-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Has the PS5 already cemented itself as the worst Playstation generation in history?
- Thread starter analog_future
- Start date
David B
An Idiot
Not everybody reads the whole thread of posts. It's 31 pages man, not gonna read that long.
David B
An Idiot
Well you mine as well tell analog_future also then.
Xbox will dip after next generation, Sony will ride it as long as they can but I also agree they will eventually get out of the console market. Nintendo will never stop.
Guardian Monkey
Member
God of War Ragnarok > GOW3 -ok fine agreed
Horizon FW > Killzone 2/3 SP -fw sucked
Helldivers 2 > Killzone MP -agreed
Spiderman 2 > MGS4 - oh fuck off with this
Uncharted = AstroBot (different genres or whatever, just going by quality) ok I’ll go with Astro on this
Uncharted 2 -wins by default
Uncharted 3 -wins by default
Ratchet RA > ToD -ok sure agreed
Returnal > Resistance Series -agreed
Demons Souls > Lair, Heavenly Sword, whatever. -agreed
GT7 > GT5 -does anyone care?
Last of us- wins by default
6-5-1 in favor of PS5. There we have it PS5 is better in my opinion. Feel free to argue against my opinion as your opinion is right too!
Last edited:
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
No ones opinion is wrong, its their opinion to haveGod of War Ragnarok > GOW3 -ok fine agreed
Horizon FW > Killzone 2/3 SP -fw sucked
Helldivers 2 > Killzone MP -agreed
Spiderman 2 > MGS4 - oh fuck off with this
Uncharted = AstroBot (different genres or whatever, just going by quality) ok I’ll go with Astro on this
Uncharted 2 -wins by default
Uncharted 3 -wins by default
Ratchet RA > ToD -ok sure agreed
Returnal > Resistance Series -agreed
Demons Souls > Lair, Heavenly Sword, whatever. -agreed
GT7 > GT5 -does anyone care?
Last of us- wins by default
6-5-1 in favor of PS5. There we have it PS5 is better in my opinion. Feel free to argue against my opinion as your opinion is right too!
Guardian Monkey
Member
“Feel free to argue against my opinion as your opinion is right too!”
Isn’t that what I said
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
I was agreeing with you, not everyone here does that though“Feel free to argue against my opinion as your opinion is right too!”
Isn’t that what I said
Guardian Monkey
Member
Got it, my bad.I was agreeing with you, not everyone here does that though
VideoGameEnjoyer
Member
The hardware rules. I haven’t forgotten how annoying it was to play games with my PS4 sounding like a jet engine, even though I absolutely loved that console and generation.
The console is basically exactly what I wanted as an upgrade so I can’t call it a disappointment. The software we have gotten is pretty damn good for the most part. But the insane dev times and mistakes they’ve made with GaaS and such have definitely hurt. That being said, I still have more to play than I could ever complete and it’s a great machine to play games on. So overall, no.
The console is basically exactly what I wanted as an upgrade so I can’t call it a disappointment. The software we have gotten is pretty damn good for the most part. But the insane dev times and mistakes they’ve made with GaaS and such have definitely hurt. That being said, I still have more to play than I could ever complete and it’s a great machine to play games on. So overall, no.
Last edited:
Killjoy-NL
Member
Nobody is saying people can't have their opinion.I was agreeing with you, not everyone here does that though
But saying Sony 1st party output is somehow worse for PS5, when it's just like any other gen, is objectively false.
Whether or not people like their offering is subjective.
Last edited:
Bojji
Member
It's not like any other, you have multiple comparisons in this thread and PS5 loses to PS3:
Killjoy-NL
Member
You already got called out on your post in the replies right after it, on the same age, with multiple people pointing out you actually showed PS5 output has been on par, despite your cherrypicking.
So again, whether or not you like their output is subjective.
Last edited:
Bojji
Member
If you remove games that are also on PS4, PS5 is quite poor.
Also, years 2011-2013 were very good for PS3 while PS5 has barely anything launching from Sony (announced). Final comparison will be done in 2027 but it doesn't look too great for PS5 right now.
Killjoy-NL
Member
Moving goalposts.
Bojji
Member
PS3 games were only on PS3, PS5 and PS4 share some library.
Cross gen is also one of the things that makes PS5 library look weaker, same is true for pc ports for people like me. I haven't used PS5 since metaphor and I could play that on pc as well, I just wanted physical version...
Last edited:
Humdinger
Gold Member
That's true. The frame does set up a negative take on PS5, right off the bat. We might've gotten different results if the question were framed more objectively - e.g., "What do you consider the worst PS generation, judging by first-party games?"
Killjoy-NL
Member
To some extent, sure.
But output remains the same and it was on PS5.
If that wasn't worth buying a PS5 for, that could be a good reason.
If you bought a PS5 regardless, it shouldn't matter.
Last edited:
Mibu no ookami
Demoted Member® Pro™
Bojji does not think that Zelda and Mario Kart 8 being crossgen titles makes the Switch weaker... I promise you that.
Killjoy-NL
Member
If they would just say they don't like the games, there wouldn't be a discussion.
But some can't help but be disingenuous.
Mibu no ookami
Demoted Member® Pro™
Because they know they're good games.
Their primary argument is that the games are available on other devices whether they play better on PS5 is irrelevant. Whether the PS5 is more cost-effective is irrelevant.
No one is looking to play these cross gen games on PS4 at 1080p30... no one.. yet here they are pretending...
Killjoy-NL
Member
I think a lot has to do with the narrative that Sony's live service comes at the expense of singleplayer releases.
People convinced themselves this is the case as well.
Xbox 360 slim
Neo Member
I'm a playstation fan, and what I mean by that is, I'm a fan of playstation from 1995-2013. They died with the PS4. I still like Xbox. Sony just doesn't have that japanese magic they had. The CECHA01 PS3 is still the best PS ever made. 1 console, 8000 games.
Last edited:
Xbox 360 slim
Neo Member
Sony used to make video games. More so movie games nowadays. They used to be the variety console.
Last edited:
So sony still makes games confirmed.
This is akin to asking if anyone cares about 3D Mario games on Nintendo consoles.
Xbox 360 slim
Neo Member
More so interactive movies nowadays. Which is fine, but can we have something else?
Last edited:
Helldivers 2, Rise of the Ronin, Stellar Blade, Astro Bot, Gran Turismo 7...
Haven't you gotten the memo? We complain about GAAS now, movie games are a thing of the past.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
But it does though. Using the two most recent examples, both Bend and Bluepoint's last released projects were single player games. They both recently had their long gestating live service projects canceled.
Whatever they start on now will not see light of day for a few years, they might have some smaller scope things or remasters in the interim but their new full releases are definitely not coming any time soon.
Xbox 360 slim
Neo Member
Good points on Astro bot, forgot about that game. More of that please, sony.
I think I mentioned 4 other games as well, lol.
Killjoy-NL
Member
Overall singleplayer output so far has been on par with other gens, though.
That was my point.
But you've got a point there.
Last edited:
Fake
Member
Me too. Fanboys can post sales numbers whatever they want, still a very dissapointing generation.
Bojji
Member
I bought PS5 for Sony exclusives. It was 2021 and before they announced their plans for multiplatform releases. If I knew how dire their output will be and that most games will end up on PC I would skip this console.
Now I use it to play physical versions of games every few months and maybe some time exclusive from Sony in late 2025/early 2026. GTA6 maybe if PS5 version is ok? This is ridiculous.
Killjoy-NL
Member
Sony was talking about PC releases since 2019.
So if PC releases are an issue, that's on you.
Mibu no ookami
Demoted Member® Pro™
I think he is still referring to cross gen games here (though maybe both).
There's just not much intellectual honesty around it. Maybe his argument is that he feels he doesn't need a PS5 and could just play on PC. I think it's a fair argument if that's you preferred way of playing, but as you said, it was clear Sony was putting more games on PC well before he bought a PS5 to the point where I think he's acting as a massive troll.
Killjoy-NL
Member
Nah, he clearly expressed PC releases in the first part of his post.
If they make the PS5 unappealing for a PC gamer, that makes sense.
But implying you were mislead while Playstation already discussed it publicly for 2 years is disingenuous as well.
Last edited:
Bojji
Member
Yeah, you have games like Heavy Rain released years before but their current PC strategy started after I bought the console. That's for sure.
Both cross gen and PC ports make PS5 library look weaker for someone with PC/PS4. List of actual PS5 exclusives is here:
Doesn't look that great...
Killjoy-NL
Member
It was announced/made public in 2019 already:
"In an interview, Shawn Layden, chairman of Sony's game studios worldwide, said exclusive titles will still be a part of the company's strategy, but that some games — particularly multiplayer titles designed to be played on personal computers — may see broader distribution. 'We must support the PlayStation platform — that is non-negotiable,' Layden said. 'That said, you will see in the future some titles coming out of my collection of studios which may need to lean into a wider installed base.'
Multiplayer PlayStation games will come to PC and other devices says Sony's Shawn Layden
Wonder when they'll show up.
www.windowscentral.com
Last edited:
Bojji
Member
It was announced/made public in 2019 already:
"In an interview, Shawn Layden, chairman of Sony's game studios worldwide, said exclusive titles will still be a part of the company's strategy, but that some games — particularly multiplayer titles designed to be played on personal computers — may see broader distribution. 'We must support the PlayStation platform — that is non-negotiable,' Layden said. 'That said, you will see in the future some titles coming out of my collection of studios which may need to lean into a wider installed base.'
Multiplayer PlayStation games will come to PC and other devices says Sony's Shawn Layden
Wonder when they'll show up.
"Multiplayer games"
By Q1 2025 most of their single player games got ported...
PC ports are good for Sony and general audience but it also makes PS5 way less necessary FOR ME compared to PS3/PS4.
Killjoy-NL
Member
"in particular multiplayer games"
This statement alone implied singleplayer games were up for debate as well.
In march 2020, Hulst discussed the PC port for HZD in a Playstation Blog:
Hermen Hulst Q&A: Interview with Head of PlayStation’s Worldwide Studios
What's next for Guerrilla, upcoming TV and film projects, and the guiding principles that drive PlayStation’s network of world-class game studios.
blog.playstation.com
Anyway, making PS5 less appealing to you is fair, but you blame Sony for misleading you, which is entirely on you.
Bojji
Member
"in particular multiplayer games"
This statement alone implied singleplayer games were up for debate as well.
In march 2020, Hulst discussed the PC port for HZD in a Playstation Blog:
Hermen Hulst Q&A: Interview with Head of PlayStation’s Worldwide Studios
What's next for Guerrilla, upcoming TV and film projects, and the guiding principles that drive PlayStation’s network of world-class game studios.
Anyway, making PS5 less appealing to you is fair, but you blame Sony for misleading you, which is entirely on you.
I expected the same thing that they were doing with PS1-PS4, so for ~25 years. I didn't expect changes in strategy but here we are.
Killjoy-NL
Member
They told you for almost 2 years before you bought a PS5 though.
Mibu no ookami
Demoted Member® Pro™
Yeah, you have games like Heavy Rain released years before but their current PC strategy started after I bought the console. That's for sure.
Both cross gen and PC ports make PS5 library look weaker for someone with PC/PS4. List of actual PS5 exclusives is here:
Doesn't look that great...
More PlayStation First-Party Games to Come to PC, Including Days Gone This Spring - IGN
Following Horizon Zero Dawn's PC release, more PS4 exclusives are on the way to your computer - possibly starting with Days Gone.
February 2021...
Games being on other platforms doesn't make the platform you're playing on worse, especially previous generations. You're lying about not knowing that games were going to PC and you're disingenuous about cross gen.
You're trolling.
Mibu no ookami
Demoted Member® Pro™
LOL, Sony used to put a bunch of their games on PC during the PS1 era...
Bojji
Member
More PlayStation First-Party Games to Come to PC, Including Days Gone This Spring - IGN
Following Horizon Zero Dawn's PC release, more PS4 exclusives are on the way to your computer - possibly starting with Days Gone.www.ign.com
February 2021...
Games being on other platforms doesn't make the platform you're playing on worse, especially previous generations. You're lying about not knowing that games were going to PC and you're disingenuous about cross gen.
You're trolling.
You expected this scale of ports at the time? I remember that Sony fanboys were super triggered when more ports were announced. When I bought PS5 I only knew about HZD being released on PC, I missed the news about DG. Still, this was all few years old PS4 games. At the time no PS5 game was ported.
And what after that?
Negotiator
Member
"We do believe in generations, and whether it's the DualSense controller, whether it's the 3D audio, whether it's the multiple ways that the SSD can be used... we are thinking that it is time to give the PlayStation community something new, something different, that can really only be enjoyed on PS5."
Source (2020):
https://www.gamesindustry.biz/sonys...ing-that-can-only-be-enjoyed-on-playstation-5
'We believe in generations:' PlayStation argues cross-gen games risk stifling innovation
"In many cases, we can't take everybody with us from previous consoles into [a next-generation experience]. You need new hardware, you need new devices to experience what these developers want you to experience."
Last edited:
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll