I thought the film was Ok, I'd like to see the full 4 hour version,though. The book is great. Have you read any Before Watchmen?
Best version of Watchmen is The Incredibles.
I started to read the Before Watchmen stuff, other than the Darwyn Cooke art it's roundly dreadful. And I don't rate Watchmen all that highly either. It's fine as a snapshot of it's time but not much more.
I'm just bitter Twilight of the Superheroes never got off the ground.