My mini review
PS3 version:
Graphics: 9.5 For an RPG they are excellent, maybe not the best designs but definitely better than most RPG's this generation. From a technical standpoint they are some of the best this gen, for an RPG.
Sound: 9.25 One of the best sounding games I've had on my 7.1 Pioneer Elite system, and I've played Uncharted 2 and have a degree in music and own a recording studio. I know what i'm talking about. I'm also loving the music, I can see where some people may find it too diverse but, the diversity helps to complement the game. The voice acting isn't the best but, it's not the worst either and that's the only real deduction I have with the sound. As hot as Vanille is and as bad is I'd like to see her in some CG porn her voice can get on your nerves especially when shes talking to herself while your running around the map.
Story and Characters: 8.25 So far I'm really liking it. While none of the characters stand out too much from one another each character does fill their role. One has a love interest, one is on a mission, on is growing up alone, and there is even a been there done that narrator. The story so far is good although it does tend to alienate you a little bit with the switching of main characters a bit often but, this does help to keep the player from feeling like the story is only about one person yet still keeps you interested in the game. I do feel the story could have been fleshed out a bit more.
Gameplay: 8.75 The battle system is really good, it isn't my favorite so far but, I think Square has done an excellent job at breaking away from a turn based battle system while still keeping the strategy in tact. Personally, I prefer turn based but, I'm finding this active system keeps me from feeling like I ever need to grind and that makes the game move forward at a faster pace.
Complaints about linearity: Every single player game I've ever played I've considered to be linear, you start the game and finish the game that's how most games work unless it's an MMO or an Online FPS. What I mean is that side-quests are always optional. With that said, I am getting the feeling like Square has pulled the player away from the potatoes and only thrown us meat. Instead of looking for that super special item or forcing your character to fall in love with someone your simply pulled through the story and not really given' the chance to explore. You can take that as bad or good, I just see it as different.
I still can't put the game down, and that says more than any justification for what I think is bad or good. That alone keeps me from lowering the score too much.
Final Score: ~9 or an A-