• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

PopGaf OT-X | Confirmed: Mariah Carey is the Queen of PopGAF

Status
Not open for further replies.
Judas was the moment I knew that Gaga would never be an icon.

Born This Gay (the song) didn't tip you off?

iUl9EcvtsJ4Y8.gif
 

Matt_

World's #1 One Direction Fan: Everyone else in the room can see it, everyone else but you~~~
born this way (the song) gets way to much hate
that song is catchy as fuck
 

Floridian

Member
I think I underappreciated born this way (album). Especially compared to its successor. I would say it's her 2nd best album, behind TFM.
 

Mau ®

Member
I listened to Born This Way a few months ago and it still held up well. It really is a body of work that only Gaga could make.
 
One song, as good as it is, can't redeem it from the rotten part.

And don't even get me started on those WRETCHED remixes.

I don't know what you mean. Born This Way's country road version is iconic. When will Dolly Parton?

The DJWS remix of Scheiße is genuinely great tho. As is his Mugler remix for Government Hooker which is better than the album version.
 

Matt_

World's #1 One Direction Fan: Everyone else in the room can see it, everyone else but you~~~
dolly's glastonbury show >>>>>
i dont even like country and I was thoroughly slain
 

Vazra

irresponsible vagina leak
9 to 5 is [ i m m e n s e l y ] iconic.



ddlfmlkdsjfldjflkasjdljasjdl

This whole video needs to be giffed.
I want your love and
I want your revenge
You and me could write a bad romance
(Oh-oh-oh--oh-oh!)
I want your love and
All your lover's revenge
You and me could write a bad romance
6eaeecdc39.gif
 

WonderzL

Banned
I've pretty much listened only to BTW my entire high school years. Nonstop. So I can't listen to it and think it's fresh anymore, but I think it's very unique and interesting. She will never top TFW though, unfortunately. But I'm here for ha whenever she feels up to make new music
 

cory64

Member
I've pretty much listened only to BTW my entire high school years. Nonstop. So I can't listen to it and think it's fresh anymore, but I think it's very unique and interesting. She will never top TFW though, unfortunately. But I'm here for ha whenever she feels up to make new music

I listened to this album almost every day of high school and I still think it's fresh. Poor BTW.
 
MI0000374790.jpg

Still fresh.

It was the 12th anniversary of that album a few days ago.

Fallen was the first album I was completely obsessed with, so it was the album that really got me into music in general. I only use a few tracks from the album these days though, can't tolerate the rest anymore.

The Open Door is the better album from them.

Not me revisiting Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge and bopping to it.

I still really like Helena.
 

twobear

sputum-flecked apoplexy
At least it gave us fair warning that Daft Punk's comeback alber would be a Real Music flop too.

eek, yes

Franz Ferdinand, what a fucking ALBER

jacqueline was seventeen
and working on a desk
when ivor peer above her spectacles...
 

3phemeral

Member
The only songs I still use on BTW:

Electric Chapel
Marry the Night
Heavy Metal Lover
Scheiße
Bloody Mary
Government Hooker
Born This Way - Jost and Naaf Remix


i0nDVgY5E3ftS.gif
iGFSDy4KVmMMT.png
i0nDVgY5E3ftS.gif
iGFSDy4KVmMMT.png
i0nDVgY5E3ftS.gif
iGFSDy4KVmMMT.png
i0nDVgY5E3ftS.gif
iGFSDy4KVmMMT.png


I can only listen to You and I if it includes the video. I love the scatter-brained edits and overall visual direction.
 

Vazra

irresponsible vagina leak
It was the 12th anniversary of that album a few days ago.

Fallen was the first album I was completely obsessed with, so it was the album that really got me into music in general. I only use a few tracks from the album these days though, can't tolerate the rest anymore.

What I didn't like was people shitting on The Open Door for not being Fallen 2.0. Then when they got what literally is Fallen 2.0 with a little hint of evolution at the end they were complaining. The fanbase is a mess.
 

twobear

sputum-flecked apoplexy
so if you're lonely
you know i'm here
waiting for you
i'm just a crosshair
i'm just a shot away from you
and if you leave here
you leave me broken
shattered
a lie
i'm just a crosshair
i'm just a shot
then we can die
i know
i wont
be leaving here
with
youuuuuuuuuu


ibyA3lUc4OMCt1.gif
 
Judas was the moment I knew that Gaga would never be an icon.
Ikr. So completely not iconic that it's not like she completely inspired a new wave of weirdness amongst the pop girls + single handedly brought dance pop back into the limelight 👀
Please don't fool yourself, Gaga is an icon. Her reign at the top may have been short but nobody else is still talked about as much as her, and it's very easy to spot the mark she left on pop culture.
BTW is what sowed the seeds for Artpop's demise tbh.

iUl9EcvtsJ4Y8.gif
Wrong tbh. But this opinion is less wrong than the one above so I'm ok with it
iUl9EcvtsJ4Y8.gif
 

cory64

Member
single handedly brought dance pop back into the limelight ��

This is a DAMNED lie and I'm not gonna stand for it.

Toxic
SOS
Stronger
Gimme More
Don't Stop The Music
Feedback
Disturbia
Womanizer
Keeps Gettin Better
Even the thief recorded a dancepop song before Gaga blew up

eek, yes

Franz Ferdinand, what a fucking ALBER

jacqueline was seventeen
and working on a desk
when ivor peer above her spectacles...

I listened to that alber every single day of summer 2004.
Changed my life tbh, "Michael" may have been my first gay experience in media (that wasn't stereotypey stuff)
 

twobear

sputum-flecked apoplexy
god absolutely everything about Franz Ferdinand is perfect

you my can feel my lips undress your eyes
undress your eyes
undress your eyes

skin can't feel my lips they tingle
tense anticipation
this one is an easy one
feel the word and melt upon it

words and love and words so leisured
words are poisoned darts of pleasure

dieeeeee
and so you die


iyjIEHlZO72TM.gif


Changed my life tbh, "Michael" may have been my first gay experience in media (that wasn't stereotypey stuff)

SIS!

me too!

when i realised that it was about a boy, i was embarrassed to listen to it because i wasn't out of the closet

but to have written such an unashamedly sexy song about fancying a guy, the power, the influence. and for it to not be a joke or tongue in cheek. a life affirming moment for a young queer growing up in rural england tbh.

this is what i am
i am a man
so come and dance with me michael


imMUNLOmx2d0R.gif
 

Vazra

irresponsible vagina leak
Kacey Musgraves new single Biscuits drops March 17
B-zC75bWoAAC31z.jpg


Ivy Levan and her impact already. Purchase Ivy Levan "Biscuit" on iTunes.
c930bb9ebf.gif
 
I wish Fergie had longevitity so she could had done more Dutchess albums. She was better than half the pop girls we have now, and Glamorous & london bridge were the best things she's done.

iUl9EcvtsJ4Y8.gif
Glamorous { d e s t r o y s } me
LA love was okay I guess. but nothing on her old shit.
Kacey Musgraves new single Biscuits drops March 17
B-zC75bWoAAC31z.jpg


Ivy Levan and her impact already. Purchase Ivy Levan "Biscuit" on iTunes.
c930bb9ebf.gif
Ivy should sue. Biscuit >>>>>> whatever this is going to be probably.
 

Vazra

irresponsible vagina leak
Glamorous { d e s t r o y s } me
LA love was okay I guess. but nothing on her old shit.

Ivy should sue. Biscuit >>>>>> whatever this is going to be probably.

The lyrics of the Kacey song are disgusting.

Mend your own fences
And own your own crazy
Mind your own biscuits
And life will be gravy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom