What other game had a thread trying to hype it up through its steam reviews? This was yet another game hype thread but it kind of backfired this time. Go search and you'll see there are only a few games getting steam review coverage hype threads, the only other ones I can remember were Hifi Rush and BG3. Most of the time games that are actually very positively reviewed on steam don't get a thread at all, I'm willing to bet some positively reviewed steam games would probably even get shitted on. It just so happens that this overhype thread for Starfield went wrong and reviews weren't extremely positive, add the fact that it's an exclusive and you get a lot of back and forth with excessive damage control on one side and schadenfreude on the other.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Starfield has 'Mixed' reviews on Steam (Up: 'Recent' reviews are Mostly Negative)
M1chl
Currently Gif and Meme Champion
Well, its not like I don't agree, tho:I would bit you'd have more fun here than playing the game itself.
It is more of a, the second part which botheres me, not that there is some tracking of review from the people. I actually find that idea good.
Heisenberg007
Gold Journalism
I love how his attempts to building a hateful narrative backfire, and everybody just starts pointing out to him the flaws of the game -- the very things he wanted to divert attention from lol.The discourse surrounding this game has been fascinating to witness on Steam. There are some people blaming the mythical "Sony pony" for this games' demise on the platform.
Starfield :: Steam Community
steamcommunity.com
Never seen anything like it before.
thicc_girls_are_teh_best
Member
Trying to butter the other side of the bread after that 7/10 Starfield score
I love how his attempts to building a hateful narrative backfire, and everybody just starts pointing out to him the flaws of the game -- the very things he wanted to divert attention from lol.
Going by the performance of some of Sony's recent PC ports, you'd think there aren't nearly enough ponies in the Steam field capable of dragging the game's score down
It's deflection, pure and simple. Can't accept that a first-party platform exclusive isn't getting resounding accolades following massive hype? Just pin it on fanboys of the opposition.
XboxERA already signaled the go-ahead for this in a way by insisting reviewers were going to "unfairly" judge the game due to bias. And we all know what type of biases they were suggesting, if you've ever watched how some of the people at XboxERA react towards PlayStation stuff (like Nick's ridiculous rant against PlayStation when Starfield and RedFall were initially delayed).
Hmmm....nah. Keep in mind you only need to pay a fraction of the price for the game, to play it in Game Pass. You can get a 14-day trail for like $6 in places, that's practically free.
That's how I'm gonna try it out, I'll just have to do so over a couple days this week instead of the weekend like I originally planned.
Last edited:
Red5
Member
Reaching new concurrent player peak on Steam.
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
Great game and looks stellar on a great HDR displayNot to shit the thread up, but on the theme of Xbox and GOTG contenders:
I’m about to start Ori and the Will of the Wisps on my Switch OLED. A game nobody can deny is worth playing.
thicc_girls_are_teh_best
Member
Still curious if it can hit 370K. I took the premier day's peak CCU and gave it a 1.5x multiplier. Which I think is more than fair.
As comparison, BG3 had a 1.8x multiplier from its official day of launch to the day it saw its peak CCU on Steam. But that game had universal praise and stronger WOM than Starfield has been seeing.
550K - 650K. There is probably an influx of new Game Pass subs for the month just to play the game, but that's at most $9.99 or $10.99 (no MP in this game). Some will get it for less.
A lot of those folks would not spend $70 outright to buy the game in its launch month.
Last edited:
poppabk
Cheeks Spread for Digital Only Future
I think you missed the point. I am pretty sure that this thread was in response to predictions in other threads that the game would get massacred in steam reviews. Most games don't get a steam review thread because most games don't have people predicting steam reviews.
That could be why this thread exists, I can't say I've seen these predictions of a massacre for this to be a response though. It's not like we haven't seen steam review threads just existing without predictions though, they even mention starfield in it predicting the exact opposite:
Baldur’s Gate 3 launches with very positive reviews (more than 75,000 reviews) atm on Steam PC
Rachet & Clank Rift Apart and now Baldur’s Gate 3 launches with very positive reviews on Steam (Overwhelming Positive recent reviews). Hopefully Starfield too at the end of this month. Safe to say this is a very successful PC launch
Last edited:
Thyuda
Member
that's insane, that means around 75% of all the people currently playing already played in EA. People are either on Game Pass or just not giving much of a damn for Starfield on Steam.
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
It keeps drawing me back in and I am enjoying myself
feynoob
Banned
It's mostly gamepass. The game cost 70$ on steam. It's no brainier that people will choose the gamepass pc version.
I had more fun downloading the preload version than actually playing this sad clunky unoptimised Bethesda garbage.
Steam review scores never lie, and quality always reflects for CCU.
After all the hype I think 350k CCU even after considering game pass players is kind of low
Steam players, in general, are the most informed gamers. we are not idiots.
Fuck this cocky developer. Your game is not done being optimized and my PC is just fine for it.
Kudos for the Digital foundry video analysis. Be ashamed of your earlier statement Bethesda.
Steam review scores never lie, and quality always reflects for CCU.
After all the hype I think 350k CCU even after considering game pass players is kind of low
Steam players, in general, are the most informed gamers. we are not idiots.
Fuck this cocky developer. Your game is not done being optimized and my PC is just fine for it.
Kudos for the Digital foundry video analysis. Be ashamed of your earlier statement Bethesda.
feynoob
Banned
It's Bethesda game. No matter how bad it is, you see yourself playing the game.
Here is a negative review about it.
demigod
Member
The discourse surrounding this game has been fascinating to witness on Steam. There are some people blaming the mythical "Sony pony" for this games' demise on the platform.
Starfield :: Steam Community
Never seen anything like it before.
“The last game to get this level of hate was Cyberpunk 2077 which also wasn't playable on a specific console.”I love how his attempts to building a hateful narrative backfire, and everybody just starts pointing out to him the flaws of the game -- the very things he wanted to divert attention from lol.
What a clown.
Thyuda
Member
I disagree. Bethesda games are huge and take a lot of time, plus they wanna be replayed, even after several months of pause.
Gamepass is 15$, so 4.6 months of active gamepass would buy you the game. For me personally the choice is simple, I'd have to buy the game. Even if I played for 2 months (30$) and wanted to continue in my third, I'd already would experience regret that I didn't just outright buy it.
Gamepass is great if you have a lot of time and want to play a lot of different games at once, but for huge, expansive RPGs... Not for me.
Topher
Identifies as young
thicc_girls_are_teh_best
Member
It's dropping again. 327K now. Didn't think they'd reach peak until later in the evening.
Just realized NFL season started (really) today. That might have some impact on CCU as well. Depends on the overlap of Starfield players and football fans.
Potentially. I do think since CCU has stayed somewhat consistent since launch, then there's a good chunk of CCU at any given time who are the same people over and over. But a larger chunk of the CCU would be new people, either those who started later and then stick around or just tried it out and dropped it quickly after.
Due to those reasons CCU doesn't actually give a completely stable view of potential sales. The correlation between CCU and sales isn't particularly strong unless there's more granularity (% time per day per user, for example). But at least Steam offers some transparency on its CCU and players; Microsoft does the absolute bare minimum and even then, it's quite lame.
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
It's not often a game of the generation is dropped upon us.
feynoob
Banned
Gamepass pc is very cheap and you aren't only getting starfield.
While Bethesda games are large, it makes sense to use the service to test the game before fully purchasing it.
For me, it will be gamepass pc and the 5 day early launch which impacted the audience perception.
We will see whether it will go higher in 2 weeks or lower.
Sleepwalker
Member
Went back and looked for the lols since I see people pretending there wasnt a hype campaign
www.neogaf.com
www.neogaf.com
www.neogaf.com
www.neogaf.com
www.neogaf.com
www.neogaf.com
There's more but those have actual tidbits of news or real announcements, these are just pure hype threads from before the game released, some of the OPs are now banned, oops.
Notice that this is in no way indicative of the quality of the game, my wife is enjoying it a lot and ill jump in sometime next week but let's not try to rewrite history.
The hype around Starfield is massive, and growing.
The last game I can remember that had this type of hype leading up to its release was Red Dead Redemption 2. It's trending on twitter every day. Forums and social media are all about Starfield, and MS hasn't advertised jack shit for it. I haven't really been a Bethesda guy, but I am a space...
Is Starfield the most important game in Xbox's history since the original Halo?
While the Series X has been doing well, there is still an outcry for AAA exclusives. After two years of meager offerings for a lack of a better word, Starfield is poised to deliver. I can't think of a more important game in the history of the Xbox brand besides the original Halo that supposedly...
What's the last game that was anticipated as much as Starfield?
It's been crazy. Everywhere I look on the gaming/tech/social media related internet, it seems like the conversation is about Starfield. It's been a few years since I've seen this type of hype and buildup towards a game's release. Maybe Cyberpunk 2077 a few years ago? But even that I don't...
What kind of character will you create in Starfield?
I'm thinking of doin a Good guy Riker playthrough, who doesn't take shit from anyone. But in such a playthrough, stealing would be prohibited.. Maybe I'll design my character after Mal from Firefly He could steal, be a robin hood kind of character who is still a good guy. Or maybe I'll...
What are you going to call your ship in Starfield?
I'm naming my ships after ships: The Satokasu The Sonally The Linaria The Talrrus The Taimatora
Starfield | What aspect of Starfield excites you the most?
The game clearly is doing a lot from piracy, base building and taming alien creatures. I think what excites me the most is the ability to modify your spaceship. I’m not normally that into modding my rides in other games, but there’s something so cool about how this game seems to handle it. I...
There's more but those have actual tidbits of news or real announcements, these are just pure hype threads from before the game released, some of the OPs are now banned, oops.
Notice that this is in no way indicative of the quality of the game, my wife is enjoying it a lot and ill jump in sometime next week but let's not try to rewrite history.
Last edited:
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
I don't think its a bad game at all, quite the contrary
I don't play games I consider bad
feynoob
Banned
GHG
the guy is lunatic. His takes are soo stupid as hell.
The Last of Us Part II Plagiarized Earlier Game :: The Last of Us™ Part I General Discussions
05/14/2019: Plague Tale Innocence Released 06/20/2020: The Last of Us Part II Released I played TLOU part II first. I played Plague Tale Innocence afterwards and I'm like TLOU part II ripped quite a lot of stuff from Plague Tale Innocence that's it's unbelievable.
Nice try Sony :: The Last of Us™ Part I General Discussions
Hmmm discount just before Starfield Early Access, sorry sony, everyone is going to play Starfield instead
Starfield :: Steam Community
killatopak
Gold Member
CDPR fixing bugs later? True. Proven by Witcher and Cyberpunk.
Bethesda? My guy, I have a laundry list of 2011 release bugs on my copy of Skyrim 10 year anniversary edition
If there's any semblance of fixes, the credit goes to modders not Bethesda.
feynoob
Banned
The issue of the game is minor and not that serious like people make it out to be.
It's just that this gen, people are too picky.
However, certain design choices are baffling and makes no sense in this age.
thicc_girls_are_teh_best
Member
Why would Starfield Steam CCU shoot up two weeks from now? Is there anything in particular? From my understanding most games see their peak CCU on the first weekend after they officially release.
If anything the 5 day early access helped add to the total player count MS & Bethesda reported. MS obfuscates pretty much all Game Pass player data for things like CCU, outside of when they want to do PR statements. Even there, they don't specify Game Pass in particular, it's always lumped in with something else (the 1+ million CCU record mentioned for example was PC Game Pass, Xbox Game Pass, Xbox game purchasers, and Steam buyers).
It's probably fair to say though that across all platforms Starfield's managed 1+ million CCU each day since official launch, as it seems Game Pass & console could be a 3.5x multiplier over the Steam numbers in a best-case and probable sense. So today for example, they might've hit a 1.157 million CCU across all platforms going off the Steam peak earlier today and using that multiplier.
Last edited:
feynoob
Banned
Mainly due to mods. 2nd is that it's Bethesda game. Those gamepass users will switch to steam soon in the future.
As for CCU, it doesn't show you the overall players. Just how many people played at the same time.
Considering there is 24 hour and time zone difference, it's hard to estimate those players from CCu.
MS have the data and we have to go by it.
Kilau
Member
I’m enjoying it also, I think it’s good just very frustrating because it could have been so much more. I also went in with very low expectations.
I do sometimes
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
I don't play them for long I should have said as I have purchased bad games and thanks to trying tons of games via Gamepass I will admit I have been known to download some stinkersI do sometimes
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
feynoob
Banned
I played redfall and I don't know why I did.I do sometimes
Maybe bevause it's fun to play bad games sometimes.
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
thicc_girls_are_teh_best
Member
There's no way substantial mods will show up for Starfield in just two weeks; if we're talking the type that would substantially jump the CCU, those will probably take a couple of months or longer. Those types of mods are quality and that takes time.
WRT overall players yes MS have the data; the problem is they obfuscate it significantly. So effectively, it makes their claims worthless, at least to me, since I don't know what methodology they are using to make certain claims. For example I just found out thanks to others mentioning it, that Microsoft counts a "player" as device-specific, even if the same person is accessing across two or more devices with Play Anywhere.
So someone accessing Starfield from their Series S, then Series X, then PC, then tablet in the span of a day would count as four 'players' towards any metric stating total players. It's not actually four unique users being counted, at least as I've come to understand it.
demigod
Member
Went back and looked for the lols since I see people pretending there wasnt a hype campaign
The hype around Starfield is massive, and growing.
The last game I can remember that had this type of hype leading up to its release was Red Dead Redemption 2. It's trending on twitter every day. Forums and social media are all about Starfield, and MS hasn't advertised jack shit for it. I haven't really been a Bethesda guy, but I am a space...
Is Starfield the most important game in Xbox's history since the original Halo?
While the Series X has been doing well, there is still an outcry for AAA exclusives. After two years of meager offerings for a lack of a better word, Starfield is poised to deliver. I can't think of a more important game in the history of the Xbox brand besides the original Halo that supposedly...
What's the last game that was anticipated as much as Starfield?
It's been crazy. Everywhere I look on the gaming/tech/social media related internet, it seems like the conversation is about Starfield. It's been a few years since I've seen this type of hype and buildup towards a game's release. Maybe Cyberpunk 2077 a few years ago? But even that I don't...
What kind of character will you create in Starfield?
I'm thinking of doin a Good guy Riker playthrough, who doesn't take shit from anyone. But in such a playthrough, stealing would be prohibited.. Maybe I'll design my character after Mal from Firefly He could steal, be a robin hood kind of character who is still a good guy. Or maybe I'll...
What are you going to call your ship in Starfield?
I'm naming my ships after ships: The Satokasu The Sonally The Linaria The Talrrus The Taimatora
Starfield | What aspect of Starfield excites you the most?
The game clearly is doing a lot from piracy, base building and taming alien creatures. I think what excites me the most is the ability to modify your spaceship. I’m not normally that into modding my rides in other games, but there’s something so cool about how this game seems to handle it. I...
There's more but those have actual tidbits of news or real announcements, these are just pure hype threads from before the game released, some of the OPs are now banned, oops.
Notice that this is in no way indicative of the quality of the game, my wife is enjoying it a lot and ill jump in sometime next week but let's not try to rewrite history.
DenchDeckard
wasn’t hyped for the game even though he said he was and even made a thread about naming his spaceship. Nope, no hype whatsoever, just fake news.azertydu91
Hard to Kill
Why ?I think that's an area where we as gamers need to progress, there's no shame to enjoy a bad game.I have played tons of bad games and enjoyed some (even moreso with friends but to be fair even a brazillian wax is fun with friends).I wish that one day the gaming community matures enough to be able to have what's in french is called "nanards" (movies so bad that they are good.
I even think that they are more telling about your tastes than good games, they are too easy to like but liking a bad game needs a real opinion.
I wanted to make a thread about it but sadly I already know the outcome: warrior trying to subtly pissing on another comunity.
But yeah my advice play some bad games with friends (a bit of booze, pizzas) and it can lead to a great night.
Edit:We tried a retro night with some friend and tried some old batman games on ps1 ...Some were amazingly bad but we had a great night.I also brought my deck while I was in chemo a few weeks ago and believe the retro bad games had a real success.
Last edited:
BlueLyria
Member
It feels like the year just flew by and I totally forgot about Ori, I thought it was 2022 tbh
Freeman76
Member
People will still be enjoying this in 5 years time. These plebs review bombing it will move onto the next thing to project their hate onto soon enough, and the Starfield community will be left to enjoy this masterpiece
feynoob
Banned
Mods at Starfield Nexus - Mods and community
Browse 9,462 mods for Starfield at Nexus Mods
www.nexusmods.com
big ones
StarUI Inventory
StarUI Inventory improves all inventory screens for use on a PC. Compact display style. More details in sortable columns. Item tag icons. Category as left sidebar. Many quality of life features!
www.nexusmods.com
that is your tinfoil hat.
that is not how ccu works. it just a log for players playing at the same time.
here is a math if you want to find player count yourself.
24 hour a day / divide by the time played at that day, and you can find how many people played that day.
12m players (2 hour play time a day)
6m players (4 hours playtime)
4m players (6 hour playtime).
that is 1m ccu player count for 24 hour.
from sep1/6 to sep 10 is 240h/120.
if we convert it to gamer time, that is 20h/10h (2hour a day) to 60h/30h (6 hour a day).
that is a basic math for finding the player count if you dont trust MS.
CCU gets lower from time to time, so pay attention to that. best method would be average ccu.
Also keep in mind for players thar only play 10 hour or lower and never touch the game after that.
Grildon Tundy
Gold Member
Gamers lash out at tentpole games because they fail to cure their depression.
Hype gives them a reason to live. Product arrives. Falls short of expectations. Gamers must face their reality once again.
Hype gives them a reason to live. Product arrives. Falls short of expectations. Gamers must face their reality once again.
Red5
Member
Nexus already has 1000 mods, although only a very few are noteworthy, but 1000 mods in the span of a week means a very active mod scene, can't wait to see what they do.
Ass of Can Whooping
Gold Member
I'm suprised I haven't killed myself yet
Physiocrat
Member
Will Starfield be significantly better in a year or so when multiple patches appear plus quality of life mods?
feynoob
Banned
10000%
mejin
Member
RGB'D
Member
I didn't say it was the best. Diablo was also super polished. As was BG 3. Probably my top 3 performance launches
feynoob
Banned
I didn't know you can cry like that.
Last edited:
Unknown Soldier
Member
I'm really enjoying the daily title updates on this thread TBH
thicc_girls_are_teh_best
Member
Mods at Starfield Nexus - Mods and community
Browse 9,462 mods for Starfield at Nexus Mods
big ones
StarUI Inventory
StarUI Inventory improves all inventory screens for use on a PC. Compact display style. More details in sortable columns. Item tag icons. Category as left sidebar. Many quality of life features!
No not those types of mods; I mean those in terms of content. The sort of mods that basically try transplanting other IP's world into the game by some major degree. Those sort of mods would bring a lot more interest than just those adding DLSS support or better framerate or resolution options.
I've been told multiple times that is how Microsoft measures players: due to Play Anywhere, a user using multiple devices counts as a player on each device they use to access a game. So # unique users * # accessed devices, that's how MS tallies player counts.
It's probably not even exclusive to them; any company doing similar tracking by similar metrics probably uses some version of that if we're talking games. Gives the best means of providing biggest possible numbers.
Is this actually how it works? Because different regions have different time zones, a part of a day in one region might overlap with part of another day in another region somewhere else in the world. So a 'day' would have to be measured as blocks of time, not a specific day. It would probably make better sense to measure it as, say, 12 million players in 24 hours. It might sound like I'm speaking semantics here, but in this case knowing the difference seems pretty important.
Keep in mind, I agree with you this is probably how the CCU is being calculated, but I was actually referring to total player statistics, not CCU. And in that case we can both be correct here; MS probably uses an averaged CCU from over some period across all devices (with rounding) and taking into account the average playtime per player per day (and that over a period of days covering some period). While at the same time, factoring "players" as any time a person, even if it's the same user, accessing the game from multiple devices to play the game. I.e they aren't differentiating between unique user and play instances, neither for CCU or total player count.
Agreed, and that is likely what Microsoft uses in calculations for total player count. Average CCU over a tracking period times number of days over a tracking period times average play time over a tracking period. So if its say 250K average CCU over 6 days with play time average of 4 hours, that's 6 million total players.
But a user can be multiple 'players, while any given 'player' will always only belong to one 'user'.
Okay, yeah, but they would still count towards total player count since they have in fact played the game, regardless how long they stuck with it.
Similar threads
- Locked