• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Marvel going street level w/ Netflix (Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Exactly. They can change almost everything about a character but his race makes people go wild. Ridiculous.

It is a case of visual identification. All those chances are relevant but do not impact the way the caracter look is imprinted in fans memory.

Change a carácter look, even like only a change of hair color, and people will complain. Try making Thor a redhead in the movies (as hes is in the Nordic Mithology) and you will see.
 

rexor0717

Member
All I'm going to say on the subject is that Danny Rand should be white. If they want to make an Iron Fist show about one of the other Iron Fists (most of which are in fact Asian) then that's fine by me. But if it's Danny Rand keep him white.

It is a problem overall that all of the well known superheroes are white guys, but that's a product of those primarily being what the characters in the comics were. Thankfully Marvel is bringing in more black heroes and female heroes with War Machine, Falcon, Black Panther, Luke Cage, Jessica Jones, and Ms. Marvel. It's not a bad effort, especially considering how white male dominated the Marvel Universe is. Unfortunately there aren't too many great established Asian characters. That said, I'm not a fan of changing a character's race just for the sake of saying "look, now we have a character that is Asian!" We can have an Asian Iron Fist just like we now have a Black Spider-Man or Black Captain America. The important thing is they are not making actual characters like Peter Parker or Steve Rogers black, they are making new characters (or old characters that had a different alias) take up the mantle of those heroes. That's the right way to go about it. Making Danny Rand non-white is just going to piss off fans of the character and it simply isn't necessary.
Yep, thats exactly how I feel about it. On that note, I would absolutely love for Sam Wilson to take up the Cap mantle after Steven Rogers in the MCU although I feel like they're setting Bucky up for it.
 

Neoxon

Junior Member
All I'm going to say on the subject is that Danny Rand should be white. If they want to make an Iron Fist show about one of the other Iron Fists (most of which are in fact Asian) then that's fine by me. But if it's Danny Rand keep him white.

It is a problem overall that all of the well known superheroes are white guys, but that's a product of those primarily being what the characters in the comics were. Thankfully Marvel is bringing in more black heroes and female heroes with War Machine, Falcon, Black Panther, Luke Cage, Jessica Jones, and Captain Marvel. It's not a bad effort, especially considering how white male dominated the Marvel Universe is. Unfortunately there aren't too many great established Asian characters. That said, I'm not a fan of changing a character's race just for the sake of saying "look, now we have a character that is Asian!" We can have an Asian Iron Fist just like we now have a Black Spider-Man or Black Captain America. The important thing is they are not making actual characters like Peter Parker or Steve Rogers black, they are making new characters (or old characters that had a different alias) take up the mantle of those heroes. That's the right way to go about it. Making Danny Rand non-white is just going to piss off fans of the character and it simply isn't necessary.
FTFY. No way they're gonna introduce Kamala Khan before Carol Danvers.
 

Bracewell

Member
FTFY. No way they're gonna introduce Kamala Khan before Carol Danvers.

Which is how this plays out in every scenario. The classic characters always get higher priority for film adaptations. Turns out all those classic characters are incredibly white, so one or two minor supporting characters get turned into PoC. This pisses off comic book purists, because "you shouldn't make white characters non-white, you should make new non-white characters". Some writer comes up with Kamala Khan as the new Ms. Marvel, but since Carol Danvers is a classic, she needs to get her shot on the big screen first.

We need to collectively keep thinking of new reasons to delay having to portray diverse superheroes on screen, because the execs at the big studios aren't doing that enough already.
 

Blader

Member
Carol Danvers is not really the classic Captain Marvel though. She's like three or four Captain Marvels down the line.
 

TDLink

Member
Which is how this plays out in every scenario. The classic characters always get higher priority for film adaptations. Turns out all those classic characters are incredibly white, so one or two minor supporting characters get turned into PoC. This pisses off comic book purists, because "you shouldn't make white characters non-white, you should make new non-white characters". Some writer comes up with Kamala Khan as the new Ms. Marvel, but since Carol Danvers is a classic, she needs to get her shot on the big screen first.

We need to collectively keep thinking of new reasons to delay having to portray diverse superheroes on screen, because the execs at the big studios aren't doing that enough already.

They have already said they're going to do Carol Danvers but personally I wouldn't have minded if it was Kamala. I wouldn't have minded if the new Spider-Man was Miles instead of Peter either, especially since we've had Peter twice now. Unfortunately that just isn't the way Marvel wants to go with it. But that's a Hollywood problem in general.

As an aside, I'm happy that it's rumoured that Jon Stewart is finally going to get his shot on the big screen as Green Lantern. But it's still bullshit that he has to share that with Hal Jordan and after Hal Jordan already got his big screen movie (which was bad). Hollywood is making baby steps though. It is cool that of the new MCU Avengers team there's only one white guy on it.

For the record, Carol Danvers (And Ms/Captain Marvel in general) isn't really classic in the same way that many of the other heroes Marvel have brought to screen are. The sad fact is that they just don't have that many headlining female heroes so they kind of have to dig down for someone. Since they're doing that already it didn't need to be a white woman but since it's their first female led film to begin with I guess that's how they're mitigating the risk or whatever. I don't agree with those sentiments but it's not surprising that that is how they're looking at it.

Also, I don't mind when minor supporting characters get their race changed. For example, as a Norse god it is a bit silly for Heimdall to be Idris Elba but ultimately it doesn't matter because him being white isn't actually an important part of the character.

For Danny Rand it absolutely is though. For that character especially, being a rich white boy is pretty important both for his stories in New York and K'un-Lun.
 

jph139

Member
Kamala is super hot right now - she has as much momentum behind her, if not more, than Carol. I'd bet that Marvel is desperate to get her on the screen ASAP and, honestly, wouldn't be surprised to see her out before the Captain Marvel movie.
 

GAMEPROFF

Banned
The Jessica Jones Artbook is releasing in europe on the 28.11.2015.
Since the regular shedule with Marvels Artbooks is always 2-4 weeks after the movie/show starts, we should expect a start in early November.
 

Terrell

Member
The Jessica Jones Artbook is releasing in europe on the 28.11.2015.
Since the regular shedule with Marvels Artbooks is always 2-4 weeks after the movie/show starts, we should expect a start in early November.

I seriously hope so, because the wait for more Netflix Marvel goodness is seriously killing me.
 
I imagine Inhumans' climax involves New York getting Terrigen gassed. Cue post-credits scene with some New Jersey Muslim family watching it on the news, with a cut to their daughter's empty bedroom with an open window.
 

Slayven

Member
I imagine Inhumans' climax involves New York getting Terrigen gassed. Cue post-credits scene with some New Jersey Muslim family watching it on the news, with a cut to their daughter's empty bedroom with an open window.

and that little girl is
Thanos
 
I think the idea of new characters taking up the "mantle" is perfectly fine, but is there any examples of it ever happening in films? The closest I can think of is the hint that Gordon-Levitt would take up the Batman mantle, but we never actually saw it happen. It seems to be a very "comic book" thing, a result of them simultaneously wanting to keep alive popular franchises but still wanting to move the series along with significant story lines. Otherwise you get The Walking Dead syndrome where you pick up new character, lose some, they settle, they get attacked, they flee ad nauseam with nothing changing. I get all that, but I don't think that aspect translates very well to the screen, because you don't get a new film every month etc. It could well be that a character is a different race in a reboot, but that's different to taking up a mantle. Maybe it'd work a bit better in something like a TV show like Daredevil. But to me, if they want more minority ethnicites in starring roles, they'd be better off just making new characters (whether that's making whole new characters, or otherwise leveraging characters who've yet to have films or TV shows made of them).
 

obin_gam

Member
they have a golden opportunity now with their Netflix deal. Make Ms. Marvel a Netflix show in the veins of Spider-Man - heck, team the two up and have a fun young teen flick!
 
I imagine Inhumans' climax involves New York getting Terrigen gassed. Cue post-credits scene with some New Jersey Muslim family watching it on the news, with a cut to their daughter's empty bedroom with an open window.

they have a golden opportunity now with their Netflix deal. Make Ms. Marvel a Netflix show in the veins of Spider-Man - heck, team the two up and have a fun young teen flick!

The Inhumans movie can lead to some great stuff in MCU. But I doubt we will see Kamala on it. Too expensive for a tv series too.

By the way, I Just remember something. Does Marvel has the movie rights to the Krees? I thouht that they, together with the Skrulls, belong to Fantastic Four/Fox. Just like the Shiar with X-men (reason that none were in Guardians). So what does it means to Carol?
 
The Inhumans movie can lead to some great stuff in MCU. But I doubt we will see Kamala on it. Too expensive for a tv series too.

By the way, I Just remember something. Does Marvel has the movie rights to the Krees? I thouht that they, together with the Skrulls, belong to Fantastic Four/Fox. Just like the Shiar with X-men (reason that none were in Guardians). So what does it means to Carol?
The Kree were in Guardians of the Galaxy.
 

richiek

steals Justin Bieber DVDs
http://screencrush.com/netflix-luke-cage-cottonmouth-marvel/

GettyImages-469735946d.jpg


Luke Cage will face Cottonmouth in show pilot.
 
"State of Affairs" star Alfre Woodward will star alongside Mike Colter in "Luke Cage" as Minetta, who will be a lead character in the series.

According to Deadline, Woodward's character Minetta is "a powerful woman in local politics who will have an impact on Luke Cage’s life." Though no further details have been provided about the role, the announcement speculates that Woodward's character will be Black Mariah, a frequent antagonist for both Cage and iron Fist in the comics.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/article/alfre-woodard-joins-marvels-luke-cage-netflix-series
 

jph139

Member
So doing the math on Woodard's casting - assuming she's the main antagonist as speculated - puts us at an early summer release for Luke Cage. Vincent D'onofrio was announced in June 2014, show premiered in April 2015 (~10 months). David Tennant was announced in January 2015, show expected to premiere around November 2015 (~10 months). Woodard announced in August 2015, show premiere around June 2015.

I think that's pretty sensible - give Daredevil some breathing room but still keep things on track for the Defenders.
 
No ome has posted the pics of the new Daredevil costume? I am shocked!

https://mobile.twitter.com/Daredevil/status/634168013344739329/photo/1

https://mobile.twitter.com/RuhailAli/status/634171288123244545/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc^tfw

Also, I would like to start the Daredevil Season 2 Production thread when this ok.
It's not as blocky but still looks way too silly lol. Sorry but the transition of a bright red devil makes him look like he went to halloween. And this is in a universe with Captain America.
 

Retro

Member
It's not as blocky but still looks way too silly lol. Sorry but the transition of a bright red devil makes him look like he went to halloween. And this is in a universe with Captain America.

Probably needs to be a brighter shade of red because they'll be doing most of the shooting in low light. I don't think we'll ever see it in conditions like that second picture.

Having said that, there wasn't much of a problem with visibility in Season 1 and he was in all black, so... /shrug.
 

Dai101

Banned
They should just go back and do the Fox Costume. It was perfect. One of the best superhero movie costumes ever.

lol no. I like the movie (the DC that is) but the bright red just doesn't work. Love the leather tho', is somewhat functional.

It's not as blocky but still looks way too silly lol. Sorry but the transition of a bright red devil makes him look like he went to halloween. And this is in a universe with Captain America.

They need to fix the cowl somehow, maybe just adding a chin-strap just like Caps always get better whith it and looks just silly without.
 

jph139

Member
That was confirmed to be a prototype of the first suit, not a newer version (the bright red one, that is, not the official teaser in a box).
 

DonasaurusRex

Online Ho Champ
They should just go back and do the Fox Costume. It was perfect. One of the best superhero movie costumes ever.

it was on this day i realized i need a "do you smoke crack".gif

come on now let that film die and only speak of the directors cut if you must (is there a version that cuts out the stupid playground fight scene?)
 

Pachimari

Member
No ome has posted the pics of the new Daredevil costume? I am shocked!

https://mobile.twitter.com/Daredevil/status/634168013344739329/photo/1

https://mobile.twitter.com/RuhailAli/status/634171288123244545/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc^tfw

Also, I would like to start the Daredevil Season 2 Production thread when this ok.
It have been talked about for days in the Daredevil OT.

And I think the second link is a prototype for Season 1. And it looks ugly.

I agree they should make a costume like the FOX Daredevil costume and just fix the mask.
 

GAMEPROFF

Banned
it was on this day i realized i need a "do you smoke crack".gif

come on now let that film die and only speak of the directors cut if you must (is there a version that cuts out the stupid playground fight scene?)
The movie had it flaws, I am always fucking angry when I see what they did to Bullseye, but the DDs costume was just great. Looked like it is supposed to do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom