• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

FakeGAF Book 4: A Game of Thirst

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't watch ANY LPers tbh, my son does, of the ones he watches PDP is the most watchable. That coupled with the interviews he's done, he seems like a cool dude.
Tell your son to watch Chip & Ironicus then >_>

That series isn't exactly typical for them as normally they do post commentary and have a large amount of editing, but fuck me it's funny

yeah, most of the better ones tend to come from something awful. I like protonjon for his informational tone in his lets plays (if they ever get finished...)
I think it's probably because there's some element of quality control, in that if you make something low effort and shitty you will be told in no uncertain terms "This is shit and low effort. Do better."

And yeah, ProtonJon is cool. Though now I'm freaking out because his Kaizo video is rapidly approaching the 10 year marker
 

Jobbs

Banned
How long is this doctor's appointment. You've been there for hours.

Are you at the doctor's house?


Jobbs this isn't an appointment. It's a gridr date.

hah. I'm home. I was just reflecting on the visit and how unusual it was. I guess when you get into more specialized medicine you get stronger personalities.
 

Jobbs

Banned
@jobbs and other emo lovers

theres a debate over the definition of emo in this thread

...Fight!

I don't think of Weezer as emo, but maybe my emodar isn't perfect

List is strange but it gets some stuff right. Sunny Day #1? Yes. Promise ring, jawbreaker, mineral, yes yes yes. Rainer Marie yes. At The Drive In -- Boy I haven't heard them in a long ass time, very good but I Don't remember thinking of them as particularly emo.

Paramore - RIOT? LOL. Cute album cute band but not emo

Coheed is emo? THat's news to me

One Armed Scissor is such a fucking rule ass song
. That second verse is one of the most epic things ever
 

marrec

Banned
The doctor honestly seemed very happy to get my shirt off.

Gay doctors getting heat from straight dudes smgdh

Pinkerton is generally considered one of the more important emo albums. then they completely gave up on that and went full pop-rock

I got into the history of emo after falling hard into Brand New love and dug through all that but never came across Pinkerton in my musical archeology but it makes sense now that I think about it.
 

Halcyon

Member
I spent all this time looking for a fitting gif and didn't find one.

No gif needed

image.php



I actually like Paramore (haven't heard whatever they're doing most recently, but I've heard the first few albums) despite not being a teenage girl. Fun music with some pretty solid guitar riffs and the drummer was really good. Just not emo at all. That's a stretch.

I saw them live in Pittsburgh before a John Mayer concert 6? years ago or some such.
 

Jobbs

Banned
I actually like Paramore (haven't heard whatever they're doing most recently, but I've heard the first few albums) despite not being a teenage girl. Fun music with some pretty solid guitar riffs and the drummer was really good. Just not emo at all. That's a stretch.

Incidentally I also like The Veronicas. Saw them live in philly a few years ago and was among the only grown men there who wasn't someone's father
 

Misha

Banned
I got into the history of emo after falling hard into Brand New love and dug through all that but never came across Pinkerton in my musical archeology but it makes sense now that I think about it.
it got poor reviews and the band completely ignored it for years so thats not surprising. its one of those albums that people who end up making music in a couple years all listen to

I actually like Paramore (haven't heard whatever they're doing most recently, but I've heard the first few albums) despite not being a teenage girl. Fun music with some pretty solid guitar riffs and the drummer was really good. Just not emo at all. That's a stretch.

Incidentally I also like The Veronicas

their new stuff is pure pop. its okay but Riot! imo is the best pop punk album.
oh and they got rid of half the band and now its just a hayley williams vessel (more so than it already was)

they didn't mature as well as Fall Out Boy
 

Granadier

Is currently on Stage 1: Denial regarding the service game future
There has to be a mathematical algorithm out there to find the average time it takes for an obscure music group to turn into pop once they get notoriety.
 

Misha

Banned
There has to be a mathematical algorithm out there to find the average time it takes for an obscure music group to turn into pop once they get notoriety.

lets use Alvvays as a case study. they got a ton of attention on blogs and stuff in the summer but most people still don't know them adn they aren't played on top 40 radio

wait into pop? they're already pop. nevermind
 

marrec

Banned
their new stuff is pure pop. its okay but Riot! imo is the best pop punk album.
oh and they got rid of half the band and now its just a hayley williams vessel (more so than it already was)

they didn't mature as well as Fall Out Boy

I had a moment with my son the other day. He's super into Fall Out Boy's new Popier stuff and so I was like "hey son, let's listen to Fall Out Boy's albums from when your pops was a teen" and he fucking hated them, I was devastated.

But only for a second because I quickly remembered that his dislike of older FOB stuff is indicative of their business and cultural acumen, and also I didn't really like FOB stuff that much when I was a kid so *shrug*
 

Misha

Banned
I had a moment with my son the other day. He's super into Fall Out Boy's new Popier stuff and so I was like "hey son, let's listen to Fall Out Boy's albums from when your pops was a teen" and he fucking hated them, I was devastated.

But only for a second because I quickly remembered that his dislike of older FOB stuff is indicative of their business and cultural acumen, and also I didn't really like FOB stuff that much when I was a kid so *shrug*

did you play anything from take this to your grave? that stuff is so different from the rest
 

marrec

Banned
did you play anything from take this to your grave? that stuff is so different from the rest

Yea I eased him into with "Grand Theft Autumn/Where is Your Boy" (the most approachable) but he wasn't having any of it lol

There has to be a mathematical algorithm out there to find the average time it takes for an obscure music group to turn into pop once they get notoriety.

I dunno, you look at artists like Grimes or Tegan and Sara or even the aforementioned Fall Out Boy and you realize that changing sound to fit a narrow chronological range of popular music is what generates one hit wonders if you ask me. The three artists I mentioned above kinda just have been doing their thing for awhile, slowly morphing their styles as they mature and evolve, and suddenly they're making pop music because the people went to them rather than them going to the people.

Especially with Tegan and Sara, they've been making the exact same style of music for like a decade and a buddy of mine told me they sold out because he heard them on popular radio, I was like "did you even listen to their latest shit?" Musical snobs sicken me, is what I'm getting at.
 

Halcyon

Member
what's up fakerz, how is your day? Mine is such that I wish that I had a time machine

I think everyone learned their lesson about time machines from Adam Sandler.



My day has been long and boring. I don't have a ton of energy and I want to skip the gym but i probably won't. Gonna watch either Gotham or the Voice when I get home which will be around 8pm. My days are long.
 
I had a moment with my son the other day. He's super into Fall Out Boy's new Popier stuff and so I was like "hey son, let's listen to Fall Out Boy's albums from when your pops was a teen" and he fucking hated them, I was devastated.

But only for a second because I quickly remembered that his dislike of older FOB stuff is indicative of their business and cultural acumen, and also I didn't really like FOB stuff that much when I was a kid so *shrug*

Only FOB song I remember from my teens is Sugar We're Goin' Down. (I didn't mind it I guess.)
 

Granadier

Is currently on Stage 1: Denial regarding the service game future
Yea I eased him into with "Grand Theft Autumn/Where is Your Boy" (the most approachable) but he wasn't having any of it lol



I dunno, you look at artists like Grimes or Tegan and Sara or even the aforementioned Fall Out Boy and you realize that changing sound to fit a narrow chronological range of popular music is what generates one hit wonders if you ask me. The three artists I mentioned above kinda just have been doing their thing for awhile, slowly morphing their styles as they mature and evolve, and suddenly they're making pop music because the people went to them rather than them going to the people.

Especially with Tegan and Sara, they've been making the exact same style of music for like a decade and a buddy of mine told me they sold out because he heard them on popular radio, I was like "did you even listen to their latest shit?" Musical snobs sicken me, is what I'm getting at.

These aren't musical snobs. More just people that want to like stuff no one else does. Once it gets popular they get angry cause they have to find some other unknown to favorite.
 

Misha

Banned
Yea I eased him into with "Grand Theft Autumn/Where is Your Boy" (the most approachable) but he wasn't having any of it lol


I dunno, you look at artists like Grimes or Tegan and Sara or even the aforementioned Fall Out Boy and you realize that changing sound to fit a narrow chronological range of popular music is what generates one hit wonders if you ask me. The three artists I mentioned above kinda just have been doing their thing for awhile, slowly morphing their styles as they mature and evolve, and suddenly they're making pop music because the people went to them rather than them going to the people.

Especially with Tegan and Sara, they've been making the exact same style of music for like a decade and a buddy of mine told me they sold out because he heard them on popular radio, I was like "did you even listen to their latest shit?" Musical snobs sicken me, is what I'm getting at.

fall out boy is weird. they started from a more narrow genre and made their own sound to be more digestible to the masses. as much as i like take this to your grave, theres a ton of bands that did the same thing. cork tree on they added more of their eccentricities and i think Patrick Stump losing weight and coming out of his shell helped add the mroe arena-y sound to the last two albums
i think uma thurman is the best example of their evolution. you can see old fallout boy in there with even more energy and catchy guitar licks
 

Jobbs

Banned
There's not a musical snob bone in my body. I listen to weird stuff, obscure stuff, and total absolute unabashed pop. I listen to Taylor Swift. I do it all.


This is a bold opinion bro

Anyway I'll give you an example.. As I mentioned before, I played through Alien Isolation then watched PDP play it.. Reason being I wanted to see how he handled the situations presented by the game, how he reacted (how much screaming -- btw, there wasn't much or really any) and what he thought. It was a way to decompress after playing that game for 20 hours.

I've watched a lot of Souls let's play because I always find it interesting comparing experiences and hearing peopels thoughts and deconstructions on a game series we share love for
 

FloatOn

Member
because you don't want to buy said game

because you want to experience something you like through others eyes

because the same reason you watch sports

because the same reason you watch porn




the list goes on.

I would rather play with balls and/or fuck firsthand

much more fun

the alternative is just lazy imo

There's not a musical snob bone in my body. I listen to weird stuff, obscure stuff, and total absolute unabashed pop. I listen to Taylor Swift. I do it all.



This is a bold opinion bro

Anyway I'll give you an example.. As I mentioned before, I played through Alien Isolation then watched PDP play it.. Reason being I wanted to see how he handled the situations presented by the game, how he reacted (how much screaming -- btw, there wasn't much or really any) and what he thought. It was a way to decompress after playing that game for 20 hours.

do you know com truise? you should know com truise

And I get your point insofar as watching something like this as a way to decompress AFTER going through it yourself but to do it in lieu of actually playing the damn thing is dumb.

how about them apples halcyon?
 

marrec

Banned
fall out boy is weird. they started from a more narrow genre and made their own sound to be more digestible to the masses. as much as i like take this to your grave, theres a ton of bands that did the same thing. cork tree on they added more of their eccentricities and i think Patrick Stump losing weight and coming out of his shell helped add the mroe arena-y sound to the last two albums
i think uma thurman is the best example of their evolution. you can see old fallout boy in there with even more energy and catchy guitar licks

The only thing I don't like about modern FOB (from a casual listening point of view) is their lyrics have degenerated quite a bit. Not that they were comparable to lyrical masters like Jesse Lacey but I think they peaked lyrically with From Under the Cork Tree.
 
This just sounds like 90's alternative music to me. But I can see how it could be classified as its own thing.
I think this is just one of those things where if you're into it, you can tell the difference, if not then you have no idea. Which isn't meant as an insult, I would have no idea how to separate out different subgenres of like electronic music, or jazz or whatever.


Because I don't want to play Watch_Dogs when I can watch amusing people play it instead and get waaaay more enjoyment out of it than I would've otherwise

Also games like The Wonderful 101 and Metal Gear Rising that I am terrible at but still want to see how they play out
 

Halcyon

Member
I would rather play with balls and/or fuck firsthand

much more fun

the alternative is just lazy imo



do you know com truise? you should know com truise

And I get your point insofar as watching something like this as a way to decompress AFTER going through it yourself but to do it in lieu of actually playing the damn thing is dumb.

how about them apples halcyon?

There's more than just watching someone play a single player game on youtube. That can be fun though. I get to watch someone who I enjoy listening to play through things like Ghost Song without having to buy it from game dev's I personally hate and who I hear like to have anonymous doctor sex.

Then there's multiplayer games, minecraft, gmod, zombies, reviews, old games, speedruns, hacks, etc etc.

It's the most popular genre on youtube other than music videos.

I'm allergic to apples.


I think this is just one of those things where if you're into it, you can tell the difference, if not then you have no idea. Which isn't meant as an insult, I would have no idea how to separate out different subgenres of like electronic music, or jazz or whatever.

I like indie rock and relaxed music so I'm actually kinda into it. It just feels very 90's to me and I remember everyone making fun of my flat-top haircut and start crying.
 

Misha

Banned
The only thing I don't like about modern FOB (from a casual listening point of view) is their lyrics have degenerated quite a bit. Not that they were comparable to lyrical masters like Jesse Lacey but I think they peaked lyrically with From Under the Cork Tree.
its basically cheesy poetry with a ton of wordplay
see if you can tell them apart from sylvia plath
or bukowski or ginsberg
(personally i think it peaks in infinity on high though)
I would argue that you are not really experiencing them if you are just watching

neither is me playing through them and being awful. its the best i can do
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom