• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

US Vice-Presidential Debates 2016 |OT| Your Big Awkward Family Reunion

Who won the debate?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
Come on. Trump being a POS or not, CNN is gonna be biased against anyone on the GOP ticket. Same for Fox News and democrats. I lived through enough elections to know this. Left wing media is that and right wing media is just that.

In what universe is CNN left wing? It sure as shit ain't this one. MSNBC? Sure, but CNN? Come on, son.
 

Valhelm

contribute something
Reposting from poligaf:

To your regular watcher, Pence absolutely won. We can argue all day about whose arguments were stronger, but Kaine came off as unhinged and immature. Pence, by contrast, seems to bring a competence and professionalism to the Trump campaign that has until now been missing.

That said, Kaine has brought several issues with Trump to national attention. By denying some substantial and easily proven claims about Trump (that Trump respects Putin, or that Trump wants Saudi Arabia to go nuclear), he set the campaign up for simple and effective attack ads. Kaine ran circles around Pence in the final abortion question, which for a sizable portion of voters was probably the most important point of discussion.

This is definitely a short-term win for the Trump folks, but I don't think it will be boost they need to become competitive again.
 
Ok, this is getting out of control.

I don't think CNN is the literal opposite of Fox, I just said they're probably saying the opposite of Fox tonight.

I don't think CNN being biased againts Trump makes Trump a better candidate.

I understand MSNBC is the Fox of the left side.

You guys needs to cool down, there's a mob mentality here when an unpopular opinion is shared.
 
Pence did what the GOP has to do now to survive- dodge, deflect, admonish any use of facts or evidence and instead play to people's emotions. That's all Pence did tonight, and he was unwilling to take seriously a number of very serious statements that Trump has made, including a suggestion that it would be a good thing if there were more nukes in more countries and not even minding if they used them on each other.
 

Toxi

Banned
I think the reason Kaine didn't concentrate on attacking Pence for his LGBT views, etc, was because he wanted to primarily focus on Trump, not Pence, the VP.

Trump is the candidate, not Pence, so he kept the attack on Trump.
A lot of people miss this.
 
Not really like that. More like "this is the narrative, while Clinton may have her own down faults we need to focus Trump instead" type.

Because there are extremely obvious issues with what Trump is doing/saying.

Take his insane late-night rant. How are you "unbiased" toward reporting on it? Do you start "reporting" on the fact that Clinton was sleeping at the time and giving that riveting observation exactly equal air time?

I don't really know what you're trying to argue here.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
Ok, this is getting out of control.

I don't think CNN is the literal opposite of Fox, I just said they're probably saying the opposite of Fox tonight.

I don't think CNN being biased againts Trump makes Trump a better candidate.

I understand MSNBC is the Fox of the left side.

You guys needs to cool down, there's a mob mentality here when an unpopular opinion is shared.

But you're literally making assertions that are objectively not true. It's not that you have an unpopular opinion, it's that what you are saying is wrong.
 
The more I think about it the more I think Clinton/Kaine came out ahead, but Pence definitely held his own and probably won the debate in a traditional sense. I think Kaine did a great job proving Trump was indefensible, which is what the Clinton campaign wanted, but Pence did well enough holding his own that he came off as the top tier Conservative Candidate for 2020 or 2024.

The liberal in me sees Pence is reprehensible, but I have to admit his composure was a strange contrast to Kaine's enthusiasm. It's funny, basically the exact opposite of Trump/Clinton, where the Democrat was generally waiting their turn and polished, but the Republican was shouting over and interrupting. It's like they flipped roles entirely for the VP debate. I still think increasingly that Kaine succeeded in every way he wanted to by focusing his attacks on Trump, and Pence's affiliation and support of Trump. It should hurt the GOP this cycle, but Pence did a great job holding his own and seeming like a well polished traditional Conservative Republican.
 
Normally I'd agree with you, but who the fuck knows anymore. The rest of the Republican field is a clown car. Anyone could rise out of this dumpster fire in 4 years.

This.

I really want to say that the republican party will attempt to get its act together but this is almost the same conversation that we were having back in 2012.
 
Ok, this is getting out of control.

I don't think CNN is the literal opposite of Fox, I just said they're probably saying the opposite of Fox tonight.

I don't think CNN being biased againts Trump makes Trump a better candidate.

I understand MSNBC is the Fox of the left side.

You guys needs to cool down, there's a mob mentality here when an unpopular opinion is shared.

Your opinion made it sound like you don't actually care about facts. You just want news networks to cheer on candidates or something...
 
Based on what?

His running mate is a disaster, and still he managed to sound confident. His answers were thoughtful and articulate - not to mention they came off more natural than the canned stuff that Kaine brought with him.

If Pence were running by himself and not with Drumpf, I might actually listen to what he had to say.

This shit boggles me. Pence is so extreme to the right that I wouldn't even expect Trump to embrace all of his policy positions.

Unless you're completely blind to substance, why would anyone think Pence is somehow more palatable?
 

rjinaz

Member
Listening to people say Pence won handily because of style, calmness, not rebutting. I think had Kaine just stood there with a smile on his face for 90 minutes and said nothing he would have won them over. What matters in politics these days I guess. Who needs substance like policies and facts?
 

TyrantII

Member
This is an interesting debate. It's true that tonight it seems as though Pence held his own and could have even won, simply because he kept a level tone and responded quickly to accusations. He APPEARED to do a great job.

But those responses were often either flat out lies, or strong diversions from the topic. Tomorrow, post fact-checking, will not be kind to Pence's performance. It will most likely be a complete 180 in media opinion on who won.

I wouldn't hold my breath.

Trump had a terrible week. Pivoting the narrative and making it a horse race again is good for bussiness.

They'll ignore the fact checking and substance for style.
 
Ok, this is getting out of control.

I don't think CNN is the literal opposite of Fox, I just said they're probably saying the opposite of Fox tonight.

I don't think CNN being biased againts Trump makes Trump a better candidate.

I understand MSNBC is the Fox of the left side.

You guys needs to cool down, there's a mob mentality here when an unpopular opinion is shared.

If you don't wanna have to defend your statements, don't make them.
 

PaulCRose

Member
The more I think about it the more I think Clinton/Kaine came out ahead, but Pence definitely held his own and probably won the debate in a traditional sense. I think Kaine did a great job proving Trump was indefensible, which is what the Clinton campaign wanted, but Pence did well enough holding his own that he came off as the top tier Conservative Candidate for 2020 or 2024.

The liberal in me sees Pence is reprehensible, but I have to admit his composure was a strange contrast to Kaine's enthusiasm. It's funny, basically the exact opposite of Trump/Clinton, where the Democrat was generally waiting their turn and polished, but the Republican was shouting over and interrupting. It's like they flipped roles entirely for the VP debate. I still think increasingly that Kaine succeeded in every way he wanted to by focusing his attacks on Trump, and Pence's affiliation and support of Trump. It should hurt the GOP this cycle, but Pence did a great job holding his own and seeming like a well polished traditional Conservative Republican.

Pence will be tainted by Trump after the campaign.
 
But you're literally making assertions that are objectively not true. It's not that you have an unpopular opinion, it's that what you are saying is wrong.
Ok, I'm wrong for thinking CNN is leaning against Trump. I'm not arguing againts Clinton or shilling for Trump when I share my opinion that CNN, a media company, is sounding a narrative for a certain side more than another.
 
I think the reason Kaine didn't concentrate on attacking Pence for his LGBT views, etc, was because he wanted to primarily focus on Trump, not Pence, the VP.

Trump is the candidate, not Pence, so he kept the attack on Trump.

Well "Kaine was rude sometimes" vs. "Pence couldn't defend Trump's record or behavior whatsoever"

It's pretty obvious which one is gonna stick

I think its a fairly genius plan tbh... Kaine just needed to be cool and he got better as it went on
 

Gattsu25

Banned
Ok, this is getting out of control.

I don't think CNN is the literal opposite of Fox, I just said they're probably saying the opposite of Fox tonight.

I don't think CNN being biased againts Trump makes Trump a better candidate.

I understand MSNBC is the Fox of the left side.

You guys needs to cool down, there's a mob mentality here when an unpopular opinion is shared.

Dude, just don't write fanfiction for what you expect people are saying on news networks that you don't even watch.

And, for me, if you are going to write fanfiction...at least toss in some booty eatin'
 

Nairume

Banned
Unhinged and immature? He started out as over eager and a little tight, but come on. There was nothing unhinged about Kaine tonight.
Saying Pence was composed also ignores all the times he clearly got shook up over something Kaine said and stumbled through every attempt at a rebuttal.
 
Ok, this is getting out of control.

I don't think CNN is the literal opposite of Fox, I just said they're probably saying the opposite of Fox tonight.

I don't think CNN being biased againts Trump makes Trump a better candidate.

I understand MSNBC is the Fox of the left side.

You guys needs to cool down, there's a mob mentality here when an unpopular opinion is shared.

"I just said they're probably..."? Probably? You're engaged in a discussion about a topic with people who are actually watching the station you're attempting to criticize despite not actually being informed about what their coverage is. You aren't being taken to task because your opinion is unpopular, but because it is ignorant and factually incorrect. And you are making no attempt whatsoever to address this.

It's shitposting.
 

Biske

Member
I hope they tackle climate change in depth on the next debate. We he heard enough on immigration, foreign policy, etc.

This wont happen.


Even if Trump wanted to talk in depth about something, even if it was possible for him too, he can't touch climate change with a million foot pole.

So unless Hillary doggedly brings it up, it will fad away after he just bullshits it away.

The question probably wont even be asked anyways.
 

fallingdove

Member
So you're OK with:

Racism

Xenophobia

Bigotry

No women rights

No minority rights

NO LBGT rigths (RE: Conversion therapy http://www.politifact.com/californi...true-mike-pence-advocated-conversion-therapy/ )

And basically government and religion as one.

Come on - you know very well that he doesn't believe those things in the way you have contextualized them.

In terms of No LGBT Rights - I don't agree with his stance on same sex marriage. But I haven't ever agreed with 100% of a politicians policies. I doubt that I am in the minority.

Its the same way that I think Hillary's stance on raising the national minimum wage is a bad idea but I will still be voting for her.
 
Ok, I'm wrong for thinking CNN is leaning against Trump. I'm not arguing againts Clinton or shilling for Trump when I share my opinion that CNN, a media company, is sounding a narrative for a certain side more than another.
Sanity is leaning against Trump. Even FOX news has trouble defending Trump sometimes. I would agree that CNN isn't that great, but saying that they are biased because they fact check is a stretch.
 

Belfast

Member
Pence looked calm cool and collected, kaine looked like a kid, throwing insults all day, and interrupting.

Which makes the irony of who runs for who especially funny.

Pence wins by default imo

Looked, seemed, felt like.

The real travesty is how these things can hold more weight for a lot of people than facts and substance.
 
This shit boggles me. Pence is so extreme to the right that I wouldn't even expect Trump to embrace all of his policy positions.

Unless you're completely blind to substance, why would anyone think Pence is somehow more palatable?

Sad that "composure" matters more to some people than the substance of what they are saying
 
Unhinged and immature? He started out as over eager and a little tight, but come on. There was nothing unhinged about Kaine tonight.

He really did look that bad in the beginning. There was no warmup or easing in, he just went straight in on talking over Pence from word one.
 

Ithil

Member
That guy going "Well Nixon didn't release his tax returns while running, so it's ok". Nixon, who turned out to be a massive tax cheat.

He didn't think that one out.
 
Trump was on trial tonight. Especially after his meltdown at the first debate.

Kaine was Prosecutor. He called Pence as a character witness.

Maybe Kaine went a bit HAM on the witness, but did Pence's testimony sway the Jury?
 

Y2Kev

TLG Fan Caretaker Est. 2009
Kaine reminded me of when I would get an essay prompt I was way over prepared for. Just an explosion of ideas from the offing without much consideration for structure or sequence. That's what hurt him. He clearly had a mastery of the substance. Ah well what can you do. It's a good thing no one gives a fuck about this. And good thing queen is controlled as hell.
 
Ok, I'm wrong for thinking CNN is leaning against Trump. I'm not arguing againts Clinton or shilling for Trump when I share my opinion that CNN, a media company, is sounding a narrative for a certain side more than another.

I don't think you're shilling for Trump or anti-Hillary or whatever the fuck.

All I'm pointing out is this: Candidate A is saying more lies, more often than Candidate B. By sheer proportion of news-worthy statements, Candidate A is going to get more airtime. By sheer proportion of amount of lies, Candidate A's statements will get more scrutiny. If we for some bizarre reason ignore the proportion and instead focus entirely on giving exactly equal air time, you're actively suppressing coverage of Candidate A's statements. That's not in the least bit "unbiased".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom