Support NeoGAF

[OpinionatedCyborg]

I wasn't impressed with those battlefield scenes. Neither side had played Total War before. SHAME 🔔 SHAME 🔔 CUNT! 🍅 SHAME 🔔

My bells and tomato ascii aren't working on GAF

 

[jvm]

They should just pull a Dallas and let it all be a dream that Bran had.

 

[Stevetopsy]

So Arya is blind...or is she dead? Huh?

This episode will be remembered as the episode where everyone died.

 

[DeathByBacklog]

I honestly thought that too. Maybe she doesn't do full frontal?

I think so. Looked very uncanny valley.

Yes. Body double with CG face from Headey.

It looked like the shot of her in the cell was real but I doubt she would subject herself to walking through extras on the street, naked, while they shouted and threw shit at her.

ed: ^^ Yeah, Sansa/Theon landed on snow, they're probably fine. That girl they tossed on gravel ain't. Stannis is questionable.



The fan theory stuff can still come true even if he's not resurrected. The dead are still mentioned.



It was. Body double, with her face done in post.

It was...really poorly done. This goes back to Dany covering up in a room with a guy she just shagged with. Why do they shoot scenes from angles that are going to look like crap because they're done so poor? Disrobe her. Fine. The idea is there. Now just shoot from angles where the faking isn't so incredibly obvious.

 

[Josh5890]

Wait what, Theon and Sansa dead?

I don't understand why this is getting so much traction. Has there been any other characters in the show where their deaths were simply implied? At least the bigger characters?

 

[Sweeney Tom]

This season was depressing but I can still hold on for the rest of the show I think

Unless they have an Arya rape scene just because Maisie will be legal, in which case fuck it I'm out

 

[CountAntonius]

No such thing as plot armor. This show beats me to the floor and as much as i fucking hate it I absolutely love the balls it has to always blindside me and make me feel something i never expected. best show ever.

 

[Loakum]

Theon and Sansa are alive.

They jumped into the moat below.

[edit]

I just re-watched the scene, there's no moat. There was, however, a big pile of snow.

I didn't see much snow when Ramsey's crazy ass ex girlfriend fell in that spot.

 

[ComputerBlue]

What the heck? Where are you getting that? It was like broad daylight. Would be some impressive cgi if true, although I watched it on the potato called HBO Go.

There are articles about it from last year. 200k to cgi that shit.

 

[TimeEffect]

Man I want to go back a few pages, but people keep talking about the B word. How well monitored is this thread.

 

[GameAddict411]

Wait...Arya died too? And Sansa? And Theon? And Jon? We never actually saw anyone die, are these just a series of terrible cliffhangers?

No one can survive several deep stabs to the chest even with today's sophisticated medicine. Either he survives by some type of magic, or he dies. The walls of winterfell has a slope to it, and it's very likely that they survived. I don't think that they will jump to their death like that.

 

[Sober]

It would be really lame if Jon somehow survives that. I seriously thought that surviving some epic fight with the white walkers would bring all the night watch together, I dont get it. How come they dont understand the predicament they are in?

It just wants to spell it out for you that the Nights' Watch is just as incompetent and fucked like everyone other house when it comes to the WW. Hell, Stannis went out like a bitch, and he was the only one who even gave half a shit.

What the heck? Where are you getting that? It was like broad daylight. Would be some impressive cgi if true, although I watched it on the potato called HBO Go.

It was painfully clear it was a body double in the scene with her having her her shaved off. If she wasn't gonna do it then she obviously wasn't gonna do it now. Just some creative CGI in post.

 

[Loakum]

This episode will be remembered as the episode where everyone died.

It's almost hilarious. lol

 

[LowParry]

I'm going off the title "Mother's Mercy". Jon will be back. Right? Oiy. How depressing.

 

[kingkitty]

Stannis...

Stannis the one true king...is dead??????????????? to worthless, bad luck Brienne? unbelievable. all that build up to the great battle with the Boltons and it was for nothing! that fire lady needs to give Stannis a refund ASAP. fucken bullshit.

and is there like, some snow cushion that will save Sansa and Theon? or did they just commit suicide?

did Arya just become morphed into the many faces people, does that mean Ayra is sorta dead? lol

and it looks like Jon Snow is dead as shit. Which is a shame since he was actually becoming an interesting character. Hopefully he gets revived but...I don't know.

fuck this show. i can't wait for the next season.

