Support NeoGAF

[Dedication Through Light]

Hopefully they keep Kenji and Bebe's social link in it, I guess. Curious how they could do that in a movie while keeping the suspense high, oh and the beach scene with mc, Akihiko, and Stupei is a must.

 

[Ultimadrago]

MC Aigis true end

But of course. I thought they taught kids this stuff in schools.

 

[Envelope]

Mitsuru > Aigis.

Spoiler

Female main character > *

 

[cajunator]

Well, I don't know how humorous it is. How would you describe them?

Madoka - scared to make decisions. she will stick up for her friends no matter what. But shes completely overwhelmed by everything

Mami - she has a sense of duty as a magical girl and enjoys fighting. she has nothing to lose and is very protective.

Sayaka- brash, quick to make stupid decisions based on pride and jealousy.

Kyoko - an adorable smartass with a rough upbringing who fends for herself and doesnt put up with shit, but shes loyal to her friends

Homura - shy and lonely and desperate for companionship. Also very clingy. But so very badass.

not difficult. I think they did a great job characterizing all of them.

 

[Dragoon En Regalia]

Lupin III (1971) 5

Enjoyed yet another episode. No complaints about editting or such to be had here yet again which is nice. It doesn't hurt I'm a sucker for Goemon either. Fujiko was a little more duplicitous in this than I expected but I can't complain. All the Goemon action stuff? So cool.

I find myself thinking the revised OP with the character introductions was a good idea as well. It negates the barrier of entry to something episodic like this by giving just enough information about the characters.

Goemon is so cool...


and apparently a huge pervert.





The highway fight was top notch. Short, dynamic, and exciting.

Some very interesting animation during that highway scene, including the marvelous crashing and explosions right at the end. So ridiculous.

 

[Go_Ly_Dow]

fuuuuuuuuuu....

wanted a tv series

 

[Ultimadrago]

Sankarea 10

Spoiler

She's sloppy seconds.

Spoiler

So a step mother, that might explain why she doesn't seem to give a damn about Rea. Huh. This is the part where someone feels compelled to give a captor their life story when someone didn't ask for it.

Classic.

In short, another ineffective story based around more people whining over love (or lack of). When will it end?

 

[Soma]

Mitsuru > Aigis.

Envelope
Stamps of Approval

 

[dakkumauji]

Hopefully they keep Kenji and Bebe's social link in it, I guess. Curious how they could do that in a movie while keeping the suspense high, oh and the beach scene with mc, Akihiko, and Stupei is a must.

Considering it's a movie, I pretty much expect them to do nothing but the full moon events. Everything else would probably be literally cameos and fanservice.

Even just focusing on the full moon events, I still expect the movie to be rushing everything just to fit everything in.

 

[Grzi]

Akihiko > every other Persona character

 

[cajunator]

Congratulations on the tag, envelope.

 

[Risette]

Madoka - scared to make decisions. she will stick up for her friends no matter what. But shes completely overwhelmed by everything

Mami - she has a sense of duty as a magical girl and enjoys fighting. she has nothing to lose and is very protective.

Sayaka- brash, quick to make stupid decisions based on pride and jealousy.

Kyoko - an adorable smartass with a rough upbringing who fends for herself and doesnt put up with shit, but shes loyal to her friends

Homura - shy and lonely and desperate for companionship. Also very clingy. But so very badass.

not difficult. I think they did a great job characterizing all of them.

I hope you realized while typing this out that every character is pretty much identical :/

 

[Chet Rippo]

Mami - she has a sense of duty as a magical girl and enjoys fighting. she has nothing to lose and is very protective.

Except

Spoiler

her head.

 

[Ultimadrago]

Except

Spoiler

her head.

9/10

 

[cajunator]

I hope you realized while typing this out that every character is pretty much identical :/

Except they aren't.
Go hate on another series. there are plenty.

 

[Dresden]

The characters in Madoka are all pretty distinctive.

Madoka - pink

Mami - yellow

Homura - black/purple

Kyouko - red

Sakura - blue

Mugi - green

 

[Makoto]

Upotte!! 10 (FINAL)

Very informative and cute. Would have liked it to be more informative than cute however. 2/5.

 

[Kazzy]

Ah, so I guess they're going with the Male MC after all and not FemMC.

I approve but I bet a few people will probably be disappointed.

Come on, that was never going to happen. The story is built around the Male MC, the female route was just an added extra.

Spoiler

And this eliminates any chance of any creepy Ken S-links taking place.

 

[jman2050]

The characters in Madoka are all pretty distinctive.

