About a year ago, I met a girl through a mutual friend when we all went out to a bar. We made small talk, the kind of things you talk about when you meet somebody for the first time. Over the next few weeks I saw her more and more often. We very quickly hit it off. She was easy to talk to and interesting. I like to tease and give people shit when I feel comfortable. Dont worry, its never mean or personal, if I see they took it the wrong way I apologize. Anyway that wasnt a problem since she was able to deal with my teasing and wasn't afraid to give me shit back, she wasnt demure or shy. I found it really endearing and admitted to myself I was attracted a little to her. One night we went out with some friends and she started asking me stuff like if I was single, and what I looked for in a girl. This got my attention, maybe shes interested? But I was seeing another girl at the time (just talking and a date or two, nothing serious and it eventually didnt go anywhere) and we were drinking, so I brushed it off as her just being drunk. Every time we hung out after I felt we had a connection, lots of flirting and teasing. I wasn't crazy about her, but I did note how fun it was to talk and hang with her. One night we had a big group of people composed of her and my friends all hanging out at a bar. There the flirting and teasing really ramped up, including subtle touching like a finger brushed across the leg, a lingering hand on the arm, touching her hand, etc. We were laughing and enjoying each other's company. It was pretty apparent there was something there, even my friends commented on it, asking what was up between me and her. That same night it all built up to the point I waited to find a good opportunity to go for a kiss, but I chickened out. I rationalized it by thinking there were too many of us all at the same table (there were) and that if I would have been able to get her alone (any tips on doing this in public setting surrounded by friends, let me know) I would have went for it, the opportunity just never presented itself.
Despite that, I i did manage to get her number and we texted a lot after that in the following weeks. I was working up the nerve to ask her out proper when she invites me to a see a movie one night. I think wow, she actually asked me out first, cool. So I go to pick her up, I dress up nice, but nothing too fancy. She gets into my car with a sweater on, long loose pants, no make up or anything like that. I immediately think this isn't a date and that I read the situation all wrong, but I wait and just see where it goes. The chemistry is there like it always is between us, we're having a good time just on the drive to the theater and I think maybe she dressed that way on our date cause she feels comfortable with me. Before the movie starts we're talking about valentines day plans and I start saying stuff like I'm working on it and that I'm talking to a girl right now who seems interesting blah blah blah, I was hinting really hard I was talking about her. Then she says she has a date with a guy, I'm thinking she's playing along and we're on the same page. She then says she's known him for a while and he's wanted to take her out for years (fuck, not the same page) so she decided to give him a chance. That threw me off, I recover and try to play it cool, like I don't just feel like an enormous idiot and we get through the movie, but I knew then I was friendzoned, shit. I take her home and as we pull up to her house she brings up a friend of mine who she is interested in (the mutual friend that introduced us) and I take note that she mentioned him a lot before in our previous convos, I just thought she was using it as an easy conversation point. Shes crushing hard but hes got a gf at this point. I sympathize lol. Anyway we keep texting throughout the next few days, decide to hang out just me and her. We head downtown, drink a bit and eventually the topic of dating comes up. I mention how I'm tired of looking for quick hookups and want something more significant, she literally says the opposite. However, now I'm tipsy enough where I admit to her I thought the night we saw the movie was her inviting me out on a date. She got really embarrassed and started apologizing but I told her it was fine, I misread the situation and that she didn't do anything wrong. I then tell her I like her, and asked her out for real. She said she wasn't interested. It makes sense as we just got done saying we're not looking for the same things, but I had to try. We both handle it well and I take her home a little later, I'm honestly glad I got a clear cut answer, I can stop worrying about it.
Here I have to admit that I was more interested in her than I thought. We text and hang out still, but its getting less and less frequent and then eventually communication just stops. I stopped going out as much (mostly due to money, but I was also going through some stuff and drinking every weekend wasn't as enjoyable) so I pretty much don't see her until months later or so when I go out for my birthday and she's at the same place with a friend. We say hi and I invite them to sit with our group. It honestly felt like no time had passed, we picked up right where we left off. The chemistry was automatic. I had a fun time, but that was it. No communication afterwards. I left it alone.
Months after this I go out to celebrate a friend's bday, she's there as well. Once again, it's like we had seen each other the day before, not even two sentences into our convo and we're already teasing and messing with one another. Over the course of the night she starts commentating a lot on how good I look (I've been losing weight and working out for the past few years) since she hasn't seen me in a while, I guess the progress is starting to become more noticeable. So she's dropping compliments, asking me how I did it and stuff, which honestly made me feel really good, and we're having a good time. We're interrupted when my friend decides to leave (he's my ride) and we say goodbye around midnight. Not too long after she texts me, informing me she's home, bored laying in bed, and that it was nice seeing me and that she always seems to have a good time when we hang out (ahh, she noticed it too?). She continues to text me throughout the night until she falls asleep.
Since then we've texted pretty regularly and have hung out once (where we're still flirting and teasing each other). The thing is, I don't really know whats going on now. I feel like there's some kind of connection between us, no matter how long its been, it never feels awkward or weird, we're always comfortable. I've made sure to tell her this too and she agrees. Right now, things feel the same as they did a year ago, but they also feel...different between us at the same time? The way we interact hasn't really changed from when I was friendzoned from before, but other things are different. For example, she texts me very often late night before going to bed, just asking what im up to (she does this throughout the day too sometimes) which wasn't so much the case when we texted before. She has also come out to the local park where my friends and I play basketball, something she's known about forever, but never made the effort (was there any reason to?) to come and say hi. She always comes out of her own volition; the last time I was texting her because I was sitting on the sidelines waiting to play, just trying to pass the time with some conversation and she said she'll come by to give me company. The thing is, she doesn't get anything out of it. She's just sitting on the bench with her phone or reading her kindle while we play. We only interact between games and when we walk home together as she leaves when I do, even though shes friends with the other people who go out there too.
This is where we are now and don't know what to do, or really what I want. I realized that when we stopped communicating and hanging out that I had made a mistake. I thought I was doing the right thing by me so I didn't continue having feelings for someone who wasnt interested in me, and it worked, but I realized that having a female friend that I regularly hang out with (I have some, but none I can call up to hang out) is a good thing for me. She has friends who could become potential interests and it'd be great to get a female perspective on certain things (such as this) as well as simply improve my social skills with women in general. I'm kinda stuck. I'm not even sure she's into me at all (I was a lot more confident about that a year ago and I was wrong), and i'm being friendzoned again. She already said no once, but things can change a lot in a years' time (she's gotten over that mutual friend of ours, I've changed physically and mentally and don't feel like a long term relationship is paramount in my life anymore) and since I've told her I've had feelings for her before, if things are different, the balls in her court, no?
Ideally, I would like to see if we really do have some sort of romantic potential, we honestly seem perfect for each other. We have similar interest in things like movies, anything sci-fi and nerdy stuff, to bond over, but different enough in other ways that things would be interesting. I've mentioned chemistry a million times, but it honestly baffles me how effortless our interactions are. I know the clearest way to find out is simply ask her, but if Im wrong again, I dont want to put myself out there like that a second time with her and it comes across that the only reason Im still talking to her is because Im looking for something more. I can say honestly that Im alright with being just a friend, I genuinely think it would be a good thing. I just cant help but think this time things have changed, I need some perspective that doesnt come from my own biases and how I see our interactions.
Just ask her out already, easy
Justttttt askkkkk
Oh. Well post it and let's see but my immediate thought upon reading this is to read the title.
I just hope you're not tying yourself into knots over some stupid shit.
I don't think it's stupid or as simple as ask her out but you guys be the judge. Most girls I'd already be done with one way or another but its different here, or at least I feel it is.