Can someone give me some insight. I'm willing to change my program up.
Here's the logic.
Progress is driven by the General Adaptation Theory. It's the same logic that gets you a tan. If you spend a few minutes in the sun every day, then some time away from it to recover, you'll tan. Over time, you'll need more sun exposure and more recovery to deepen your tan. If you do too much sun exposure, you'll burn, and if you don't give your body a break from the sun (usually sleeping), you won't tan since you'll be too busy trying not to fry. If you don't give your body enough sun exposure, you won't tan.
Right now you're a pale kid going out in the Mexican sun and frying for six hours, and doing that once a week. It kind of works, but it's a rough way to tan.
So apply this logic to strength training. You are a newbie, which is awesome. It means that big gains are ahead of you! It also means that your body does not require an intense stimulus with lots of volume, and doesn't need that much time to recover. In fact, the stimulus might be too intense for you to recover properly at all at this point. You want to provide an adequate but not excessive stimulus (tan but not burn) with enough frequency to drive progress. Enough stimulus to supercompensate, enough recovery to improve, rinse and repeat.
So reduce the number of exercises, only using the ones that you need. Drive progress on those movements incrementally, slowly building up. Do them with enough frequency to keep progress climbing instead of climbing up then falling halfway back before you drive them up again.
Initially 3x/week (add weight to all exercises every time you do them, 10lbs for squat/dl and 5 for bench/ohp, then dropping to 5/2.5 eventually once you're had a failure and reset):
Squat 3x5
Bench press 3x5
Deadlift 1x5 (i did 3x5 on this too for a couple of weeks until I started to feel beaten up all the time)
After a couple of weeks,
Workout A:
Squat 3x5
Bench 3x5
Deadlift 1x5
Workout B:
Squat 3x5
OHP 3x5
Power Clean 5x3
Then after another couple of weeks (a-b-a, b-a-b),
Workout A:
Squat 3x5
Bench 3x5
Deadlift 1x5
Chinups 3xfailure
Workout B:
Squat 3x5
OHP 3x5
Power Clean 5x3
Pullups 3xfailure
Then after a couple of weeks again,
Monday:
Squat 3x5
Bench/OHP (alternate weekly) 3x5
Deadlift 1x5
Chinups 3xfailure
Wednesday:
Squat 2x5 @80% of Monday
OHP/Bench (alternate weekly) 3x5
Deadlift 1x5/Power Clean 5x3 (Alternate weekly)
Friday:
Squat 3x5
Bench/OHP (alternate weekly) 3x5
Pullups 3xfaillure
(I like to throw some dips and bicep curls in this day, just 3 sets of each)
At this point you'll be strong and won't look or feel like the same person. This process takes about 3-8 months, life circumstances depending. It's the SS progression.