Madoka - pink

Mami - yellow

Homura - black/purple

Kyouko - red

Sakura - blue

Mugi - green

Go Go Madoka Magica

dooo dooo dooo dooo dooo dooo

 

[madp]

All of this discussion about Madoka made me wonder this: would it still be GAF Anime of the Year 2011 if only the votes of AnimeGAF participants were counted? This probably sounds elitist as all hell, but that isn't the intent--this is simply an exercise to see how differently AnimeGAF's opinions differ from non-AnimeGAF AotY participants. The split among voters was about 50/50. If I've ever seen you post in the thread, I included your vote.

So, the (mostly accurate) results of the 2011 AnimeGAF AotY:

Spoiler

1. Mawaru Penguindrum - 243
2. Madoka Magica - 242
3. Usagi Drop - 222
4. Steins;Gate - 185
5. Hourou Musuko - 163
6. Fate/Zero S1 - 146
7. Hanasaku Iroha - 123
8. The Idolm@ster - 92
9. Working'!! - 87
10. Redline 85

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

 

[cajunator]

Being Meguca is suffering...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MPwF6YTLLuc

 

[Instro]

The characters in Madoka are all pretty distinctive.

Madoka - pink

Mami - yellow

Homura - black/purple

Kyouko - red

Sakura - blue

Mugi - green

Mugi will become white in the movies.

 

[Geneijin]

Mitsuru > Aigis.

Spoiler

Female main character > *

That's not how a tier list works.

 

[survivor]

All of this discussion about Madoka made me wonder this: would it still be GAF Anime of the Year 2011 if only the votes of AnimeGAF participants were counted? This probably sounds elitist as all hell, but that isn't the intent--this is simply an exercise to see how differently AnimeGAF's opinions differ from non-AnimeGAF AotY participants. The split among voters was about 50/50. If I've ever seen you post in the thread, I included your vote.

So, the (mostly accurate) results of the 2011 AnimeGAF AotY:

Spoiler

1. Mawaru Penguindrum - 243
2. Madoka Magica - 242
3. Usagi Drop - 222
4. Steins;Gate - 185
5. Hourou Musuko - 163
6. Fate/Zero S1 - 146
7. Hanasaku Iroha - 123
8. The Idolm@ster - 92
9. Working'!! - 87
10. Redline 85

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

Usagi Drop isn't #1, AnimeGAF fails like rest of GAF

 

[Soma]

Come on, that was never going to happen. The story is built around the Male MC, the female route was just an added extra.

Spoiler

And this eliminates any chance of any creepy Ken S-links taking place.

It'd be kinda cool if the movie will focus on the end on the game.

something like (The Answer spoilers)

Spoiler

Elizabeth going after the MC and brings him back


then he fights alongside Akihiko, Aigis, Elizabeth and Mitsuru in P4 Arena

 

[Dresden]

Usagi Drop isn't #1, AnimeGAF fails like rest of GAF

fail

real men voted for wandering son as #1

 

[darkside31337]

All of this discussion about Madoka made me wonder this: would it still be GAF Anime of the Year 2011 if only the votes of AnimeGAF participants were counted? This probably sounds elitist as all hell, but that isn't the intent--this is simply an exercise to see how differently AnimeGAF's opinions differ from non-AnimeGAF AotY participants. The split among voters was about 50/50. If I've ever seen you post in the thread, I included your vote.

So, the (mostly accurate) results of the 2011 AnimeGAF AotY:

Spoiler

1. Mawaru Penguindrum - 243
2. Madoka Magica - 242
3. Usagi Drop - 222
4. Steins;Gate - 185
5. Hourou Musuko - 163
6. Fate/Zero S1 - 146
7. Hanasaku Iroha - 123
8. The Idolm@ster - 92
9. Working'!! - 87
10. Redline 85

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

Thank goodness the votes are open for all of GAF.

 

[Kazzy]

It'd be kinda cool if the movie will focus on the end on the game.

something like (The Answer spoilers)

Spoiler

Elizabeth going after the MC and brings him back


then he fights alongside Akihiko, Aigis, Elizabeth and Mitsuru in P4 Arena

Spoiler

I hope they incorporate the answer (even if people hate it) because the battle for everyone's soul's would be fantastic to watch.

 

[Dedication Through Light]

All of this discussion about Madoka made me wonder this: would it still be GAF Anime of the Year 2011 if only the votes of AnimeGAF participants were counted? This probably sounds elitist as all hell, but that isn't the intent--this is simply an exercise to see how differently AnimeGAF's opinions differ from non-AnimeGAF AotY participants. The split among voters was about 50/50. If I've ever seen you post in the thread, I included your vote.

