Hey guys, was looking at upgrading my sound. One of the things I haven't payed attention in years. The OP lists the Creative Labs Sound Blaster Z as an enthusiast card and a great value. Is that the best one for the money? Was looking at some more expensive solutions like the Xonar Essence STX, is the Creative lab still a better option... a lot newer in any case.
The Sound Blaster Z is a great card. I've had mine for a few months and it has been great. I had a Xonar Essence STX before I picked up the Z, and I'm happier with the Z and would highly recommend it.
The main reason I changed sound cards was to get 5.1 audio to my receiver with analog inputs. The only way the Xonar could get 5.1 was through digital outputs, which sometimes caused problems in games. The Z handles 5.1 much better, and the 5.1 audio sounds better as well.
For recording purposes, I've made some recordings from some vinyl records on both cards and the recordings sound great from both. I'm sure the Xonar probably has better recording quality in the lab, but I haven't noticed a difference in sound quality. Also, it looks like Creative just released a driver to add ASIO to the Z, which takes away an advantage the Xonar had over it.