Support NeoGAF

[BobTheFork]

So ps3 version slight frame drops
360 major tearing
I assume this will eventually get a PC version though.

Spoiler

warning, sarcasm may induce rage.

 

[Majine]

So ps3 version slight frame drops
360 major tearing
I assume this will eventually get a PC version though.

Remind me, but wasn't the PC version of GTA IV pretty horrible overall?

 

[Yoshi256]

All I read is New York Times Review, L.A. Times review, where the hell are the IGN, Gametrailers, Gamepro and Gamespot reviews? Wasn't the embargo lifted this morning?

 

[TheVampire]

Ive been playing RDR on 360 for about 6 hours and I havnt noticed any tearing.
The performance has been great.


Now something like Alan Wake I noticed the tearing but not in this game.

 

[BobTheFork]

Remind me, but wasn't the PC version of GTA IV pretty horrible overall?

To my knowledge no, it looked great. All the screens I've seen certainly look really nice. The mod make all the difference as well. I would love to see what mods come from a RDR pc version.

Ive been playing RDR on 360 for about 6 hours and I havnt noticed any tearing.

Ha! Too late, someone else saw tearing once. It's now an official bullet to be fired in the console wars(tm)

 

[Majine]

To my knowledge no, it looked great.

I never played it, but seem to remember alot of rage about something in the PC version...

Nvm.

 

[ConradCervantes]

To my knowledge no, it looked great. All the screens I've seen certainly look really nice. The mod make all the difference as well. I would love to see what mods come from a RDR pc version.

He probably meant in terms of performance; in which case, yes, for the majority of PC folk, the game ran horribly.

 

[BobTheFork]

He probably meant in terms of performance; in which case, yes, for the majority of PC folk, the game ran horribly.

ah, it was a memory hog wasn't it?

 

[Dabanton]

Haha where is this 360 tearing nonsense coming from? some people are talking like they've seen it with their own eyes, they also all seem to be getting the PS3 version...

Whatever makes you feel better boys. :lol

 

[Noisepurge]

yeah the tearing issue was also confirmed after the ending credits of Brisco County Jr.

 

[Mik2121]

Can you guys stop this lame 360 vs PS3 thing now?. We already know it performs greatly on both consoles, no need to discuss anything else. God damn...

 

[ConradCervantes]

Haha where is this 360 tearing nonsense coming from? some people are talking like they've seen it with their own eyes, they also all seem to be getting the PS3 version...

Whatever makes you feel better boys. :lol

A member here (Magnus?) got his hands on both skus and did some comparing. Slight slowdown on PS3 sku, some tearing on XB360 sku. Overall the differences are negligible unless you REALLY have an eye for these sorts of things, which frankly I'm grateful that I don't.

 

[GreekWolf]

So ps3 version slight frame drops
360 major tearing
I assume this will eventually get a PC version though.

This is really, really stupid.

Multi-console owners are genuinely interested in weighing the pros and cons between both versions before making a purchasing decision, and you're blatantly spreading FUD.

 

[Dabanton]

A member here (Magnus?) got his hands on both skus and did some comparing. Slight slowdown on PS3 sku, some tearing on XB360 sku. Overall the differences are negligible unless you REALLY have an eye for these sorts of things, which frankly I'm grateful that I don't.

That's strange as i could swear he said this...

Haven't seen any screen-tearing in the 360 version myself yet.

 

[BobTheFork]

This is really, really stupid.

Multi-console owners are genuinely interested in weighing the pros and cons between both versions before making a purchasing decision, and you're blatantly spreading FUD.

obviously. Hopefully obvious enough that's it's sarcasm. It's basically a contradiction of the posts right before me.


edit MAgus wasn't the one who talked about tearing. Can't remember, but some said they saw it slightly once and one guy was talking from the depths of his ass and saying it ahd tearing just because the ps3 version had v-sync

 

[ConradCervantes]

That's strange as i could swear he said this...

Ah. I must've attributed it to the wrong fellow. I just assumed it was he who said it since thus far he's the only person who's played both versions and is writing about it.

I'm also a poor researcher when tired and slightly buzzed.

 

[CaseyTappy]

Imaginary Tearing is the worst , you keep looking for it .........distracting you as you play !

 

[GreekWolf]

obviously. Hopefully obvious enough that's it's sarcasm. It's basically a contradiction of the posts right before me.

Damn it, you're right. That's what I get for skimming pages.

Sorry mate. I'm still annoyed that I bought the wrong version of Ghostbusters. On the plus side, it makes a fanciful and decorative coaster.

 

[Windom Earle]

The tearing discussion is bullshit. Geez, why does everyone believe the fud "einkeiexpress" is spreading? He's the guy who falsely claimed to be Rockstar employee as well.

careful, you dont want to stir up some hub hub now do you?

It's just funny to see chandoog suddenly so concerned about resolution, while it was a non issue in the Alan Wake thread :lol

 

[Hunter Gather]

So ps3 version slight frame drops
360 major tearing
I assume this will eventually get a PC version though.

Where do see anyone say 'major tearing'. Go wine somewhere else.

 

[BobTheFork]

Where do see anyone say 'major tearing'. Go whine somewhere else.

We just covered this, look up.

 

[Deleted member 30609]

I want a version of the box-art that correctly titles the game: Haunted's Avatar: The Game

 

[NHale]

Imaginary Tearing is the worst , you keep looking for it .........distracting you as you play !

Even worse is when you see a bad texture and start wondering if the other version also has that bad texture. It pisses me off and I often quit the game and never play it again. I can't stand the feeling of other people playing a game that has 1 small thing better than my version.

I also can't stand jaggies. I can't play games with them unless they are exclusives, in that case they don't bother me.

 

[MMaRsu]

I want a version of the box-art that correctly titles the game: Haunted's Avatar: The Game

You getting this too? Awesome ^^

 

[Deleted member 30609]

You getting this too? Awesome ^^

not day one, unfortunately. some time in June, though!

 

[FrankT]

So ps3 version slight frame drops
360 major tearing
I assume this will eventually get a PC version though.

Uh no. Fud.

I've been watching the vids all weekend and seen no such thing. Now I haven't been playing it, but will be tonight but this guy has been in here posting about playing it multiple times so I'll take his word for it;

Ive been playing RDR on 360 for about 6 hours and I havnt noticed any tearing.
The performance has been great.


Now something like Alan Wake I noticed the tearing but not in this game.

Of course there is this too;

Haven't seen any screen-tearing in the 360 version myself yet

.

:lol
I didn't intend that to top a page. I can't expect anyone to scroll past that and see the rest.

edit: holy hell you edited in more still without reading past that post, I really must have pissed you off. again, read the end of the last page, it was sarcastic.

Oh it was sarcasm. Oh hahahaaa.

 

[BobTheFork]

Uh no. Fud.

:lol
I didn't intend that to top a page. I can't expect anyone to scroll past that and see the rest.

edit: holy hell you edited in more still without reading past that post, I really must have pissed you off. again, read the end of the last page, it was sarcastic.

 

[CaseyTappy]

I find there's a lot more poop up/in on the PS3 version !

Spoiler

filthy horses

 

[Always-honest]

You might want to set the RGB Full Range option to Limited (Settings > Display Settings)

indeed. cause that's what it does when your screen doesn't support it (many don't)

 

[Haunted]

I want a version of the box-art that correctly titles the game: Haunted's Avatar: The Game

You know you read too much GAF if screenshots remind you of a poster's avatar instead of the actual game. :lol

 

[Yoshi256]

I hope there is a cheat for the DeLorean, finally a good Back to the Future III videogame.

 

[Deleted member 30609]

You know you read too much GAF if screenshots remind you of a poster's avatar instead of the actual game. :lol

I didn't know what Red Dead was prior to this game, and it has been your avatar since I've been on GAF. I'm a reasonable man, get off my case.

 

[Always-honest]

pre-ordering ps3 version.

thanx magnus. i can live with minor framerate drops.
richer sound, less apparent jaggies (softer, i know), and better friends..(the most important part)

 

[englishbob]

Re: The tearing on the 360 version.

Maybe those that have said its "tearing" is because they are upscaling it to 1080p?

Lost Planet 2 is terrible at 1080p, has loads of tearing, set it to 720p and its perfect. Maybe RDR is the same?

 

[Haunted]

I didn't know what Red Dead was prior to this game, and it has been your avatar since I've been on GAF. I'm a reasonable man, get off my case.

Oh, it happens to all of us. You should see the reactions when someone posts the concept art of Ramirez from Skies of Arcadia. :lol

If my avatar got you to try out any of the Red Dead series, then all the better.

 

[Tempy]

Sarcasm doesn't work on the innernets.

 

[BobTheFork]

Sarcasm doesn't work on the innernets.

well if it had come on the last page it would have made more sense.
I posted that after one person thought they saw tearing once while spinning the camera at top speed.

 

[Zeliard]

Please realize that the inevitable PC version will blow both out of the water as always and shut the fuck up with the thread-ruining 360 vs. PS3 second-place talk.

Goddamn. Every. Single. Time.

 

[MMaRsu]

pre-ordering ps3 version.

thanx magnus. i can live with minor framerate drops.
richer sound, less apparent jaggies (softer, i know), and better friends..(the most important part)

If you had me as an XBL friend you'd have better friends on XBL

 

[Gacha-pin]

Please realize that the inevitable PC version will blow both out of the water as always and shut the fuck up with the thread-ruining 360 vs. PS3 second-place talk.

Goddamn. Every. Single. Time.

Six months later, uh? I assume nobody talks about RDR 360 vs PS3 anymore

 

[Always-honest]

If you had me as an XBL friend you'd have better friends on XBL

well allow me to ad you

 

[Mik2121]

well allow me to ad you

Hey, do I have you on my PSN friends list? If not, give me your ID so I can add you.

 

[Dabanton]

Please realize that the inevitable PC version will blow both out of the water as always and shut the fuck up with the thread-ruining 360 vs. PS3 second-place talk.

Goddamn. Every. Single. Time.

Who's arguing that it won't?

All consoles owners care about is that they'll be playing this by the end of the week.

 

[MMaRsu]

well allow me to ad you

Just made a spot just for you

 

[JambiBum]

Just made a spot just for you

Aw aren't you two just cute

Spoiler

I wanna be friends

 

[Gacha-pin]

Just made a spot just for you

sounds you are a good guy

 

[Zeliard]

Who's arguing that it won't?

All consoles owners care about is that they'll be playing this by the end of the week.

If that were true then you'd be talking about the actual game. But it took one guy, who was a proven troll and is banned, to come in and start whining about both the 360 and PS3 versions for almost the entire discussion on RDR to turn to that.

360 vs PS3 again and again and again. How many times do we have to see it? I own both systems as well and have for years, but damn. It can be nice to know the differences between versions but sometimes you guys go too far with it. The game itself is far more interesting. The 360 and PS3 versions these days are generally similar enough that there just isn't much to talk about on the technical end unless we're in another Bayonetta situation. And with RDR, unless you're just gonna ignore the multi, it's best to go with your friends list. When the PC version finally comes along is when we get the (usually) far more technically proficient versions of these games.

I'm getting the 360 version by the way. Pre-ordered it from Amazon a long time ago, and I'm really looking forward to playing it tomorrow. Haven't looked forward to a game like this in a while.

 

[Hanmik]

The game itself is far more interesting. The 360 and PS3 versions these days are generally similar enough that there just isn't much to talk about on the technical end unless we're in another Bayonetta situation. And with RDR, unless you're just gonna ignore the multi, it's best to go with your friends list..

That´s the problem with RDR.. we never saw any pictures or movies with some PS3 footage. Rockstar just showed the X360 footage. So people started wondering if there was a reason for this.. that´s how the comparison started this time around. People where afraid of a Ghostbusters or Bayonetta situation.

 

[JordoftheDead]

360 vs PS3 again and again and again. How many times do we have to see it? I own both systems as well and have for years, but damn. It can be nice to know the differences between versions but sometimes you guys go too far with it. The game itself is far more interesting. The 360 and PS3 versions these days are generally similar enough that there just isn't much to talk about on the technical end unless we're in another Bayonetta situation. And with RDR, unless you're just gonna ignore the multi, it's best to go with your friends list. When the PC version finally comes along is when we get the (usually) far more technically proficient versions of these games.

See? It takes Carl Sagan to be the voice of reason.

 

[iMike76]

IGN's review drops from the heavens at 9:00 a.m. PST.