Support NeoGAF

[dramatis]

Chihiro anywhere other than last is inconcievable. Her defining character trait is that she's plain and boring.

For me, Chihiro is first because she liked Keima for who he was, as immersed in games as he had been before the pact with Elsie. She was also an incredible wingwoman for Ayumi despite her own feelings.

Strangely enough, the way things ended with Chihiro is the reason why I can place TWGOK way above other harem manga. It's a bit of a look inside a guy who by all appearances seems very confident in himself, but only because he melds his fantasies with reality. When faced with romance in reality, he ran away. He couldn't believe that a girl could actually like the real and nasty him.

I don't expect TWGOK to end unhappy, but it would have been interesting to think about how the effects of charming so many girls can go badly when they get a better look at him.

 

[Ignis Fatuus]

This is still the definitive and correct list.

God Tier
Tenri/Diana
Ayumi/Mercury
Yui/Mars

Top Tier
Chihiro
Tsukiyo/Vulcan

High Tier
Elsie
Miyako
Urara
Nanaka

Mid Tier
Akari
Sumire
Haqua

Low Tier
Dokurou
Jun
Kanon/Apollo
Shiori/Minerva
Rieko
Kusunoki
Mio
Minami
Mari

Garbage Tier
Nora
Hinoki

 

[scy]

And I might be the only one here who has Kusonoki (younger sister) in their top five.

No, she's one of my favorite girls as well. I was always sad she wasn't more relevant.

On that note, even the elder sister wasn't that bad either. She was interesting at least.

This is still the definitive and correct list.

;_____;

 

[Wiseblade]

Top Tier

Tsukiyo/Vulcan

Doll girl? What? Even library girl is better than her.

 

[Ignis Fatuus]

Doll girl? What? Even library girl is better than her.

Vulcan is awesome tho.

 

[wonzo]

I don't know what kind of porn they like

I'v given y'all more than enough information ITT!!!!!

 

[Kusagari]

Chihiro anywhere other than last is inconcievable. Her defining character trait is that she's plain and boring.

No u.

I actually really liked the shogi girl whose name I cannot remember right now.

 

[Ignis Fatuus]

No u.

I actually really liked the shogi girl whose name I cannot remember right now.

Nanaka. I have her as High Tier.

 

[Save 'N Quit]

This is still the definitive and correct list.

.

Vulcan is fine.

But she alone cannot push Tsukiyo up to Top Tier.

No, she's one of my favorite girls as well. I was always sad she wasn't more relevant.

On that note, even the elder sister wasn't that bad either. She was interesting at least

Only bad thing about the sister is that her Arc was one of the weaker ones.

 

[showx]

Recommend me some great finished shonen.

 

[dramatis]

Recommend me some great finished shonen.

Fullmetal Alchemist.

 

[dumbyugi]

The Class Rep Is a Boy in Drag 1

It's exactly what the title says. It seems like it'll be alright.

 

[Dedication Through Light]

Recommend me some great finished shonen.

Katekyo Hitman Reborn

 

[dumbyugi]

Recommend me some great finished shonen.

Black Cat
Fullmetal Alchemist
Death Note
Chrno Crusade
Eyeshield 21
Ghost Sweeper Mikami
Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro
Flame of Recca
Touch
Psyren
Yu-gi-oh!
Yu Yu Hakusho
Yakitate!! Japan

 

[Naito]

Recommend me some great finished shonen.

Kongou Banchou.

 

[Wiseblade]

Black Cat
Death Note
Yu-gi-oh!

Did he kick your dog or something? Why would you inflict this upon an innocent?

 

[Crash Station]

Recommend me some great finished shonen.

Choujin Gakuen.

 

[dumbyugi]

Did he kick your dog or something? Why would you inflict this upon an innocent?

All three of them are some of my favourite manga. In fact Black Cat is my absolute favourite manga.

 

[Kusagari]

Recommend me some great finished shonen.

Kongou Banchou.
GTO

 

[Wiseblade]

All three of them are some of my favourite manga. In fact Black Cat is my absolute favourite manga.

I didn't mean to include Black Cat. But isn't it from the TLR duo? But death Note isn't nearly as intellectual as it thinks it is and YGO is just ugh.

 

[Bossun]

HSDK

Wow, did I see that right?

 

[dumbyugi]

I didn't mean to include Black Cat. But isn't it from the TLR duo?

It's only by Yabuki, the writer for TLR was one of his assistants during Black Cat.

 

[dakkumauji]

Fairy Tail 333

Yeah, she's not gonna follow through with this.

 

[Laughing Banana]

Ya know... hentai really has a lot of weird words for uh.... their classification.

Stuff like Mizugi, Netorare, Paizure, Megane, Osananajimi (WTF), Oppai, Kemonomimi, Ahegao, Ashikoki, Chikan, Futanari, Pettanko, Shimapan.......

It is such a... uhh... diverse, amount of classification that is seemingly invented to fit all sorts of situations......

 

[Dedication Through Light]

Megane is a weird word?

 

[dumbyugi]

Ya know... hentai really has a lot of weird words for uh.... their classification.

Stuff like Mizugi, Netorare, Paizure, Megane, Osananajimi (WTF), Oppai, Kemonomimi, Ahegao, Ashikoki, Chikan, Futanari, Pettanko, Shimapan.......

It is such a... uhh... diverse, amount of classification that is seemingly invented to fit all sorts of situations......

Porn in general tends to classify by fetish types, hentai just uses Japanese words for different fetishes. Osananajimi is childhood friend by the way.

 

[Antiwhippy]

HSDK

Whao, thought tanaka had it in the bag for awhile there, but goddamn at kensei caving in his head into his fucking body.

You know. this arc turned out waaay better than expected. Thought it was going to be dumb disciple fights for awhile.

 

[LeleSocho]

Megane is a weird word?

Are you calling these not weird?

 

[BassForever]

Did he kick your dog or something? Why would you inflict this upon an innocent?

The only series on this list that is questionable is Deathnote mostly because part 2 sucks balls. It's still worth checking out at least for part 1 just say part 2 doesn't happen.

 

[dakkumauji]

Silver Spoon 76

D'awww Vice President is so cute in the snow.

 

[Antiwhippy]

Chihiro anywhere other than last is inconcievable. Her defining character trait is that she's plain and boring.

She's the only one who seems like she has an actual chemistry with keima.

Also every girl in this manga is kinda boring. Except for Yui.

 

[bigkrev]

But death Note isn't nearly as intellectual as it thinks it is and YGO is just ugh.

Says the guy who plays YGO . I think its great up through Battle City, its fine to bail out after that before everything starts to go to shit.

 

[BassForever]

Says the guy who plays YGO . I think its great up through Battle City, its fine to bail out after that before everything starts to go to shit.

Honestly if you've invested enough of YGO to get though Battle City you might as well read the last arc, besides the final duel at the end makes whatever issue the millennium arc has go away IMO

 

[Eleuin]

Hello Mangaf! I've lurked the thread for a little bit and besides Wednesdays this place is alright.

I've read Aunt tits, food smut and Molestor Man thanks to you guys so cheers for that.

Of the big three I'm only caught up with Naruto because I already read up until after Itachi's death and I might as well finish it at this point.

I see I came at the right moment with the twgok tiers
Ayumi is clearly best girl and the current arc is dragging on because its focusing on worst girl Tenri.

 

[bigkrev]

Hello Mangaf! I've lurked the thread for a little bit and besides Wednesdays this place is alright.

I've read Aunt tits, food smut and Molestor Man thanks to you guys so cheers for that.

Of the big three I'm only caught up with Naruto because I already read up until after Itachi's death and I might as well finish it at this point.

I see I came at the right moment with the twgok tiers
Ayumi is clearly best girl and the current arc is dragging on because its focusing on worst girl Tenri.

Ah, friend. You will fit in just fine.

 

[B-Dubs]

This is still the definitive and correct list.

God Tier
Tenri/Diana
Ayumi/Mercury
Yui/Mars

Top Tier
Chihiro
Tsukiyo/Vulcan

High Tier
Elsie
Miyako
Urara
Nanaka

Mid Tier
Akari
Sumire
Haqua

Low Tier
Dokurou
Jun
Kanon/Apollo
Shiori/Minerva
Rieko
Kusunoki
Mio
Minami
Mari

Garbage Tier
Nora
Hinoki

I can live with this.

Ippo 1011

Poor guy is never going to get anywhere with her so long as she lives with her brother. I'll admit I still find it funny though.

Hello Mangaf! I've lurked the thread for a little bit and besides Wednesdays this place is alright.

I've read Aunt tits, food smut and Molestor Man thanks to you guys so cheers for that.

Of the big three I'm only caught up with Naruto because I already read up until after Itachi's death and I might as well finish it at this point.

I see I came at the right moment with the twgok tiers
Ayumi is clearly best girl and the current arc is dragging on because its focusing on worst girl Tenri.

No, you are wrong. Now we must do kung fu at each other.

 

[Soma]

Hello Mangaf! I've lurked the thread for a little bit and besides Wednesdays this place is alright.

I've read Aunt tits, food smut and Molestor Man thanks to you guys so cheers for that.

You're pretty alright yourself!

 

[dakkumauji]

To Aru Kagaku no Railgun 60

Hm, I'm ok with that characterization for the Queen.

 

[Dedication Through Light]

K – Side: Black & White 1 (ln)

Imagining Kuroh as a kid and trying to cook and even use his clansman powers (though as a novice) is an alright experience. I think the writer of this section though could have spiced it up a bit and focused less on the teacher that is clearly wanting to get with Miwa Ichigen.

 

[scy]

And smutGAF grows stronger...

 

[Dedication Through Light]

Haikyuu!! 62

Nishinoya got so high in the air from that and such an excited Yamaguchi, lol. I didnt see the push em back push em back seijou, I hope Oikawa and Iwaizumi are thinking of someway to counter this or something, will be crushed if they lose, but it would make this one of the best moments in the series if Karasuno can win with this Hinata Kageyama full distance quick attack.

 

[BassForever]

Hello Mangaf! I've lurked the thread for a little bit and besides Wednesdays this place is alright.

I've read Aunt tits, food smut and Molestor Man thanks to you guys so cheers for that.

Of the big three I'm only caught up with Naruto because I already read up until after Itachi's death and I might as well finish it at this point.

I see I came at the right moment with the twgok tiers
Ayumi is clearly best girl and the current arc is dragging on because its focusing on worst girl Tenri.

Hope you enjoy the stay, we don't bite... much

 

[Antiwhippy]

Just don't expect any constructive discussions here.

 

[Articalys]

Why did I get assigned Nisekoi?

 

[Akito]

Why did I get assigned Nisekoi?

Articalys is Nisekoi because he actually seems to like it without irony.

.

 

[Articalys]

Well, that's what I get for skimming through five pages of the thread without looking too carefully.

And I only liked it unironically when the plot wasn't incredibly stupid like it is now.

 

[Stat Flow]

Hello Mangaf! I've lurked the thread for a little bit and besides Wednesdays this place is alright.

Already declaring your intentions against us.

 

[Wiseblade]

Well, that's what I get for skimming through five pages of the thread without looking too carefully.

And I only liked it unironically when the plot wasn't incredibly stupid like it is now.

At least you read the thing you're associated with.

 

[Village]

Manga gaf, do you have any good manga.

Happy stuff, or sad whatever.

I am in a horrible place right now.

 

[Wiseblade]

Manga gaf, do you have any good manga.

Happy stuff, or sad whatever.

I am in a horrible place right now.

Yotsuba!