• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Breaking: Israel launches Operation Protective Edge against Hamas in Gaza

Status
Not open for further replies.

Buzzati

Banned
You are disgusting.

It is a war. Casualties will happen. I hate it, Palestinians hate it, Israelis hate it. They happen in ever war. We come here to have a discussion about it. If you believe what is going on is wrong, then you are entitled to that opinion, but posting graphic videos of the death of a child is wrong. We don't need to see that.

BsSaWMrCQAEZyWG.jpg


Excuse me, but who do you think you are? The goal here is to show how disgusting the country of Israel is and how indiscriminately they murder people. This is the 23rd child to be murdered. May the image burn in your fucking brain.
 

JordanN

Banned
So just like the IDF are warning palestinians about avoiding those places, hamas is now doing the same. So that means Israel can't complain about civilian casualities right?

What I just said is utter bullshit and everyone knows it, but several posters have made such a claim in this thread. If you don't like people having a different view than yours on the matter then don't enter this thread.

Israel is not keeping their tanks in an airport.

Here's a mosque Hamas stored weapons in during the 2008 Gaza war.
ibnX0A1v0ESF9w.jpg


Again, it's bad enough Hamas litters themselves everywhere in Gaza.
 

P. Fembot

Banned
You're only giving one limited angle of the situation here. A more accurate Mexican analogy would be if the US had occupied Mexico decades ago, was controlling all their infrastructure, supplies, trade etc, and continued an expansion policy where they continuously stole, occupied and settled upon more and more Mexican land each and every year. Then when the Mexicans reacted, America bombed them to hell and back and blamed it on Mexican terrorists for inciting the violence.

I'm not hanging around for long, but the fact is, 'Mexico' is still bombing America in this situation. America would always defend herself.
 

LNBL

Member
Without taking sides and pardoning my ignorance. What's the reason behind the bombings?

Ok, lemme try and explain from my point of view.

3 Israelie teenagers go missing on the 12th of June, this causes Netanyahu (PM) to blame Hamas for this abduction and quickly after that the White House confirms the statement of the PM. However, organizations like Hamas etc always publicly claim attacks or actions, but this time they have denied all involvement with this abduction.

The media has since labeled the Hamas accusations as a fact. What follows is the burning of 16 year old Palestinian boy, while he is still alive, which was supposedly done by several Israeli fanatics.

Edit: Amjad's earlier posted article describes my ideas about the situation as well. http://www.lrb.co.uk/blog/2014/07/0...&hq_e=el&hq_m=3288693&hq_l=13&hq_v=e0a2a63d45
 
TBH this thread dismays me. If Mexico were shooting rockets into America daily, and were sending rockets to LA Airport, I'm sure the tone would be different.

I come to GAF for the gaming forum, pop my head into off-topic, and find hardcore anti-Israel views.

I'm not a huge fan of Israel but they do have a right to defend themselves. Do you want them to just sit there in their bomb shelters and take rockets from Hamas?

And to the people saying that there are no Israeli casualties, that's only because they have bomb shelters and an anti-missile defense system. Hamas are now firing at Ben Gurion Airport and telling the world not to fly in to Israel due to their attacks on the airport.

WTF are Israel meant to do?

The US-Mexico situation would be different, namely Mexico is not under the US control. There are aspects to compare and I'd say US would be given permission from Mexico to stop the rocket attacks per our relationship as neighbors.

That airport hosts a military airbase, so it is not entirely a civilian target. Could be related to planes dropping smartbombs.

"Protective Edge" was launched as a knee-jerk reaction to the kidnapping and slaying of three Israeli youth and the honor killing that followed of a Palestinian teenager. Israel can protect itself with drones, iron domes, and an array of surveillance capabilities. Each rocket launch should be pinpointed and that information used to catch those firing rockets. The degree that this operation has been implemented, and the hint it could continue with an ground-invasion, one must ask: "At what point will Israel be secure?" Gaza has been under blockade for like eight years. Israeli settlements have continued in the midst of attempts to forge a peace deal.
 

danwarb

Member
I'm not hanging around for long, but the fact is, 'Mexico' is still bombing America in this situation. America would always defend herself.

They'd be wrong to conduct themselves in that manner. Acting against themselves in the long run.

Their people = our people. We behave in the same unreasonable ways given the same circumstances.
 

Quotient

Member
BsSaWMrCQAEZyWG.jpg


Excuse me, but who do you think you are? The goal here is to show how disgusting the country of Israel is and how indiscriminately they murder people. This is the 23rd child to be murdered. May the image burn in your fucking brain.

Do you honestly believe that Israel is intentionally targeting children. That they aren't making any attempts to avoid casualties?
 

nib95

Banned
These people look like they're chilling out enjoying the show. Is there a fireworks display?
Yeap. The fireworks being the airstrikes that are being dropped on Palestinians...

Apparently the people in the crowd were cheering each time there was a massive explosion...
 
Do you honestly believe that Israel is intentionally targeting children. That they aren't making any attempts to avoid casualties?
No attempts to avoid considering the population density and the armaments. Limiting civilian casualties is part of the operation but these targeted airstrikes are not perfect.
 

diamount

Banned
Don't the rockets Hamas fire into Israel don't actually cause any damage? Like they might as well be using fireworks, and you got Israel using real bombs and don't care who is in the crossfire.
 
Do you think Israel cares if they kill children through their attacks?
Israel has even called off numerous air strikes because civilians had, at the bequest of Hamas, scrambled onto the rooftops of key buildings being used to store ammunition and organise attacks. And those were adults who knew exactly what they were doing - by no means legitimate targets but hardly innocent bystanders once they became a crucial part of Hamas's military strategy. In a few instances when the rooftops were cleared and the go ahead was given, yet civilians returned despite the warning shots, civilians have been killed and the IDF has expressed regret. Bearing that in mind, of course they want to avoid children's deaths.

Edit: That Hamas asks civilians to become human shields is implicit acknowledgement that Israel cares about civilian casualties.
 

nib95

Banned
I'm not hanging around for long, but the fact is, 'Mexico' is still bombing America in this situation. America would always defend herself.
Let me put it another way. What would you do if your country was under a brutal military occupation for decades, and the country occupying it, continually stole more and more land each and every month, destroyed your homes each and every week, displaced you, your friends relatives etc, and built their own homes on what was previously your land? Would you respond?

What if some of your family responded, and in doing so they were arrested in droves and could face torture, abuse, rape, imprisonment without trial or rights etc as a result. What then?
 

GaimeGuy

Volunteer Deputy Campaign Director, Obama for America '16
Sderrot is a city of like 20k people and has half a dozen rockets fired into it each day from gaza. Has been that way for years

I can't imagine having air raid sirens and explosions being an everyday occurrence in any city and NOT having a group of people cheering on as their military retaliates, proportionally or otherwise. :/
 
You are out of your mind if you think they give a shit at all beyond having the impotent international community whine in their ear for the thousandth time.
An impotent international community is better than one that would wield great power in this modern World. It would unravel or become a monolithic governing body under the control of the "peacemakers."
 

Buzzati

Banned
Israel has even called off numerous air strikes because civilians had, at the bequest of Hamas, scrambled onto the rooftops of key buildings being used to store ammunition and organise attacks. And those were adults who knew exactly what they were doing - by no means legitimate targets but hardly innocent bystanders once they became a crucial part of Hamas's military strategy. In a few instances when the rooftops were cleared and the go ahead was given, yet civilians returned despite the warning shots, civilians have been killed and the IDF has expressed regret. Bearing that in mind, of course they want to avoid children's deaths.

Edit: That Hamas asks civilians to become human shields is implicit acknowledgement that Israel cares about civilian casualties.

I guess Hamas loves Israelis too! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_shield#Israel


And can I have a source for the story on those civilians that went to the rooftops? I'm not disputing you, but I'd like to read it because I'm interested.
 
Are you really going to argue that the unauthorised and banned use of a few human shields by disgusting soldiers in past conflicts is somehow equal to how central human shields are to Hamas's military strategy?

Way to ignore the proof that Israel cares about minimising casualties while Hamas does everything in its power to increase the number of dead children it can parade in from of useful idiots who will place all the blame on Israel.


Edit: Here is a video released by the IDF showing a strike being called off
 

This is what happens when the 'enemy' is dehumanized. The people watching and cheering are shells of human beings.

Yeah, yeah, the other side does it to, and it's just as sick then too, but that doesn't make this any less repulsive.

Most people have a good idea of what Hamas is by this point. And anyone with a functioning brain (which is a rarity I understand) knows all of Palestine does not equal Hamas, but anyone who thinks Israel is some sort of paragon of virtue in this longstanding conflict or that their worst is any different than the worst in Palestine are truly pathetic.
 

Buzzati

Banned
An impotent international community is better than one that would wield great power in this modern World. It would unravel or become a monolithic governing body under the control of the "peacemakers."

Then which great power has taken the place of a would-be monolithic international community? There is already a globalized narrative that enables Israel to do what it does without repercussions.
 

JordanN

Banned
Don't the rockets Hamas fire into Israel don't actually cause any damage? Like they might as well be using fireworks, and you got Israel using real bombs and don't care who is in the crossfire.
Not even close.
ibqWTyHnJZN5xJ.jpg

iRGcCwZBokoKp.jpg


There is also a picture of an Israeli child with his leg blown off, but I'll refrain from posting the gruesome pics.
 

Buzzati

Banned
Are you really going to argue that the unauthorised and banned use of a few human shields by disgusting soldiers in past conflicts is somehow equal to how central human shields are to Hamas's military strategy?

Way to ignore the proof that Israel cares about minimising casualties while Hamas does everything in its power to increase the number of dead children it can parade in from of useful idiots who will place all the blame on Israel.

When has bad PR ever dissuaded Israel, ever?
 
Are you really going to argue that the unauthorised and banned use of a few human shields by disgusting soldiers in past conflicts is somehow equal to how central human shields are to Hamas's military strategy?

Way to ignore the proof that Israel cares about minimising casualties while Hamas does everything in its power to increase the number of dead children it can parade in from of useful idiots who will place all the blame on Israel.


Edit: Here is a video released by the IDF showing a strike being called off

When has bad PR ever dissuaded Israel, ever?
Maybe they try to avoid killing children because they don't want to kill children. Hard to believe that Israelis aren't all bloodthirsty monsters I know.
 

Buzzati

Banned
Maybe they try to avoid killing children because they don't want to kill children. Hard to believe that Israelis aren't all bloodthirsty monsters I know.

It is less about them being bloodthirsty and more about them legitimizing their claim over the land and the people. Why should they take more pains than necessary to do that? What is their incentive?


Not all Israeli's are bloodthirsty monsters, but you have to call a spade a spade at some point. When the parties to the Geneva Convention, numerous UN resolutions, ICJ and other instances have called their habits detestable, what do you have left? The people themselves cannot even protest Israel's terrorism. This is an aberration of democracy. This country is disgraceful.
 

JordanN

Banned
I'm talking the magnitude that the Palestinians are getting.
A rocket is a rocket. They've shot thousands of them at Israel causing lots of property damage, psychological trauma, and death. Calling them "fireworks" is incredibly disrespectful to the victims of the attack (as if they feel no pain from losing a leg).
 
Then which great power has taken the place of a would-be monolithic international community? There is already a globalized narrative that enables Israel to do what it does without repercussions.
Hey, its a crazy idea but if the Palestinian State applied to be annexed by the United States then it would at least force recognition and maybe even initiate a larger conversation about the US role here. Its likely not to go through (arguably a bluff anyway).
 

diamount

Banned
A rocket is a rocket. They've shot thousands of them at Israel causing lots of property damage, psychological trauma, and death. Calling them "fireworks" is incredibly disrespectful to the victims of the attack (as if they feel no pain from losing a leg).

Erm, yes compared to what Israel drops on the Palestinians that is exactly what they are in terms of yield and damage. Not to mention the majority, if not all of them miss their intended target.. if there was any intended target in the first place.
 
It is less about them being bloodthirsty and more about them legitimizing their claim over the land and the people. Why should they take more pains than necessary to do that? What is their incentive?


Not all Israeli's are bloodthirsty monsters, but you have to call a spade a spade at some point. When the parties to the Geneva Convention, numerous UN resolutions, ICJ and other instances have called their habits detestable, what do you have left? The people themselves cannot even protest Israel's terrorism. This is an aberration of democracy. This country is disgraceful.
I don't disagree there are idiots on the Israeli side who would cheer every IDF bomb. I don't disagree that Israel sometimes cracks down on criticism, although it has a good record of allowing peaceful protest in general (at least within its borders...) . But you have made a lot of noise without addressing my evidence that Israel takes measures to reduce casualties while Hamas does everything in its power to increase the number of 'martyrs'.
 

Buzzati

Banned
I don't disagree there are idiots on the Israeli side who would cheer every IDF bomb. I don't disagree that Israel sometimes cracks down on criticism, although it has a good record of allowing you in general. But you have made a lot of noise without addressing my evidence that Israel takes measures to reduce casualties while Hamas does everything in its power to increase the number of 'martyrs'.

Recall that I asked you for the source of your evidence, and you decided not to do that. How can I address your evidence if you don't show it to me?

EDIT: Oh, you linked to the IDF's murder porn youtube page. I am very familiar with this channel. Great gems on here for anyone wanting nothing but videos of aircraft bombings. You'll have to excuse me if I don't take my evidence from the exact people we're trying to find objective information about. Are you for real with this?

Here you go:

http://online.wsj.com/articles/civilian-deaths-shine-light-on-israeli-tactic-1404955844
 

pgtl_10

Member
The US-Mexico situation would be different, namely Mexico is not under the US control. There are aspects to compare and I'd say US would be given permission from Mexico to stop the rocket attacks per our relationship as neighbors.

That airport hosts a military airbase, so it is not entirely a civilian target. Could be related to planes dropping smartbombs.

"Protective Edge" was launched as a knee-jerk reaction to the kidnapping and slaying of three Israeli youth and the honor killing that followed of a Palestinian teenager. Israel can protect itself with drones, iron domes, and an array of surveillance capabilities. Each rocket launch should be pinpointed and that information used to catch those firing rockets. The degree that this operation has been implemented, and the hint it could continue with an ground-invasion, one must ask: "At what point will Israel be secure?" Gaza has been under blockade for like eight years. Israeli settlements have continued in the midst of attempts to forge a peace deal.

What honor killing? Six Israeli Jews were arrested as suspects.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom