Well, I don't recall any of the games mentioned uniting people who had not played it in such unwavering certainty of it's low quality on (apparently) all fronts or having their review threads locked by moderators due to the level of trolling going on, but if I'm simply forgetting this occurring, feel free to provide any examples that show where my error lies.
NeoGAF around the time of the MGS4 and FFXIII was the fucking pits (lurker talking). The Order didn't even come close.