Can't we all just unite around the fact that Anohana is out of the top ten?
your favorite show doesn't deserve a spot!
YAEY!
your favorite show doesn't deserve a spot!
YAEY!
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Spring Anime 2012 III | AITAKATTA YES!
- Thread starter hosannainexcelsis
- Start date
- Status
Ultimadrago
Member
I don't know what fall has to do with it, but I don't think the show is going to age well outside of a few select episodes. The show has a lot of plotting issues that sour me on it the more I think about them. Not that it's a bad show, but they make it hard to call it a great one.
darkside31337
Tomodachi wa Mahou
Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae wo Bokutachi wa Mada Shiranai - 8.74
MAL don't lie. Only AnimeGAF thinks negatively of the show, something I'm not surprised by.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Ano hana was a nice ride even if just a bit drawn out, though it is at least something worth buying. Not an anime Id put on a top list.
You got your wish cause Ano Hana is out of the top 10
Where is the avatar from? It's pretty cool
darkside31337
Tomodachi wa Mahou
Not sure what your point is. It's a really fine top 30, I only disagree with a handful.
Ginga e Kickoff
All caught up now. Tournament time, hopefully they use this to flesh out the so forgettable characters who take up half the team.
I can't tell if I like or hate the triplets, they're kind of annoying due to their selfishness but their arrogance and skill is refreshing since they're on the main team and not one of the rival teams.
All caught up now. Tournament time, hopefully they use this to flesh out the so forgettable characters who take up half the team.
I can't tell if I like or hate the triplets, they're kind of annoying due to their selfishness but their arrogance and skill is refreshing since they're on the main team and not one of the rival teams.
So when AnimeGAF disagrees with a MAL rating it's just AnimeGAF being AnimeGAF, but when you do you have a valid reason for doing so?
Go_Ly_Dow
Member
was more of a 'fyi' post!
There are some good stuff there. I definitely disagree with their #1 and I also think there is a lot of recent anime on the list. Then again. if I made a top 10 list most of it would be 2000+ so I shouldn't be the one complaining.
Thanks. I should get around watching that movie eventually.
watch Perfect blue and Millennium Actress.
Yeah Millennium Actress is on the watch list too.
I believe it's like 20-25% or 3 episodes. I remember reading something like that
Chet Rippo
Member
What a shitty list.
MY RITORU PONI
YUUJOU WA MAHOU
Episode 1
I never knew Stephenie Meyer wrote MLP
Twilight Sparkle is apparently the heroine of this show. She has no friends, is a bit uppity, and has a boy toy she calls Spike.
She also is somewhat close to the princess, who scoffs at her warnings that the evil moon pony is going to come down from the sky, and instead orders twilight to go make some friends.
There's a genki pony, a super genki pony, a kansai-ben equivalent pony, an oujo-sama pony, a shy-moe pony... I think that's all of them. I guess Twilight gets to be the tsundere.
Anyway, the princess goes missing, the evil sky pony descends, and the episode ends.
Thus begins my trek through 2 seasons of MY LITTLE PONY: MAGIC IS FRIENDSHIP.
Why, you ask?
YUUJOU WA MAHOU
Episode 1
I never knew Stephenie Meyer wrote MLP
Twilight Sparkle is apparently the heroine of this show. She has no friends, is a bit uppity, and has a boy toy she calls Spike.
She also is somewhat close to the princess, who scoffs at her warnings that the evil moon pony is going to come down from the sky, and instead orders twilight to go make some friends.
There's a genki pony, a super genki pony, a kansai-ben equivalent pony, an oujo-sama pony, a shy-moe pony... I think that's all of them. I guess Twilight gets to be the tsundere.
Anyway, the princess goes missing, the evil sky pony descends, and the episode ends.
Thus begins my trek through 2 seasons of MY LITTLE PONY: MAGIC IS FRIENDSHIP.
Why, you ask?
Ultimadrago
Member
More off-the-wall Envelope impressions!?
Chet Rippo
Member
I watched 2 episodes of MLP, that was enough for me.
Femmeworth
Banned
It's not lying if they have shitty taste.
Were they the first 2 episodes?
I think that it's generally a good rule because it acknowledges that for most anime, it's impossible to make an informed judgment on the quality of a series after a single episode. It discourages kneejerk reactions from people who wish for their vote to count (though there will always be attention-whoring MAL reviewers who write reviews for shows after a single episode just to be the first reviewer), but it certainly doesn't compensate for the propensity of MAL members to use the four-point scale and certainly can't counteract bad taste (man, I sound like a snob.)
Dragoon En Regalia
Member
Ashita no Joe is comprised of two seasons, both reaching to and/or past 50 episodes, separated by a whole decade of advancement in the anime industry between 1970 and 1980. I think that's still the king of monumental-scale anime planning. One of the top examples, anyway.
Reknoc, unless episode 3 introduces a horde of big breasted ponies, Chet will never like it.
If they were the first 2, the formula changes (for the better) from then on.
It's definitely worth the time.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Gundam Age 35
EXA-DB plot is a bit more compelling than the present battle at hand, if it can involve Liel more, Captain Ashe, then it would be good. Dont know what Kio is even thinking anymore his skills are so low in comparison to the other mains, even against Asemu. Bulky modifications for the Age-3..Age 3 Orbital arent good at all. Dont understand how bulkier form increases mobility. Decent episode.
Oh on the plot itself
EXA-DB plot is a bit more compelling than the present battle at hand, if it can involve Liel more, Captain Ashe, then it would be good. Dont know what Kio is even thinking anymore his skills are so low in comparison to the other mains, even against Asemu. Bulky modifications for the Age-3..Age 3 Orbital arent good at all. Dont understand how bulkier form increases mobility. Decent episode.
Oh on the plot itself
would be interesting if Gundam was ever actually captured and they had to mount a rescue for Kio
Well I never watched past episode 2, so for all I know it could or could not have big breasted ponies.
Femmeworth
Banned
It's not snobbery if you are stating the truth.
The show doesn't, but the internet certainly does.
People watch what they like, and are predisposed to rate favorably the things they like, so the scores are naturally going to get bumped up. /shrug
That three-episode rule would also discard a lot of scores for shows that people watched a single episode of before abandoning. It's like any other aggregation of popular taste.
That three-episode rule would also discard a lot of scores for shows that people watched a single episode of before abandoning. It's like any other aggregation of popular taste.
Theonik
Member
There is a slight genre shift from EP 3 onwards so 1-2 aren't the most representative episodes of the show.
I'm talking about the opposite, comrade cajunator.
Ultimadrago
Member
And here I thought it was possible to be a truthful snob.
Oh sweet, does it turn into a battle shounen?
I get no gratification from passing judgment on others, even when I disagree strongly with them. Playing the "bad taste" card is ultimately just name-calling so it's best used sparingly if at all.
It just so happens that the temptation to be petty is strong when it comes to MAL sometimes.
Well now I know what I want from season 3.
firehawk12
Subete no aware
That's the whole point of AnimeGAF though.
(Which is why there's a K-On thread, I assume.
)
Ultimadrago
Member
Is this where people start posting pony power rankings?
Chet Rippo
Member
It's a nicely animated show, but that's about all I can say. I'll just let my brother watch it instead, he seems to like it.
well I have had osme series wherE I didn't like the first episode but warmed up to it too.
- Status