What's important is whether he's misreading the Constitution or the law, not whether he misreads the state of the country or the consequences. The problem with the preclearance requirement was not that it was completely unnecessary everywhere, but that it wasn't targeted to where it was necessary today.
(And Citizens United was correctly decided, of course, and the terrible consequences predicted by liberals have failed to materialize.)
I think it wasn't the country that he midread but rather Congress. Remember, the Court basically said the old formula was outdated and needed revision and Congress needs to do it.
Basically, what they said a few years prior but without striking down those portions of the VRA. I'm guessing Kennedy/Roberts thought by striking it down Congress would do its duty. They were wrong. The Republicans don't care because they just want their votes.
That was the miscalculation. Not that racism is dead or that states wouldn't try to do racist shit but that Congress would actually function as a governing body (or more specifically Congressional Republicans).
I think Kennedy, and possibly Roberts, regret that decision now. They put their faith in clowns.
(My point is you could make a valid case their argument for striking down those portions of the VRA were correct on some points but at the end of the day they needed to remain until competent people can fix the issue).
Also, regarding the NC decision. What is striking is not that is was struck down like in Wi and Tx. What was striking was not that the evidence showed the act discriminated.
The key finding, IMO, was that the Court's opinion was that the law was
intentionally discriminatory towards African Americans. This could be them signaling the Obama Administration for preclearance? I mean...it was very sharp in tone with regards to this point. Unlike in Tx where they ruled that the law happened to cause discrimination against certain people, the NC Court ruled the law was written with that specific intention. Yikes.
BTW, Meta, may I ask you 2 unrelated questions?
1. What state do you live in?
2. Who do you intend to vote for in the Presidential election.
Obviously, you don't have to answer. I know you're not voting Trump, but I'm curious if you're voting Hillary or 3rd party or not at all (for Pres that is). And if you're not in a swing state, would you change your vote if you were in one?