Just finished the game first time through on Titan difficulty and I feel like this is my least favorite of the three GoW games. Sure, the game had some epic moments and the combat is definitely refined compared to how the previous GoW games played, but the over package just left me with an empty feeling. I was not impressed with this game at all. It feels exactly like GoWII only on a larger scale, obviously. Not that there is anything wrong with that. The core mechanics and level design still engage you enough, but there was absolutely no "wow" factor for me in this game.
The thing that bothers me the most is the lack of content. What happened to the polish and cool design of the Treasure room in the previous GoW games? There are like NO unlockables in this game. Apparently completing Chaos, the hardest difficulty, unlocks nothing. WTF!? I hate the red text they use for the menus as well, it just seems off to me. There are no cool locked icons next to the unlockables, the challenges don't rank you anymore, plus there are not as many as there used to be. No new game+, ONE costume unlock, are you serious? I guess I shouldn't be surprised in the age of DLC, but still, you know, a game called Bayonetta exists now and has these EXPECTED features covered.
I like the collectible artifacts that act as replacements for the GoWII urns, but still. All the menus and "content" seems extremely last minute. From that standpoint I am very disappointed. Yeah, the game looks great, the story direction is subjective, the combat is most definitely refined, but it just doesn't feel like the ultimate GoW title. As far as action games go this year, Bayonetta steam rolls this game by a long shot.