So, the (mostly accurate) results of the 2011 AnimeGAF AotY:

Wow, even with that none of the ones I picked made it. AnimeGAF is missing on some good anime.

 

[Hitokage]

All of this discussion about Madoka made me wonder this: would it still be GAF Anime of the Year 2011 if only the votes of AnimeGAF participants were counted? This probably sounds elitist as all hell, but that isn't the intent--this is simply an exercise to see how differently AnimeGAF's opinions differ from non-AnimeGAF AotY participants. The split among voters was about 50/50. If I've ever seen you post in the thread, I included your vote.

So, the (mostly accurate) results of the 2011 AnimeGAF AotY:

Spoiler

1. Mawaru Penguindrum - 243
2. Madoka Magica - 242
3. Usagi Drop - 222
4. Steins;Gate - 185
5. Hourou Musuko - 163
6. Fate/Zero S1 - 146
7. Hanasaku Iroha - 123
8. The Idolm@ster - 92
9. Working'!! - 87
10. Redline 85

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

I didn't even vote!

 

[Envelope]

I didn't vote either, so it's clearly invalid.

 

[DiGiKerot]

In other news, A Letter To Momo is really very good indeed and I looked forward to it being shown in the States so more of you can see it.

Hand-drawn cars and scooters - you folks are going to FLIP YOUR LIDS when you finally get to see it!

 

[PdotMichael]

So, the (mostly accurate) results of the 2011 AnimeGAF AotY:

Spoiler

1. Mawaru Penguindrum - 243
2. Madoka Magica - 242
3. Usagi Drop - 222
4. Steins;Gate - 185
5. Hourou Musuko - 163
6. Fate/Zero S1 - 146
7. Hanasaku Iroha - 123
8. The Idolm@ster - 92
9. Working'!! - 87
10. Redline 85

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

no Denpa Onna, the list is invalid

 

[Kazzy]

I didn't vote either, so it's clearly invalid.

Stamps of Approval = Ratings!

 

[Mature]

MGX - 10

Spoiler

NOOOOO!!! Urabe better panty scissors the hell out of this woman.

 

[jman2050]

All of this discussion about Madoka made me wonder this: would it still be GAF Anime of the Year 2011 if only the votes of AnimeGAF participants were counted? This probably sounds elitist as all hell, but that isn't the intent--this is simply an exercise to see how differently AnimeGAF's opinions differ from non-AnimeGAF AotY participants. The split among voters was about 50/50. If I've ever seen you post in the thread, I included your vote.

So, the (mostly accurate) results of the 2011 AnimeGAF AotY:

Spoiler

1. Mawaru Penguindrum - 243
2. Madoka Magica - 242
3. Usagi Drop - 222
4. Steins;Gate - 185
5. Hourou Musuko - 163
6. Fate/Zero S1 - 146
7. Hanasaku Iroha - 123
8. The Idolm@ster - 92
9. Working'!! - 87
10. Redline 85

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

Doesn't look terribly different from the actual results, at least if memory serves.

 

[Go_Ly_Dow]

tsuritama 9

loved every second of it.

never change tsuritama, never change!

 

[Hitokage]

Doesn't look terribly different from the actual results, at least if memory serves.

A certain show is now on top.

 

[Envelope]

A certain show is now on top.

 

[A Black Falcon]

I didn't even vote!

Nor did I.

 

[dimb]

Spoiler

8. The Idolm@ster - 92
9. Working'!! - 87
10. Redline 85

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

One day you guys will understand Im@s. Chihayafuru doesn't even deserve a spot.

 

[Envelope]

One day you guys will understand. Chihayafuru doesn't even deserve a spot.

 

[survivor]

One day you guys will understand Im@s. Chihayafuru doesn't even deserve a spot.

Neither show deserve a spot

 

[BGBW]

And a lot of the votes for Idolm@ster were troll 10 votes, so the REAL #10 spot is Chihayafuru at 81 votes.

Also many decided to vote for Chihayafuru this year.

 

[dimb]

Also many decided to vote for Chihayafuru this year.

I might have. Probably not after the episodes from this year though.

 

[cajunator]

One day you guys will understand Im@s. Chihayafuru doesn't even deserve a spot.

*adds to the list

 

[jman2050]

A certain show is now on top.

1-4 were all pretty close in the normal vote too so it's all splitting hairs in the end!

 

[Hitokage]

1-4 were all pretty close in the normal vote too so it's all splitting hairs in the end!

No, I specifically remember otherwise because I had made the determination that even if I HAD voted that I couldn't have changed the results.

 

[Instro]

A certain show is now on top.

DESTINYYYY!

 

[PdotMichael]

Penguindrum was a fall anime, so the show is a little overrated.