 

[DangerMouse]

-'Kill the boy so the man can be born'
-'Jon always comes back'
-'There's power in you'
-Meli's perfect timing in showing up at The Wall
-Visions of her at Winterfell surrounded by burning Bolton banners.

Kit will have to sign on as a series regular on Walking Dead or something before I believe Jon is gone for good. The Snow will Rise

They also didn't make it a point to have Beric and Thoros discuss resurrection with Melisandre for no reason.

If only.

 

[Einchy]

I didn't see much snow when Ramsey's crazy ass ex girlfriend fell in that spot.

She was thrown inside the walls of Winterfell while Theon and Sansa jumped on the other side to escape.

 

[Oreoleo]

Theon and Sansa are alive. Arya is alive. Come on, guys.

 

[Shining Sunshine]

How long til next season?

 

[OpinionatedCyborg]

Mess.

Official season rankings:

1 > 2 >>>>>>>>> 4 >>>>>>>>> 3 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 5.

At least we'll always have Hardhome.

I felt like the series lost a step around the time Tyrion went on trial (too much happened in too short a time frame). The pacing's been off since then.

 

[Sectorseven]

I was expecting Sansa to land on Theon, simultaneously killing him and saving her.

 

[Sweeney Tom]

I didn't see much snow when Ramsey's crazy ass ex girlfriend fell in that spot.

She fell onto ground after being shoved off a smaller ledge. They moved up to a larger ledge that had a snow bank with a decent amount of snow in it. Of the people who are questionably permadead (them, Stannis, Snow), they are most likely to be alive during next season's first two episodes.

 

[Josh5890]

Stannis' death shows that karma does exist in Game of Thrones(if only on rare occasions)

 

[FrenchMovieTheme]

How long til next season?

probably till next april or may

 

[-Plasma Reus-]

How long til next season?

10 months.

 

[cutmeamango]

No body for Stannis, no confirmed death for Stannis.
Same for Myrcella, although it's easier to end her non-existent character so far.

And yeah Jon Snow + Melisandre, may help his case, but I hope he stays dead.

 

[Loakum]

Theon and Sansa are alive. Arya is alive. Come on, guys.

All those abrupt edits, it's hard to tell if they're alive. Man...this show is hardcore. lol

 

[rexor0717]

I was expecting Sansa to land on Theon, simultaneously killing him and saving her.

Yeah, I totally thought he was going to meat shield her.

Theon and Sansa are alive. Arya is alive. Come on, guys.

Seriously. It would be the worst writing/editing to have them be dead.

The night's watch is full of shitheads. Like you're upset he brought back wildlings? You want to keep fighting them forever you ingrates? Fuck you all, you're all fucking criminals and rapists anyway. Fuck off. "For the watch" my ass, as if you have honor all of a sudden. And fuck you Olly, I want to see you get mauled to death by a dire wolf.

Jon's going to pull a Gandalf and appear to them in a blinding light of resurrection greatness. They'll know the error of their ways.

 

[Lamel]

The night's watch is full of shitheads. Like you're upset he brought back wildlings? You want to keep fighting them forever you ingrates? Fuck you all, you're all fucking criminals and rapists anyway. Fuck off. "For the watch" my ass, as if you have honor all of a sudden. And fuck you Olly, I want to see you get mauled to death by a dire wolf.

It would be really lame if Jon somehow survives that. I seriously thought that surviving some epic fight with the white walkers would bring all the night watch together, I dont get it. How come they dont understand the predicament they are in?

Cuz they are dumb shits with no perceptive ability. They want to live out their shitty fucking lives at the wall fighting wildlings forever, without realizing that they are all fucking doomed. I'm with you, after hardhome its really hard to sell to me that they still don't understand the grave threat. Fuck em.

 

[jetjevons]

People really think Jon Snow's going to be resurrected? The only way that works is if he then becomes a slave to the lord of light and is forced to do some depressing and horrible shit for Melisandre to stay alive. Then GRR Martin can shame him and kill him AGAIN!

 

[140.85]

I noticed they filled the floppy wieners quota this episode. I was wondering where they were all season, lol.

 

[ComputerBlue]

Jon Snow will be revived as Jon Targaryen...


I hate this show so much right now, but bloody hell it's depressing that the season is over and we've got another 10 months wait.

 

[Gnilres]

Stannis' death shows that karma does exist in Game of Thrones(if only on rare occasions)

So Ser Alliser Thorne will get what's coming to him? That's the only thing that will bring me back for season 6. Jon was honestly by far my favorite character

 

[Loakum]

She fell onto ground after being shoved off a smaller ledge. They moved up to a larger ledge that had a snow bank with a decent amount of snow in it. Of the people who are questionably permadead (them, Stannis, Snow), they are most likely to be alive during next season's first two episodes.

Thanx. But with Sansa's luck, it's anyone's guess.

 

[Minion101]

I think Jon is dead but will be used for blood magic.

 

[Josh5890]

The night's watch is full of shitheads. Like you're upset he brought back wildlings? You want to keep fighting them forever you ingrates? Fuck you all, you're all fucking criminals and rapists anyway. Fuck off. "For the watch" my ass, as if you have honor all of a sudden. And fuck you Olly, I want to see you get mauled to death by a dire wolf.

Hey wait a minute what happened to Ghost? I hope the Night's Watch didn't kill the beast.

 

[Eyeh4wk]

Goddamn GRRM, I got genuinelly excited when Ollie entered Jon's room with news about Benjen, then I saw the traitor sign. Goddamn

 

[Ovid]

The stark kids are all becoming disabled, bran can't walk, arya can't see, Sansa probably broke something badly, jon can't breathe lol

LMFAO!!!

 

[Ferrio]

Jon will be back. Red lady just comes there just at the right time, and she's itching for his blood which is abundant right now. Davos as his right hand man? Count me in.

 

[Shining Sunshine]

probably till next april or may

10 months.

FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!!

 

[Gnilres]

The night's watch is full of shitheads. Like you're upset he brought back wildlings? You want to keep fighting them forever you ingrates? Fuck you all, you're all fucking criminals and rapists anyway. Fuck off. "For the watch" my ass, as if you have honor all of a sudden. And fuck you Olly, I want to see you get mauled to death by a dire wolf.



Cuz they are dumb shits with no perceptive ability. They want to live out their shitty fucking lives at the wall fighting wildlings forever, without realizing that they are all fucking doomed. I'm with you, after hardhome its really hard to sell to me that they still don't understand the grave threat. Fuck em.

We speak the same language, my friend

 

[Madrin]

Theon and Sansa are alive. Arya is alive. Come on, guys.

Seriously. At the very most they will break their legs and lose their ability to walk. Then maybe they'll meet up with Bran, and Hodor will carry all 3 of them around on his back.

 

[Einchy]

You can tell that the wall has a big slope and there's snow in the bottom that could act as padding.

They're probably going to be pretty beaten up but they won't die from it.

 

[Josh5890]

So Ser Alliser Thorne will get what's coming to him? That's the only thing that will bring me back for season 6. Jon was honestly by far my favorite character

Like I said, karma only happens now and then

 

[Sectorseven]

Why would it be in Melisandre's interest to resurrect Jon Snow?

 

[jediyoshi]

Why would it be in Melisandre's interest to resurrect Jon Snow?

King's blood. It makes the world go round.

 

[Gnilres]

Goddamn GRRM, I got genuinelly excited when Ollie entered Jon's room with news about Benjen, then I saw the traitor sign. Goddamn

It hurt so much. SO MUCH. Fuck ollie I hate that bastard

 

[FantasticMrFoxdie]

But yeah I dont believe it.

Stannis and Sansa are definitely alive since they don't show it.

Jon seems like the only definitive death since they showed it. Even then it all seems to convenient that Melisandre returns to the Watch after that.

 

[yellowjacket25]

Considering what Theon and Sansa have been through they really don't seem like the suicide types. Plus the scene didn't seem like a suicide at all. Theon appeared to have a plan when the soldiers were returning. He went right to a specific spot and they both agreed to go for it. It seemed like a bit of a leap of faith but not a suicide.

 

[jetjevons]

Why would it be in Melisandre's interest to resurrect Jon Snow?

No-one who wasn't already a disciple of the lord of light has just been 'resurrected'.