, I'm glad you liked it. Apparently Glenn Beck is a fan too; I don't think he realizes that he was the template for the villain.
You are advocating the total removal of taxation and government services. America has plenty of government services that benefit this country, but we also have to pay taxes. In Somalia, you don't need to pay any taxes nor do you get any government handouts. See? It's simple.
I have the most political boner after watching this.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5jeLjKxv-4
Geez, we don't need your reality check ruining our hype Buzz Killington.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5jeLjKxv-4
Geez, we don't need your reality check ruining our hype Buzz Killington.
So its ethical if I take your property by force assuming I then distribute it in such a way I feel benefits the greater good?
Necromanti
Member
It is ethical because the benefits greatly outnumber the disadvantages. Secondly, the argument in your latter sentence is one that holds no ground in reality. There are people working 2-3 jobs who still cannot afford basic necessities. I'm all for dissenting viewpoints as long as they are grounded in evidence and logic.
Xplatformer
Member
American indian?
It'd be nice to get a positive argument from you. You talk about people jumping on you for your dissenting viewpoint, but I'm not sure you've actually even asserted that it is unethical to forcibly take people's money to pay for government services. And you've yet to even gesture at an argument for it.
Not my property, but a portion of my earnings. Absolutely.
heliosRAzi
Banned
Well, sleeping can take six to hours out of the 24...
kingdaddy157
Banned
Buenas noches damas y caballeros. Hoy quiero hacerles una propuesta. Mañana Es el dia de las elecciones de Los Estados Unidos y ustedes tienen la oportunidad de elejir a este caballo blanco, con especimen de cien dioses y Mexicano como su nuevo Presidente. Yo prometo darles Ciudadania absoluta a todas aquellas personas que imigraron a este pais a buscar un sueño. Un sueño de nunca regresar a la pobresa y echar hacia delante. Mucho mejor, propongo unificar a Los dos paises y llamar el Nuevo país, Los Estados Mexicanos Unidos de America. No habra distinccion ni habra racismo entre nosotros.
Segundo propongo a reducir $5trillones de dolares en la deuda nacional. Ese dinero vendra de un lugar májico en la cual Los impuestos de nosotros
pagariamos el minimo de impuestos and Matematicamente la economia del país va a florecer como nunca antes en la historia de mas de 230 años de existencia. Todo pasará el primer dia en la cual yo tome mi asiento en la Casa Blanca y empieze a trabajar con Los Congresistas de la nación.
Finalmente gracias por elejirme como Nuevo Presidente, que Los mormones lo tengan a todos en la gloria de dios y que viva Mexico!!
Segundo propongo a reducir $5trillones de dolares en la deuda nacional. Ese dinero vendra de un lugar májico en la cual Los impuestos de nosotros
los Ricos
mentira solamente trabajaré con Los republicanos pero el público no lo sabe
Finalmente gracias por elejirme como Nuevo Presidente, que Los mormones lo tengan a todos en la gloria de dios y que viva Mexico!!
bueno lo primero que dije de lo Mexicanos Es mentira pero ustedes saben no le digan a nadie
- Status