Well, yeah, pretty much. He loves NFL Blitz for a reason.
But there have been a decent amount of arcade sports games in the past generation.
There was a XBLA Tecmo Bowl, NFL Jam, and NFL Blitz.
Baseball has been the most fucked but that has been because 2k drove baseball games back 10 years.
Plus even when there is a new sports game that would cater to what Jeff and others in games media want it is almost never promoted or written about.
Remember when Jeff called out Brad and other like him for hating Call of Duty sequels for no other reason than it was popular rather than the series gradual downturn when it came to map design and a diminishing quality in its single player mode. I feel like Jeff and others could be called out for as much when it came to sport games.
Maybe I'm in the minority but for as much as I loved Tony Hawk games in the past a more "realistic" game like skate grabs me more.
Even in the modern sports games I feel they have done a decent job of trying to make the controls simpler for those who want it. NHL has the NHL96 mode, MLB the Show has a 1 button hit and pitch, Madden will call plays for you, and I was able to pick up and play NBA2k14 and enjoy it without much experience in basketball games in about 10 minutes.