MikeHattsu
Member
You do it
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Winter Anime 2016 |OT| Celebrating the New Year and PSO2's release in the west!
- Thread starter BGBW
- Start date
- Status
You do it
Nah, the cartel campaigning for Yamato 2199 to win is GAF's greatest shame.
"utterly failed " yeah right. To me the IBO fights feel completely different than Seed , Wing or 00. For one Gundams in IBO are not overpowered like in those shows, making the fights longer and far more interesting and diverse, and also all the characters feel more human.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Gundam has been stagnant forever. GBF was a breath of fresh air.
MikeHattsu
Member
Cause you're the one who saved us from mana sharing.
We talked about it in the manga thread. Obviously don't venture in there if you aren't completely up to date since there's unmarked spoilers for everything.
If you remember Part 4 at all, you should know the perfect breaking point between the second and third cour.
Votes are worth 10-1 points respective to their ranking from 1-10.
Ah, I see.
FMA Brotherhood >> FMA OG though the later does some things better like pacing and music and a few characters like Lust. Writing gets really wonky in the later though.
Can we not let the overflow from that thread/event flow into this one? Thx.
Haha yeah I was thinking the same thing. Gundam was on my list but it got bumped down to honorable mention due to some of the recent shenanigans
Can we not let the overflow from that thread/event flow into this one? Thx.
Haha yeah I was thinking the same thing. Gundam was on my list but it got bumped down to honorable mention due to some of the recent shenanigans
Admiral Woofington
Member
Cool results. You know color me surprised, but I thought Shirobako would come closer considering that usually when OPM wasn't top then Shirobako was. But I did call that OPM was in more lists in different positions than Shirobako. If someone didn't have Shirobako in the top 3 it usually wouldn't appear in the list.
I mean it came close enough. This is like Witcher 3 v Bloodborne. Both appeared often enough, but Bloodborne tended to be in most lists than Witcher 3.
I don't watch many Gundam shows, have only watched Seed and I'll eventually watch G-Gundam, and maybe from a veteran it's not doing anything special but it had a solid amount of early episodes that hooked me. Viewing something as someone who isn't terribly familiar should count for something.
But admittedly the recent episodes haven't all been that amazing, I doubt it'll appear in my 2016 AOTY ballot.
edit: jesus Working!!! wasn't even top 25
Working!!! was robbed. Fuck all y'all
I mean it came close enough. This is like Witcher 3 v Bloodborne. Both appeared often enough, but Bloodborne tended to be in most lists than Witcher 3.
I don't watch many Gundam shows, have only watched Seed and I'll eventually watch G-Gundam, and maybe from a veteran it's not doing anything special but it had a solid amount of early episodes that hooked me. Viewing something as someone who isn't terribly familiar should count for something.
But admittedly the recent episodes haven't all been that amazing, I doubt it'll appear in my 2016 AOTY ballot.
edit: jesus Working!!! wasn't even top 25
Working!!! was robbed. Fuck all y'all
I like that all mechs (not just gundams) in IBO fell like tanks and not some delicate war machines and don't get destroyed in a single shot like in Seed or 00. This made some fight really long and great. The MC had to even resolve to melee and for looking weak points in armor with it , since all the mechs are so sturdy and armored.
Also to the 3 other people that voted Yamada-kun and the Seven Witches, bless your heart.
Also to the 3 other people that voted Yamada-kun and the Seven Witches, bless your heart.
Admiral Woofington
Member
Why even bother letting people vote for 10 different shows if most placements give the same amount of points as the one right below it?
KenjiGlove
Banned
Basileus777
Member
Nah, I want my arbitrary ordering to make the most difference possible.
I wish I have counted the OPM+Jojo only posts.
Joe Molotov
Member
Did my 9 votes for Non Non Biyori count or nah?
No, I counted your first place vote, and then whatever you had listed at 10. I discarded your 2-9 votes.
I'm not sure what Quru did in his official numbers.
Joe Molotov
Member
I don't regret what I did.
There were around 4 people that listed the same show for 1-9 and their next favourite at 10.
Which I'm not sure is a disservice to their second favourite show, or if its reflective of their enjoyment of their second favourite show.
Because it was fun. Not every show aims to be a cultural masterpiece.
I mean, if we're going rank shows based on fun, I would rank JoJo far higher than a food shounen with exploitative fanservice.
SliceSabre
Banned
I wanna know why gundam made the list.
BRUTAL
Damn wish i had a wii u for bayo.
Get on Little Witch Academia for more crazy witch antics.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Don't really have enough energy to get worked up over any of the year lists, just see it as a general representation of 500+ people and everyone will have at least one stickler outlier that they wanted more exposure for. At least this is better then 3,000 posts of bloodborne vs witcher 3 which is zzzzzzzzzzzz
nintendoman58
Member
Jojo should have been number one, really. I mean, I like Soma but Jojo was one of the most fun adventures I've seen in an anime in a long time.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
JoJo will have its day because Diamond is Unbreakable is way better then Phantom Blood, Battle Tendency or Stardust Crusaders
strangedopamine
Member
Wakako-zake was the best food based anime of last year. You lot can't convince me otherwise.
As a whole, I didn't enjoy Stardust Crusaders as much as the first two parts, especially Battle Tendency. I hate the weekly format, it can be hit or miss on the episodes and I feel a lot of them were the later in Jojo's case. I'm actually a bit surprised it ranked that high, I was expecting it at the second half of the list.
Sibersk Esto
Banned
Up to episode 3 of concrete revolutio
That sakuga at the end gave me serious blue balls.
That sakuga at the end gave me serious blue balls.
i mean witchborne is better than blooder 3 and you know it's true
hosannainexcelsis
Member
That's fine. I'm watching Wakako-zake at the moment and I'm not too big on it. It's probably a lot more meaningful if you've been to the kind of Japanese restaurants it's highlighting, but I have no experience with them and the food isn't gone into in any detail due to the short length, so I can't care. I don't even particularly like the voice Sawashiro is using for the main character. The backgrounds are nice though.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked