Overall I really enjoyed it but DQ8 is still number 1. For reference I have played all the ds remakes too.
A few issues with the game however:
The music; whilst it was good, there seemed to be only a handful of tracks...perhaps my memory fails me but DQ8 didn't feel like this.
There were a few occasions where in order to progress required talking to an npc that didn't feel logical but generally I think this is more to do with the original game's development roots and era (ie a snes/Ps1 mix)
The overall level progression felt kind of restrained/modest (ie you can kill the demon king at roughly level 36 which feels a little low) but this is likely more to do with it being a game from the Ps1.
The job system was nice; I had hero & Ruff as heros and Aishe & Mervyn as champions....dat blade of ultimate power...using it twice per turn felt godlike
I look forward to replaying DQ8!