Not to defend it but what you think will happen to the gamepass library about 10 years from now? Really people believe to preserve all their library behind a paywal service? Digital library is not forever
I dont understand your gamepass comparison because its a subscription service - you're just renting everything.
The only comparison there is something like Sega Genesis Segachannel or Nintendo's satellite service which was shut down quickly.
For me personally, ill never get gamepass - not for me. I buy exactly what I want and dont have the desire to just play games on a whim.
The only real long term digital gaming examples from my experience are:
-Steam - I can still play all of my Steam purchases from when it was released in 2003 just fine.
-For Xbox, I purchased several original and 360 Xbox games digitally in the late 2000's (like Orta, NG Black, Lost Planet 2) that now play on new Xbox hardware.
-I never had a wii in its prime (I have one now) but from what I understand you can no longer download your digital purchases there.
-Sony shutting down PS3 store worries me that its only a matter of time before my digital PS3 titles wont be downloadable - the shutdown doesnt set a good precedent. Apparantly the cbomb news also affects PS3 digital purchases (not digital AND physical like the Ps4).
Most of this comes down to your perspective and preference in gaming. Some only play the latest and greatest. For me - I currently, in 2021, have 14 consoles still hooked up.
I play my NES, Genesis, SNES, PC Engine, PS1/2/3, Dreamcast along with modern stuff. If im going to spend thousands of dollars on PS4/5, XSX, Switch games - I expect to be able to play what I bought 30 years from now. The fact that this cbomb issue also affects physical disc games is a big deal from my perspective.
But again Sony
can fix this with a simple software fix.