RumblingRosco
Member
I have to ask a stupid question...
when we gain weight, it's nearly impossible to do it in the form of pure, 100% muscle, so there's always some fat coming with it.
when we lose weight, do we lose in a similar way both muscle and fat or does proper diet makes you retain all gained muscle and shed only the fat?
I would say it is much to reduce body fat while retaining muscle than it is to gain muscle without gaining some fat.
So, basically, you are right. You can gain 5 lbs of muscle and 5 lbs of fat in 12 months, but you can probably cut 1 lb of muscle and 5 lbs of fat in 2 months. Amounts and timeframe are just random estimates as the exact amounts entirely depend on your current body fat %, diet, lifting routine, genetics, etc. I would say you'll always lose at least a little bit of muscle when cutting, but there's no reason you can't lose a vast majority of fat instead of muscle.